What's new

Is this the end of Islamic State in Bangladesh?

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
9,641
Reaction score
-1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Is this the end of Islamic State in Bangladesh?

There are indications that al-Adnani was indeed the principal patron or sponsor of ISIS operations in Bangladesh

This is the big news of the day – Abu Muhammad al-Adnani, the second most senior leader of the Islamic State (ISIS) is dead. According to latest reports, al-Adnani was killed in a US air strike near the town of al-Bab in Northern Syria on Tuesday. As he was the the chief spokesman and propagandist of the group, he was often described as “the voice of ISIS.” However, as Rukmini Callimachi of The New York Times (NYT) notes on Twitter, “[al-Adnani] was far more than the mouthpiece of IS. He was head of the Emni, the secret service of IS which plotted external terror attacks.”

How important was al-Adnani (real name: Taha Subhi Falaha) for Bangladeshi ISIS jihadis? An indication of that can be found in an infamous ISIS video featuring three Bangladeshi jihadis in Raqqa, the ISIS capital. In that video, which was recorded at an intersection of a shopping street just two blocks away from the ISIS headquarters, Bangladeshi ISIS fighter Abu Issa al-Bengali (real name: Tahmid Rahman Shafi) refers to al-Adnani as “our Sheikh.” According to him, the gruesome slaughter of foreign nationals and Bangladeshis at the Holey Artisan Bakery in Dhaka “was just a glimpse” of a global war envisioned by the Sheikh.

There are indications that al-Adnani was indeed the principal patron or sponsor of ISIS operations in Bangladesh. This was first revealed by Rukmini Callimachi as she interviewed Harry Sarfo, a former ISIS member now serving a prison sentence in Germany. During the interview, Sarfo told Callimachi that a regional division of the Emni – ISIS secret service headed by al-Adnani – was responsible for plotting and executing the “recent café attack in Dhaka, Bangladesh.”


It is also highly likely that Tamim Ahmed Chowdhury – the alleged mastermind of the Gulshan attack – was sent to Bangladesh by al-Adnani himself or one of his deputies overseeing the “Asian affairs division” of the Emni. Chowdhury left Canada sometime in 2012/2013 and received training in Syria before being deployed as an ISIS coordinator in Bangladesh. He was recently killed – some believe executed – by a special police unit in Narayanganj.

These deaths – al-Adnani’s in al-Bab and Chowdhury’s in Narayanganj – will certainly have a crippling effect on ISIS operations in Bangladesh.
However, as the NYT journalist Callimachi points out on Twitter: “I would caution people not to see this as a blow ISIS can not recover from. [The organisation] is built to survive deaths.”
http://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2016/09/01/end-islamic-state-bangladesh/
 
. . .
Geographically Bangladesh is on the laps of India. If 'real' IS tries to make a footprint it has to come through India or Myanmar which is not possible because India and Myanmar are Hindu and Buddhist country respectively. Bangladesh is far far away from Islamic countries of Middle East and Central Asia. So Bangladesh doesn't have foreign extremist problem unlike Pakistan which is next to Afghanistan (Taliban breeding ground) or Syria which is next to Iraq (Al-Qaeda and IS breeding ground).

Being India locked Bangladesh has strategic advantage to safeguard herself from Middle East militants. India won't let Bangladesh to become another Syria or Iraq for own safety. This fake IS in Bangladesh is home grown so called jihadi outfits such as Harkatul Jihad (HuJi) and Jama'atul Mujahideen Bangladesh (JMB).
 
.
It's a setback...a significant setback but nothing more.

This isn't some rebel army or movement which you can just destroy by killing a certain amount of fighters.

This is an ugly idea that will take years and years and even then it will be impossible to completely destroy because of lone wolfs.
 
.
Geographically Bangladesh is on the laps of India. If 'real' IS tries to make a footprint it has to come through India or Myanmar which is not possible because India and Myanmar are Hindu and Buddhist country respectively. Bangladesh is far far away from Islamic countries of Middle East and Central Asia. So Bangladesh doesn't have foreign extremist problem unlike Pakistan which is next to Afghanistan (Taliban breeding ground) or Syria which is next to Iraq (Al-Qaeda and IS breeding ground).

Being India locked Bangladesh has strategic advantage to safeguard herself from Middle East militants. India won't let Bangladesh to become another Syria or Iraq for own safety. This fake IS in Bangladesh is home grown so called jihadi outfits such as Harkatul Jihad (HuJi) and Jama'atul Mujahideen Bangladesh (JMB).
Also like to point out Bangladesh's security forces won't be lenient if India gets too involved with our security measures and so naturally they will repel isis influence on their own.
 
.
Geographically Bangladesh is on the laps of India. If 'real' IS tries to make a footprint it has to come through India or Myanmar which is not possible because India and Myanmar are Hindu and Buddhist country respectively. Bangladesh is far far away from Islamic countries of Middle East and Central Asia. So Bangladesh doesn't have foreign extremist problem unlike Pakistan which is next to Afghanistan (Taliban breeding ground) or Syria which is next to Iraq (Al-Qaeda and IS breeding ground).

Being India locked Bangladesh has strategic advantage to safeguard herself from Middle East militants. India won't let Bangladesh to become another Syria or Iraq for own safety. This fake IS in Bangladesh is home grown so called jihadi outfits such as Harkatul Jihad (HuJi) and Jama'atul Mujahideen Bangladesh (JMB).
mate... IS is an ideology.. as long as you got internet, you can get it.. they dont sneak in from other countries, so india being hindu country or burma being buddist country makes no difference.
 
.
Is this the end of Islamic State in Bangladesh?

There are indications that al-Adnani was indeed the principal patron or sponsor of ISIS operations in Bangladesh

This is the big news of the day – Abu Muhammad al-Adnani, the second most senior leader of the Islamic State (ISIS) is dead. According to latest reports, al-Adnani was killed in a US air strike near the town of al-Bab in Northern Syria on Tuesday. As he was the the chief spokesman and propagandist of the group, he was often described as “the voice of ISIS.” However, as Rukmini Callimachi of The New York Times (NYT) notes on Twitter, “[al-Adnani] was far more than the mouthpiece of IS. He was head of the Emni, the secret service of IS which plotted external terror attacks.”

How important was al-Adnani (real name: Taha Subhi Falaha) for Bangladeshi ISIS jihadis? An indication of that can be found in an infamous ISIS video featuring three Bangladeshi jihadis in Raqqa, the ISIS capital. In that video, which was recorded at an intersection of a shopping street just two blocks away from the ISIS headquarters, Bangladeshi ISIS fighter Abu Issa al-Bengali (real name: Tahmid Rahman Shafi) refers to al-Adnani as “our Sheikh.” According to him, the gruesome slaughter of foreign nationals and Bangladeshis at the Holey Artisan Bakery in Dhaka “was just a glimpse” of a global war envisioned by the Sheikh.

There are indications that al-Adnani was indeed the principal patron or sponsor of ISIS operations in Bangladesh. This was first revealed by Rukmini Callimachi as she interviewed Harry Sarfo, a former ISIS member now serving a prison sentence in Germany. During the interview, Sarfo told Callimachi that a regional division of the Emni – ISIS secret service headed by al-Adnani – was responsible for plotting and executing the “recent café attack in Dhaka, Bangladesh.”


It is also highly likely that Tamim Ahmed Chowdhury – the alleged mastermind of the Gulshan attack – was sent to Bangladesh by al-Adnani himself or one of his deputies overseeing the “Asian affairs division” of the Emni. Chowdhury left Canada sometime in 2012/2013 and received training in Syria before being deployed as an ISIS coordinator in Bangladesh. He was recently killed – some believe executed – by a special police unit in Narayanganj.

These deaths – al-Adnani’s in al-Bab and Chowdhury’s in Narayanganj – will certainly have a crippling effect on ISIS operations in Bangladesh.
However, as the NYT journalist Callimachi points out on Twitter: “I would caution people not to see this as a blow ISIS can not recover from. [The organisation] is built to survive deaths.”
http://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/2016/09/01/end-islamic-state-bangladesh/

Is this the end of IS in Bangladesh? - Not really... These militant organizations are structured in a way that makes them pretty quick to fill up the vacuum when somebody dies... Be it the death of Tamim or Adnani, someone else will fill up their position and IS will live on... or perhaps we may see a new group being craved out of the IS in Bangladesh... The ideology stays...
 
.
Isis won't survive in BD. BD is flat country, you will get caught easily.

Well, modern militancy doesn't really depend on the terrains for their existence... In the past, we used to see the militant organizations establishing their training bases around CHT or Cox's Bazar because of the hilly terrain in those areas, but now they are able to have their bases even within busy urban areas...

It's a setback...a significant setback but nothing more.

This isn't some rebel army or movement which you can just destroy by killing a certain amount of fighters.

This is an ugly idea that will take years and years and even then it will be impossible to completely destroy because of lone wolfs.

True that...
 
.
The problem with extremism is a fact in most countries in the world including India.
However IS or any extremist groups would never flourish in BAngladesh or India.
The best they can hope for is an odd attack . We have proved this in the past with JMB (bangla bhai and Co) and we are proving it again with neo JMB/ISIS (tamim and co)..
 
.
You can't kill an idea.

The problem with extremism is a fact in most countries in the world including India.
However IS or any extremist groups would never flourish in BAngladesh or India.
The best they can hope for is an odd attack . We have proved this in the past with JMB (bangla bhai and Co) and we are proving it again with neo JMB/ISIS (tamim and co)..

There are actually plenty of militants in India. Be they guided by Islamic ideology or something else.

It appears that those terrorists in Bangladesh were financially hard up relative to other terrorist groups around the globe. If they have money and mobilize resources, they can flourish.

Regardless of ideas, they are mercenaries. They will switch to whichever company pays more in a theater of war. This is what happened in Syria.

Something tells me that this goes way beyond ex-Major Zia.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom