What's new

Navy had warned government about 'vulnerable' state of submarines in 2010

Brahmos_2

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Feb 19, 2013
Messages
1,412
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
New Delhi:The Indian Navy had repeatedly warned the government since 2010 that the poor state of its submarine division, both operationally and in terms of number of vessels, leaves India very vulnerable to attacks by sea.

In a confidential report to the Prime Minister's Office and the Defence Ministry, the Navy had expressed concern that by 2015, India would be at its lowest submarine capability ever. This means that by next year, India's sub-surface strength and anti-access capability in the Indian Ocean region will be its worst ever.

The Naval Headquarters, sources said, has reiterated that every year, but nothing has moved on new acquisitions.
India's current submarine strength is precarious - it has only seven conventional subs. It needs a full fleet of at least 15 subs, including new vessels and older ones refitted.

As of now, even if matters are fast-tracked, the country can only begin acquiring news subs by the end of 2015 or early 2016, sources said. Six Scorpene submarines are being built at Mazgaon Docks but the first one will be available only by 2015-end or early 2016 at the earliest.

In more worry, even as this critical capability has eroded, there has been an increase in both submarine strength and capacity of the Pakistan Navy and that of the Chinese PLA Navy. The sorry state of India's submarines was tragically illustrated this week when two officers were killed and seven sailors injured in a fire on the 25-year-old INS Sindhuratna while it was being sea tested after being refitted without replacing the old batteries

Navy chief Admiral DK Joshi, in an unprecedented move, resigned the same evening, taking moral responsibility of this and a series of other accidents that took place on his watch.

In August last year, a dockside blast had killed all 18 sailors aboard another submarine, the INS Sindhurakshak. There have been eight other mishaps, mostly minor, involving Navy assets in recent months.

Navy had warned government about 'vulnerable' state of submarines in 2010 | NDTV.com
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Why do we need submarines...???We are having the blessings of 'Edvige Antonia Albina Màino' ..:hitwall::hitwall:

Goddess-sonia-statue-story_1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Ofcourse Congies did nothing...how could they...its not like they would do anything good for the nation
 
Now how can we deal with this situation
First thing being done is leasing a second Akula II class sub for 1.5 Billion USD
India likely to acquire another nuclear-powered submarine from Russia on lease - The Times of India
Now thanks to the sensitive nature of the deal, it is unlikely to be openly announced, but it is believed that final negotiations had taken place when Manmohan went to Russia in october,
However we are likely to get this sub only in 2018-19
Scorpenes will start coming in 2016
INS Arihant will enter service either by end of this yr or early next yr
INS Arhidaman will enter service in 2018

The first Kilo class Sub to be retired will be INS Sindhudhvaj inducted in 1987, which will retire in 2015 or whenever Arihant enters service
I expect another 4 Kilo and Type 209 Subs will be retired between 2016-21, these will be replaced by scorpenes

in short their is a likelihood that IN will be left with 4 Kilos, 2 Type 209, 6 Scorpenes by 2021
Add to that possibly 2 Akula and 3 Arihant

I believe that India should take up DCNS offer of to provide 2 Scorpene subs on emergency basis
DCNS can deliver them by 2018, which should provide some relief to the indian navy
Defence News - France Offers 2 off-the-shelf Scorpene Submarines to India
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom