IS destroy ancient artifacts in Iraq

[Syrian Lion]

I$i$ already sold most of the artifact to Europe...

 

[That Guy]

What's your point then? Both idea and people are responsible for the crime.

I've been repeating my point multiple times.

 

[janon]

Yet it is a person who comes up with ideas. An idea cannot kill a man, that is nothing more than philosophical nonsense.

People act on the ideas they believe in. If they believe that it is a good idea to kill somebody, they will do it. The culpability of course lies on the person - which is why we arrest people, not ideas. But when you say "ideas don't kill", you seem to be implying that there are no bad ideas, only bad people. There are bad ideas, plenty of them.

 

[Water Car Engineer]

I cant believe these luntics are doing this.

These things are priceless, some of these have survived 1000s and 1000s of years of nature and people!!!

This isnt a loss to the ME only, but all of humanity!!

 

[Screambowl]

People act on the ideas they believe in. If they believe that it is a good idea to kill somebody, they will do it. The culpability of course lies on the person - which is why we arrest people, not ideas. But when you say "ideas don't kill", you seem to be implying that there are no bad ideas, only bad people. There are bad ideas, plenty of them.

Bad ideas, bad thoughts bad following or bad learning give rise to bad people. So how to do you see this in context of Islam and Muslims, and the rest of the world?

 

[TejasMk3]

Not the first time this has happened, lots has been done in the past in India by these types...

Leftist historians will of course, later, deny all of it, and will say they brought art and architecture to the region, while destroying evil indigenous stuff, used to oppress people

 

[janon]

Bad ideas, bad thoughts bad following or bad learning give rise to bad people. So how to do you see this in context of Islam and Muslims, and the rest of the world?

I don't classify people as good or bad, I find it far more useful to classify actions as good or bad. Believing bad ideas cause people to do bad actions, which is what I said in my previous post.

 

[Screambowl]

I don't classify people as good or bad, I find it far more useful to classify actions as good or bad. Believing bad ideas cause people to do bad actions, which is what I said in my previous post.

you quoted the teachings of Bhagwat Geta, the righteous statement. How far do you relate your statement with Muslims? Do you wish to see them more reformative in tolerating?

 

[Brutas]

Any civilized individual with sane mind would consider them nothing less than barbarian bedouin desert savages.

 

[Falcon29]

Shame on them for destroying superior Arab artifacts and not Hindu Idols to start off Ghazwa Al Hind -2.0

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Shame on them for destroying superior Arab artifacts and not Hindu Idols to start off Ghazwa Al Hind -2.0

 

[janon]

you quoted the teachings of Bhagwat Geta, the righteous statement. How far do you relate your statement with Muslims? Do you wish to see them more reformative in tolerating?

Where did I quote the Bhagvat Gita?

To the question, yes I wish they would reform their beliefs like many other religions have done. For example, today Christians no longer obey many biblical laws, like "Thou shall not suffer a witch to live.", or that homosexuals should be stoned at the edge of the village, or how to treat slaves.

 

[A1Kaid]

I cant believe these luntics are doing this.

These things are priceless, some of these have survived 1000s and 1000s of years of nature and people!!!

This isnt a loss to the ME only, but all of humanity!!

Most of them are replicas, so calm down.

 

[Screambowl]

Where did I quote the Bhagvat Gita?

unintentionally or unknowingly what ever you said is in Bhagwad Geetha , under the description of Karma yoga.
you can read all that here Lord Krishna’s Teachings on Karma Yoga

But my question was how much muslims are responsible for the degradation of Islam? And who degraded it are according to you Muslims? Because you said, it's the deed and ideas which are bad not the person.

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Most of them are replicas, so calm down.

Like Im supposed to know that?