Many Jewish people descend from ethnicities of ancient Europe, study says

[Anubis]

Ashkenazis have both European ancestry and Semitic ancestry, what is surprising in that. As far I know, Judaism don't allow conversion, its only allow it by ancestry.

Judaism definitely allows conversion.Converts are called 'ger' in Hebrew!

Well the theory is a little diverse,it depends on who's telling the story,in some parts the West are Saudi puppets because of arab money

Anyway there's a new one now:americans are going to leave the ME after they make amends with Iran,Saudis + their gulf allies will become best friends with Israel to smash Iran.How do you like this one ?

What do you mean the US in leaving ME??Where are we gonna send the soldiers to??Australia??

 

[flamer84]

What do you mean the US in leaving ME??Where are we gonna send the soldiers to??Australia??

This was a discussion/theory i've heard this morning on a romanian blog,according to them,due to the fact that the USA is slowly breaking free of fuel dependence from the ME and some cut backs to the military they're going to focus only on the Pacific theatre and the containing of China leaving the ME to it's faith.

I don't buy it though.

 

[Archdemon]

So it defeated their whole claim to 'Jewishness' or their claim to ancient Israel. They don't actually have linage with ancient Israel.

That doesn't stop them from repeating the same old lies over and over again. The foreigners should have had their state in Britain or in Uganda as they originally had planned.

By they chose a path of irresponsibility and brutal force to manage their own state in the mandate of Palestine. As those Jewish paramilitaries tied to political parties did without permission and long before an Israeli state was created.

This is accurate history that most people today ignore. They ignore the aftermath, just as yourself people how a small portion of the population had overwhelming control over significant amounts of the land.

But neither from Uganda.

 

[Archdemon]

Everybody migrated from Africa straight to India and from there to the rest of the world ?? Colour me surprised



Everybody migrated from Africa straight to India and from there to the rest of the world ?? Colour me surprised

it also can be said everybody migrated to Saudi Arabia and then to the rest of the world,

 

[flamer84]

it also can be said everybody migrated to Saudi Arabia and then to the rest of the world,

I can buy that (altough with a big if) because the Arabian Peninsula was closest to Africa but why didn't they go from the Arabian peninsula in all corners of the word directly ? It was a land mass...look at the darts,they go to India and only from there they actually come back again to the ME and the rest of the world.Confusing.

 

[Archdemon]

Ashkenazis have both European ancestry and Semitic ancestry, what is surprising in that. As far I know, Judaism don't allow conversion, its only allow it by ancestry.

Judaism just like Christianity and Islam has sects/streams, Conservative Judaism, Orthodox Judaism, Reform Judaism, Progressive Judaism, Humanistic Judaism etc. Some of streams allow and recognize conversion to Judaism.

 

[rmi5]

I can buy that (altough with a big if) because the Arabian Peninsula was closest to Africa but why didn't they go from the Arabian peninsula in all corners of the word directly ? It was a land mass...look at the darts,they go to India and only from there they actually come back again to the ME and the rest of the world.Confusing.

It seems that those early humans had not been evolved too much from monkeys and they had a low IQ
OR, maybe some Indian guy wanted to show human beings starts from India

 

[HAIDER]

According to history the Bani Israel tribe was dark in skin and curly hair....

 

[Umair Nawaz]

@ 500

See this was what is was saying now even studies agree with my stance.

Quran doesnt say what u claim.

 

[HAIDER]

I saw a video on utube may be a "conspiracy" theory ? it was abt islam being created by the Vatican to capture the Jewish settlement. n thats why qur'an says jews r filthiest than pigs n donkeys. but Christians as the misguided ones ??? where am I going in this religious world! !!

Read the Quran, it never said that, you are twisting the facts...

 

[flamer84]

I saw a video on utube may be a "conspiracy" theory ? it was abt islam being created by the Vatican to capture the Jewish settlement. n thats why qur'an says jews r filthiest than pigs n donkeys. but Christians as the misguided ones ??? where am I going in this religious world! !!

What ? ???
Actually the christians want the temple to be built,therefore we want Isreal in control, as we believe that it will lead to the return of Jesus.The way we act on it it's different,we ,the ortodox do not interfere because we believe God will make things happen while Bible nutters from the West actively support Israel to build the temple ,which is wrong,causing violence to fulfill the prophecy is not the way of Christianity.

 

[Archdemon]

I can buy that (altough with a big if) because the Arabian Peninsula was closest to Africa but why didn't they go from the Arabian peninsula in all corners of the word directly ? It was a land mass...look at the darts,they go to India and only from there they actually come back again to the ME and the rest of the world.Confusing.

The main reasons for human migration is search for recourses(food), weather/natural disasters and tribal disputes/war. I will go crazy on this one, maybe they were following shoreline? look at the map.

 

[Hussein]

According to history the Bani Israel tribe was dark in skin and curly hair....

ramses II?

 

[al-Hasani]

Well, it is hardly news that the Ashkenazi Jews (Jews from Central and Eastern Europe) are heavily mixed with the local populations there or at least partially. But it depends which study you look at.

What is certain is that the Mizrahi Jews (Jews from Arab lands) and Sephardic Jews are more likely to be "genuine" Jews and Semitic than at least a large portion of the Ashkenazi Jews. At the other hand I have also seen DNA studies done on Ashkenazi Jews that show a surprisingly big genetic connection to us Arabs and other Semites living in the ME. Appearance (your phenotype) and your DNA are two distinct things. So physical appearance tells little.

Anyway the Palestinian Arabs (despite them not being homogenous either - who is that in the ME region or the world for that matter?) have a bigger claim of being pure Semites/natives to the region than European looking (or at least sometimes) Ashkenazi Jews with roots to Belarus, Poland, Ukraine, Romania, Russia etc. I struggle to see how anyone can have doubts about that. Especially given the DNA studies conducted in this modern age.

That is why I find the obsessiveness of Zionists and their logic of them having a "God-given" right to something that they in reality have no genetic/ancestral ties to absolutely hilarious. Oh, and Judaism puts GREAT emphasis on ancestry.



Regarding the out of Africa theory then that is pretty much a certain theory until now. The same with the first human migrations being to the Arabian Peninsula and from there on to the remaining world.

 

[anonymus]

What is this chart and why are romanians shown to come from India ?

Actually,why are all europeans shown to come from India ? Why is there a Romania in the Caucasus? Why are romanians shown like some ancestors of italians and spaniards ? I call BS on this map.

That is not a map which genographic project has published.

https://genographic.nationalgeographic.com/human-journey/