What's new

No Rakhigarhi migration since Harappan era: Experts

Kashmiri Pandit

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 12, 2015
Messages
3,023
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
India
Three years after digging out human skeletons from the Harappan-era graveyard in Rakhigarhi village, archaeologists have concluded that there was no large-scale influx of foreigners or migration of locals, indicating those living in Haryana and the Ghaggar basin now are descendants of original inhabitants.

Prof Vasant Shinde, Vice Chancellor of Deccan College, Pune, said on Friday that the DNA analysis of 5,000-year-old skeletal remains belonging to the Indus Valley Civilisation revealed that there had been no migration from this region for the last 10,000 years.

“The Aryan invasion theories, stating that people from other countries arrived in India while locals migrated, are no longer relevant. There is no substance in these theories. Maybe the term Aryan, which is being used from the Vedic era, was used for a tribe or community,” he said. He asserted that they were saying this on the basis of actual data.

“We cannot depend only one source and must have complete information on the period to arrive at a conclusion. Our data has been analysed in two laboratories, Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad, and Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences, Lucknow. We are now getting the data cross-examined at Harvard University before publishing the paper in a research journal,” he said.

Professor Shinde stated that facial reconstruction and physical appearance of the skeletons had striking similarity with current inhabitants of Haryana and Punjab. He said facial reconstruction and pathological studies were being carried out in the Seoul National University College of Medicine in South Korea.

“The sharp facial features and build-up of Harappan skeletons and current inhabitants are identical. We can say that those who lived about 5,000 years ago in Haryana are the ancestors of the current population,” he maintained.

“We will soon make the findings public for the scrutiny of scientists. We have collected DNA samples of current inhabitants for matching these with Indus Valley Civilisation samples. We are looking into genetic similarities of Harappan and present-day population,” he stated.

He said they had extract DNA from three human skeletons while many other samples had got contaminated. “Climatic conditions in this region are not favourable for preservation of skeletons for long. Whatever we managed to extract provides very crucial information,” he said.

He reiterated that Rakhigarhi, spread over 550 hectares and divided into nine zones, had emerged as the metropolis of Harappan times, which was the hub of administration and trade. “People have trade relations with central Asia and there is a lot of evidence in Rakhigarhi to prove it,” he added.

http://www.tribuneindia.com/mobi/ne...ration-since-harappan-era-experts/606026.html
 
. . .
Three years after digging out human skeletons from the Harappan-era graveyard in Rakhigarhi village, archaeologists have concluded that there was no large-scale influx of foreigners or migration of locals, indicating those living in Haryana and the Ghaggar basin now are descendants of original inhabitants.

Prof Vasant Shinde, Vice Chancellor of Deccan College, Pune, said on Friday that the DNA analysis of 5,000-year-old skeletal remains belonging to the Indus Valley Civilisation revealed that there had been no migration from this region for the last 10,000 years.

“The Aryan invasion theories, stating that people from other countries arrived in India while locals migrated, are no longer relevant. There is no substance in these theories. Maybe the term Aryan, which is being used from the Vedic era, was used for a tribe or community,” he said. He asserted that they were saying this on the basis of actual data.

“We cannot depend only one source and must have complete information on the period to arrive at a conclusion. Our data has been analysed in two laboratories, Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad, and Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences, Lucknow. We are now getting the data cross-examined at Harvard University before publishing the paper in a research journal,” he said.

Professor Shinde stated that facial reconstruction and physical appearance of the skeletons had striking similarity with current inhabitants of Haryana and Punjab. He said facial reconstruction and pathological studies were being carried out in the Seoul National University College of Medicine in South Korea.

“The sharp facial features and build-up of Harappan skeletons and current inhabitants are identical. We can say that those who lived about 5,000 years ago in Haryana are the ancestors of the current population,” he maintained.

“We will soon make the findings public for the scrutiny of scientists. We have collected DNA samples of current inhabitants for matching these with Indus Valley Civilisation samples. We are looking into genetic similarities of Harappan and present-day population,” he stated.

He said they had extract DNA from three human skeletons while many other samples had got contaminated. “Climatic conditions in this region are not favourable for preservation of skeletons for long. Whatever we managed to extract provides very crucial information,” he said.

He reiterated that Rakhigarhi, spread over 550 hectares and divided into nine zones, had emerged as the metropolis of Harappan times, which was the hub of administration and trade. “People have trade relations with central Asia and there is a lot of evidence in Rakhigarhi to prove it,” he added.

http://www.tribuneindia.com/mobi/ne...ration-since-harappan-era-experts/606026.html


Ahem,
sure sure.

Stand a Kashmiri pandit next to Tamil pandit, and say there wasn't a migration.
 
.
Bhirana is the oldest Harappan site, and the Rakhigarhi is the largest. Both these sites are located in Haryana. So it's quite possible that the people who migrated west afterwards are the descendents of the Haryanvi people.
 
. . .
These guys should concentrate on releasing the full study for public reading instead of giving one liners to the press to make the ingrates feel good about themselves.

I will accept it when I see evidence of it.
 
.
Three years after digging out human skeletons from the Harappan-era graveyard in Rakhigarhi village, archaeologists have concluded that there was no large-scale influx of foreigners or migration of locals, indicating those living in Haryana and the Ghaggar basin now are descendants of original inhabitants.

Prof Vasant Shinde, Vice Chancellor of Deccan College, Pune, said on Friday that the DNA analysis of 5,000-year-old skeletal remains belonging to the Indus Valley Civilisation revealed that there had been no migration from this region for the last 10,000 years.

“The Aryan invasion theories, stating that people from other countries arrived in India while locals migrated, are no longer relevant. There is no substance in these theories. Maybe the term Aryan, which is being used from the Vedic era, was used for a tribe or community,” he said. He asserted that they were saying this on the basis of actual data.

“We cannot depend only one source and must have complete information on the period to arrive at a conclusion. Our data has been analysed in two laboratories, Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad, and Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences, Lucknow. We are now getting the data cross-examined at Harvard University before publishing the paper in a research journal,” he said.

Professor Shinde stated that facial reconstruction and physical appearance of the skeletons had striking similarity with current inhabitants of Haryana and Punjab. He said facial reconstruction and pathological studies were being carried out in the Seoul National University College of Medicine in South Korea.

“The sharp facial features and build-up of Harappan skeletons and current inhabitants are identical. We can say that those who lived about 5,000 years ago in Haryana are the ancestors of the current population,” he maintained.

“We will soon make the findings public for the scrutiny of scientists. We have collected DNA samples of current inhabitants for matching these with Indus Valley Civilisation samples. We are looking into genetic similarities of Harappan and present-day population,” he stated.

He said they had extract DNA from three human skeletons while many other samples had got contaminated. “Climatic conditions in this region are not favourable for preservation of skeletons for long. Whatever we managed to extract provides very crucial information,” he said.

He reiterated that Rakhigarhi, spread over 550 hectares and divided into nine zones, had emerged as the metropolis of Harappan times, which was the hub of administration and trade. “People have trade relations with central Asia and there is a lot of evidence in Rakhigarhi to prove it,” he added.

http://www.tribuneindia.com/mobi/ne...ration-since-harappan-era-experts/606026.html
Indian modi gov funded research by gov employed researchers about an issue which is very sensitive to hindutva nationalist
Kind of like job given to german resarchrese but Hitler to prove they r decent of pure Aryan whom themselves came from lost Continent of atlantis
 
.
5,000 years ago in Haryana
Interesting. So what happened to the "Pakistan came into existence in 1947" that Indians have adopted as a mantra? Haryana only came into existence in 1966.

Revisionism at its finest
More "Horseplay in Harappa"?

https://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1720/17200040.htm


These guys should concentrate on releasing the full study for public reading instead of giving one liners to the press to make the ingrates feel good about themselves.
They won't do that. This way they get to create a perception that equates a ancient civilization with India. As long as that perception sticks they have succeeded. You know the dictum "lie enough times and it will become accepted as fact".


And so it happens that Indians have managed to pull the foci of the IVC from the Indus, Pakistan deep into India in Haryana.


w4PxGTY.png



sHGmwYE.jpg
 
.
Interesting. So what happened to the "Pakistan came into existence in 1947" that Indians have adopted as a mantra? Haryana only came into existence in 1966.

More "Horseplay in Harappa"?

https://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1720/17200040.htm


They won't do that. This way they get to create a perception that equates a ancient civilization with India. As long as that perception sticks they have succeeded. You know the dictum "lie enough times and it will become accepted as fact".


And so it happens that Indians have managed to pull the foci of the IVC from the Indus, Pakistan deep into India in Haryana.


w4PxGTY.png



sHGmwYE.jpg

I find this all quite amusing that, even with whatever they are trying to pull, they have instantly killed the mantra of the folks from South and East of India who consistency have screamed that the original inhabitants of IVC moved to where they are and the Pakistanis are invaders with this gem, especially since the populations of North West India, and Punjab/Haryana in particular, closely resemble the population on the western side of the Wagah border, (yes we do need to wait and see how true their claim is):

Professor Shinde stated that facial reconstruction and physical appearance of the skeletons had striking similarity with current inhabitants of Haryana and Punjab. He said facial reconstruction and pathological studies were being carried out in the Seoul National University College of Medicine in South Korea.

“The sharp facial features and build-up of Harappan skeletons and current inhabitants are identical. We can say that those who lived about 5,000 years ago in Haryana are the ancestors of the current population,” he maintained.
 
.
Bhirana is the oldest Harappan site, and the Rakhigarhi is the largest. Both these sites are located in Haryana. So it's quite possible that the people who migrated west afterwards are the descendents of the Haryanvi people.

it was sarswati valley civilization never indus valley civilization the harappan sites also falls near sarswati path , the great river which is worshipped in vedas had a path through modern himachal, Indian panjab, Haryana, Rajyasthan, Gujrat
 
. . .
Ok, let us do that.

Can you tell me which one is a Kashmiri pandit and which one is a Tamil pandit ?

ganesh-venkatraman-nisha-krishnan-wedding-pictures-photos-stills-68.jpg


Sridevi-Vidya-Balan-Tumhari-Sulu.jpg

Good,

Now try to ask yourself,
what percentage of south indian dravidians look like those movie stars.

Why is it, that Dravidian like to fantasize with faces, that do not have any resemblance to 99% of them ?

Why does fair and lovely sell so much in Hindu-stan.

Tell me why ?
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom