Nadeem F Paracha insults Allama Iqbal.

[M. Sarmad]

Has he criticized Allama Iqbal before?

Other critics have also criticized Iqbal`s Shaheen as it is a symbol of force and ferocity , He is not the first one . I wonder why no one here is actually trying to discuss Iqbal`s view and disprove NFP .

 

[Luftwaffe]

Dude that is old talk. muslims will be judged under secular laws of the world!

I don't a damn about secular and non secular carefully study western laws they are all derived and close to what Quran has..just study them you get justice fro western law than eastern. I believe you meant secular mindset.

 

[Kompromat]

Yeah i searched it , I know Maulana moududi
By Aero's reaction i thought he was referring to some jin type bala or something

I have Ziltch respect for Maulana Maudidi. The reason for my outrage is that this hobo, compared Iqbal to Maudidi. They belong to two different universes.

I don't a damn about secular and non secular carefully study western laws they are all derived and close to what Quran has..just study them you get justice fro western law than eastern. I believe you meant secular mindset.

I think he was being sarcastic.

 

[M. Sarmad]

He's a crypto marxist, self hating, drug addicted anarchist.

Annemarie Schimmel, a famous scholar, pointed out that Muhammad Iqbal “… has been regarded as the unsurpassable master of every virtue and art; he has been made a forerunner of socialism or an advocate of Marxism; he was anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist .... "

 

[EyanKhan]

I have Ziltch respect for Maulana Maudidi. The reason for my outrage is that this hobo, compared Iqbal to Maudidi. They belong to two different universes.

Iqbal is a very complex personality as are all Philosophers.
Poets Ignite a hope inside of you , show you the best inside of you , create a picture of the best you can be.

Iqbal as a poet did that , He asked the muslims to stretch the realities of time.

Just think of a poet asking people to be mediocre robots , nobody would have given him a sec of their time.
Comparison with Moudodi was incorrect of him , but he has a right to his view. Also to remember the political ground realities can change drastically with time. Our time was very different from Iqbal's time so perhaps some differences might be there for some people.

He has every right to his opinion though being a professional (atleast thats what they say he is) He should have picked a better choice of words.

Annemarie Schimmel, a famous scholar, pointed out that Muhammad Iqbal “… has been regarded as the unsurpassable master of every virtue and art; he has been made a forerunner of socialism or an advocate of Marxism; he was anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist .... "

Nice catch bro
It annoys me how people just blame everything on Marxists/commies , left-wingers

 

[SHAMK9]

Who is this asshole?

 

[Multani]

Other critics have also criticized Iqbal`s Shaheen as it is a symbol of force and ferocity , He is not the first one . I wonder why no one here is actually trying to discuss Iqbal`s view and disprove NFP .

Let's discuss Allamah Iqbal's views. in sha Allah

Allamah Iqbal derived his religious teachings from prominent scholars of India. One of them is Shaykh Jamat Ali Shah. He is also the scholar of Sialkot that Qaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah asked for support for the creation of Pakistan.

 

[Informant]

Chill man, he has his rights to mock anyone. Move along, the problem with Pakis is they make mountains out of molehills.

 

[Kompromat]

Annemarie Schimmel, a famous scholar, pointed out that Muhammad Iqbal “… has been regarded as the unsurpassable master of every virtue and art; he has been made a forerunner of socialism or an advocate of Marxism; he was anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist .... "

Thats her personal opinion and i am yet to find a shred of evidence from Iqbal's work that may have Marxist undertones. Marxism is a political blanket for atheists, Iqbal is the furthest thing away from it. I am not sure how did she reach this absurd conclusion.

 

[EyanKhan]

Let's discuss Allamah Iqbal's views. in sha Allah

Allamah Iqbal derived his religious teachings from prominent scholars of India. One of them is Shaykh Jamat Ali Shah. He is also the scholar of Sialkot that Qaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah asked for support for the creation of Pakistan.

Interesting to note as well , as many "Islamic" scholars were against Pak's creation , saying that Quaid-e-Azam wanted to create a modern secular/moderate state rather then a nation for muslims.

 

[Kompromat]

Chill man, he has his rights to mock anyone. Move along, the problem with Pakis is they make mountains out of molehills.

We have the right to blast his pigface in a way we see fit!

 

[Ghareeb_Da_Baal]

Who is this asshole?

he is the leader of 1% libtard gang that wants to make decisions for you just like ttpeeeeeee

 

[jha]

Its his point of view. I think he is referring to the way the term Iqbal's shaheen is being misused for sinister purposes these days. I might be wrong though. But NFP should also have the right to be wrong.

 

[M. Sarmad]

Thats her personal opinion and i am yet to find a shred of evidence from Iqbal's work that may have Marxist undertones. Marxism is a political blanket for atheists, Iqbal is the furthest thing away from it. I am not sure how did she reach this absurd conclusion.

Sir g do you know , In Javednama Iqbal generously praises Marx, giving him the highest status that a person could aspire to, short of prophet-hood. ... ??? But right now you are in a bad mood . We will discuss it some other time ....

 

[Luftwaffe]

Here for an idiot NFP who can't really understand Iqbal.

People who have no hold over their process of thinking are likely to be ruined by liberty of thought. If thought is immmature, liberty of though becomes a method of converting men into animals.

M. Iqbal