Merging Afghanistan With Pakistan

[Marshmallow]

God Save Pakistan

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Afghanistan has already merged with Pakistan. Half of Afghanistan is already in Pakistan. We have been invaded and taken over by millions of unarmed Afghans. This has happened and most Pakistanis havn't even noticed.

 

[Max]

Pakistan dont need Afghanistan for anything, Taliban may target Isb instead of Kabul if this wet dream realize. But this move can also stop proxy wars b/w Pakistan and Afghanistan. Afghans may need us, they can get Pak army support, so its upto them, what they want, Afghan can freely use Karachi and Gawadar ports. @A-Team what do you think about United states of Pakistan and Afghanistan?

 

[RealNapster]

It would be better if we merge India and Afghanistan together, into Pakistan with Islamabad as its capital...!

 

[Irfan Baloch]

@Irfan Baloch @Hyperion @Icarus @MilSpec

x and y are equal aren't they? there is a maths theorem on it.

 

[mikkix]

If and if anything may happen then I think merging of both countries must be done peacefully. Otherwise afghanis have a history to invade and ruled southasia and Pakistan. If india helps afghans then afghan invasion of pakistan is on cards in our life time.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

Extended KPK all the way to the Pakhtoon belt inside Afghanistan. That's more or less all of southern Afghanistan. All pakhtoons need to come under the wings of Pakistan. With regards to the Northern Afghanistan, they are the farsawan lot, I would keep them at arms length if I have to be brutally honest.

 

[volatile]

Sooner or later it will be Inshallah not merger but under United Federation ,but current time demands we should first stabilize our relationship thru mutual respect ,honour and benefit .

 

[Path-Finder]

We can call the union Ashikistan.

 

[Shapur]

Yes, as long as we have clear states with within the union such as European Union. We can have Kashmir, Punjab, Sindh, Pashtunistan, Balochistan etc. Get rid of Urdu as national language. All these states should have their own language as the national and we can communicate with each other in English as we already do. This will ensure the survival of local languages and cultures and get rid of resentment some people have regarding the threat to their language and culture. I would add Tajikistan to this Union as well. We can sign a common defence pact like NATO etc.

Given the current state of affairs this will not be possible as Afghanistan needs another 30 years of peace but maybe in the future.

 

[Shapur]

we should not just stop there but have all the Muslim nations of the Indian ocean join the federation it would make us a true super power.

@Shapur are you Pashtun afghan or Tajik would you be willing to merge with Pakistan with all or some of afghanistan

I am Pashtun from Northern Afghanistan originally so I can speak both languages.

Ofcourse I mean all of Afghanistan but not under the current status quo. Northern Afghanistan plus Tajikistan can be named Khorasan.
Ofcourse the more countries the better but one has to start somewhere and lead by example so others can follow.

 

[Tiger Genie]

I think it is a good idea. Afghans are good people but Afghanistan is under constant blackmail by Pakistan. In turn, Pakistanis have no clue how to be a responsible nation, so Afghans can help with that.India and Iran should help bring this about.

 

[Icarus]

invade as much as Iran as possible and take the oil.

And that would obviously carry no repercussions for us, right? With such myopic plans, your federation would probably end up declaring war on itself.

 

[Kompromat]

Something like this: https://defence.pk/threads/afpak-administrative-union-an-ultimate-peacemaker.180112/

Yes, as long as we have clear states with within the union such as European Union. We can have Kashmir, Punjab, Sindh, Pashtunistan, Balochistan etc. Get rid of Urdu as national language. All these states should have their own language as the national and we can communicate with each other in English as we already do. This will ensure the survival of local languages and cultures and get rid of resentment some people have regarding the threat to their language and culture. I would add Tajikistan to this Union as well. We can sign a common defence pact like NATO etc.

Given the current state of affairs this will not be possible as Afghanistan needs another 30 years of peace but maybe in the future.

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Get rid of Urdu as national language. All these states should have their own language as the national and we can communicate with each other in English as we already do. This will ensure the survival of local languages and cultures and get rid of resentment some people have regarding the threat to their language and culture.

Sorry....Millions of Pakistanis, spread all over Pakistan and the world disagree with you......STRONGLY.

Regional languages are good, Urdu is better. The man who carved out Pakistan in Sub Continent, Mr. Jinnah, was not stupid as your post implies. He was intelligent and possessed personality. People here still dream/think of him.