BelligerentPacifist
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2007
- Messages
- 2,238
- Reaction score
- 0
Why don't I see anything wrong in his statement? :/
I see a problem. The Madinanite model has to be preceded by a Maccan model, which is the model of rijaal saazii / mardum saazii - 'building men'. Where are the men who would effect the change that the Madinanite phase entailed.
Also, I think, and wAllaahua3lam, that the Madinanite phase was taufiiqiiyah i.e. it was miraculously delivered unto humanity by Providence. Why would some men come seek knowledge from a community that was being persecuted, ridiculed and openly murdered in Makkah and go back and the quasi-entire city of Madiinah turn Muslim in absentia of the original Maccan community (bar the sole Maccan in Madiinah MuS3ab bin 3umayr R. A.).