Samudra
SENIOR MEMBER
![](/styles/default/xenforo/ranks/Lieutenant.jpg)
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2006
- Messages
- 887
- Reaction score
- 0
The locals were not wiped out, indeed even the culture was not wiped out considering Hinduism exist to this day
AM.
I think you just mentioned the problem. Hindu's exist.
As much as we have some noticeable Muslim rulers of the sub-continent a vast majority of them were always not so pleasant when dealing the native 'Hindu' population. The damn name 'Hindu' was given by the Persians and the Muslims cemented it. They inadvertently instilled a sense of belonging to one religion amongst the perpetually divided sub-continental society of idol worshiping kaffirs. With temples being deconstructed and made into mosques on a regular basis - the 'Hindu' religion was strengthened. But for the Muslims butchering kaffirs this unity would not have come around.
The Hindu narrative came about and it will only be a whine fest full of gory stories about how aliens came about to destroy what was theirs. The Hindu - whatever he maybe, survives and identifies himselves as the victim of so many centuries of alien rule.
I'll give you a good example. Have you ever wondered why many north Indian rural women hide themselves in the goonghat? The Rajputs and many other communities had to save their women from the prying eyes of aliens. Have you heard about the story of Padmini ? She was the Hindu women who committed jauhar to escape a Muslim King's lust. The Rajputs are a proud people and they won't forget the story about Padmini. The story will have to remind them that the Mughals came from Central Asia and went after their native land and women. I know exactly after which Hindu's dynasty's fall (400 years ago) my tribe migrated down south, the rivers we crossed and kings who helped us en route, how we did manage to protest our idols. I know at least three other friends of mine who remember their family story - even after migration all the way from Gujarat to South India, 300 years before.
In Europe - the pagan or druid or whatever does not exist. They were finished off and absorbed into Christianity.
In India - the Hindu exists and he happens to remember - through stories of Shivaji, Padmini and traditions such as goonghat and jhauri, the persecution he underwent. It is natural he feels not too well towards the Muslim.
Has that translated into ridiculous persecution of Muslims or 'aliens' ? Thankfully, we've had enough sense to act civilized AND more importantly we found a enemy in the form of Pakistan. Pakistan - the punching bag!
All the anger towards 'aliens' built up by oral narratives of persecution passed down through the centuries found a convenient vent through Pakistan - a state for the Muslims.
When the partition was being talked about fundamentalists on both the sides imagined that their job was unfinished. The Hindu radicals wanted Muslims finished. The Muslim mullahs wanted Hindu's finished. That is perhaps one of the reasons why both of them wanted an undivided India.
But for Kashmir some form of reconciliation could've occurred and the Hindu might have slowly forgotten. Kashmir led to renewed enmity which the politicians did fan through religious fundamentalism - I speak of both Islamic and Hindu parties on both sides of border.
For my country - I'm glad we've turned out into what we have. We continue to carry forward the Indus Valley Civilization and what not. Pakistan could've turned out fine but for Kashmir.
As you said - its all part of the evolution. The rivalry included.
What does get my goat though is some Sindhi or Punjabi gloating about Hindustani's getting massacred by Mussalman warriors from Central Asia. That individual forgets that in the list of those who were given the jhappad his forefathers name appears first! Why, your nation state has in itself forgotten the fact and goes on to glorify Afghans with very silly names for its missiles.