Muslims ‘are Britain’s top charity givers’

[Steve781]

Do non-Muslims give to Muslims though? If you harbor such hatred for Muslims why are you on PDF?



If i may correct you bhai, Zakat is NOT tax. It is a pillar of Islam and the nearest English definition is 'obligatory charity'. There is tax in Islamic Economics but this is has nothing to do with it.

I was asking a question.If you look at the websites of organisations like Muslim Aid and Islamic Relief and the list of countries that they operate in, in many cases some very poor countries like Haiti, Zimbabwe or Cambodia where there are very few Muslims are excluded.

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

and it is a matter b/t Person and his Creator

Yes it is a matter between Allah and the person. However, zakat collection is the duty of the Islamic state from those living in the Islamic land. As there is NO Islamic State today, like you said it is a duty of the individuals to discharge their duty to Allah.

I know this is what you said, but I'm mentioning this for those who don't know.

 

[Leviza]

I was asking a question.If you look at the websites of organisations like Muslim Aid and Islamic Relief and the list of countries that they operate in, in many cases some very poor countries like Haiti, Zimbabwe or Cambodia where there are very few Muslims are excluded.

Yes, Muslim do give charity to non Muslim orgs as well. I worked myself voluntary for few non muslims charity orgs when i can spare some time ..

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

I was asking a question.If you look at the websites of organisations like Muslim Aid and Islamic Relief and the list of countries that they operate in, in many cases some very poor countries like Haiti, Zimbabwe or Cambodia where there are very few Muslims are excluded.

Sir, English is not my language, but the way you wrote the sentence was clear what you meant. With respect to the online donations, they are ALWAYS seeking money for 3rd World countries as the money goes further.

Muslims living in their country like Britania, Amrka or any other Christendom state give sadaqa (charity) to help their fellow countrymen is no big deal, what do they want a prize for discharging their duty to Allah and the poor?

Itni nafrat

Bas car!

 

[livingdead]

If this includes charity they are obliged to give due to religion, then most of it goes to their own people. Some of it goes to islamic charity orgs and some of these orgs do help non muslims.

The article does not even mention hindus, in my experience hindus are stingy(gujjus definitely are), unless its to build some some temple.

 

[Steve781]

Yes, Muslim do give charity to non Muslim orgs as well. I worked myself voluntary for few non muslims charity orgs when i can spare some time ..

Good for you. Like I said, it was just a question.

 

[Jaanbaz]

If this includes charity they are obliged to give due to religion, then most of it goes to their own people. Some of it goes to islamic charity orgs and some of these orgs do help non muslims.

The article does not even mention hindus, in my experience hindus are stingy(gujjus definitely are), unless its to build some some temple.

South Asians are stingy usually, Muslims only donate because its religious duty. I wonder how many check which charity the money is going towards. The best charity is to donate to local community, there are plenty of people in UK who could do with new clothes and food.

 

[Leviza]

Good for you. Like I said, it was just a question.

Yes i know it was just a question, but do you mind answering the same question other way round ?

have you ever donated to or worked for Muslim charity Org ? i mean that will build some bridges ...

 

[Kambojaric]

Do they give to non Muslims though?

Muslim Aid launches Emergency Appeal to help victims of Nepal earthquake - Muslim Aid

 

[Zibago]

Sir, English is not my language, but the way you wrote the sentence was clear what you meant. With respect to the online donations, they are ALWAYS seeking money for 3rd World countries as the money goes further.

Muslims living in their country like Britania, Amrka or any other Christendom state give sadaqa (charity) to help their fellow countrymen is no big deal, what do they want a prize for discharging their duty to Allah and the poor?



Bas car!

That is a valid question

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

a number of muslims in Britain live off the govt welfare. that's public money of non-muslims.

Listen Hindustani if you wanted to be on the table be generous and stop trolling! On a minor point, they're entitled to the welfare if they get it.

That is a valid question

No, it is not. I don't question their loyalty to Pakistan, as they are Pakistani. As you know our Azad Kashmir is Qadiyani-free and I've never met or seen one in person. I don't hate them, and the Ulima-ikram say we don't accept them as Muslims, but we don't hurt or harm them as per Islamic law.

If you're being the thekdar of them, then tell them to humble themselves and stop being abusive. Go and check their insulting comments. We are Kashmiri, not Palestinians if they think we'll take their abuse.

 

[Curious_Guy]

As you know our Azad Kashmir is Qadiyani-free e.

I thought there are many communities of Qadiyanis in Kashmir

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

I thought there are many communities of Qadiyanis in Kashmir

I live in Mirpur, Azad Kashmir and never seen or met one.

 

[Curious_Guy]

I live in Mirpur, Azad Kashmir and never seen or met one.

Its because they are also humans and dont have any peculiar difference in appearence .

 

[Zibago]

Listen Hindustani if you wanted to be on the table be generous and stop trolling! On a minor point, they're entitled to the welfare if they get it.



No, it is not. I don't question their loyalty to Pakistan, as they are Pakistani. As you know our Azad Kashmir is Qadiyani-free and I've never met or seen one in person. I don't hate them, and the Ulima-ikram say we don't accept them as Muslims, but we don't hurt or harm them as per Islamic law.

If you're being the thekdar of them, then tell them to humble themselves and stop being abusive. Go and check their insulting comments. We are Kashmiri, not Palestinians if they think we'll take their abuse.

What abuse crying when they are treated as third rate citizens?
We tell west to not generalize all muslims due to actions of a few amd you are painting all mirzais with the same brush

I live in Mirpur, Azad Kashmir and never seen or met one.

There is a small population of Mirzais in Kotli and i find it hard to believe there are mirzais in Kotli and Gujrat and non in Mirpur