Indus civilization and it's true inheritance

[El Sidd]

LOL - never heard of Pakistani mangoes or rice. Are they even popular?

You are too young to even care kid. I can understand

 

[Jackdaws]

You are too young to even care kid. I can understand

Ok uncle. Did they disappear at the time of the dodo?

 

[El Sidd]

Ok uncle. Did they disappear at the time of the dodo?

No but
Feels like it though

 

[newb3e]

aryan
rajputs
brahmin
dalits
cradle of civilization
oldest culture
india

in that order!

 

[war&peace]

One day you are a Marathi, the next a Haryanvi....Kashmiri yet today from the Punjab-Rajasthan, what are you, I am puzzled, are you a son of a thousand fathers , each and every one a B@STARD like you.
Gangadesh Mata Ki Jai

@Kaptaan @DESERT FIGHTER @war&peace @Sher Shah Awan @Talwar e Pakistan

Excellent observation. How can a single person have so many ethnicities...except for being a product of some polyandrous relationship..which is not so uncommon in India and we have seen Indian friends defending it robustly.

PS: Even in a polyandrous relationship a single sperm from a single male would fertilises the egg (ovum)...except... but I don't want to go discuss or imagine the scenario.

 

[django]

Excellent observation. How can a single person have so many ethnicities...except for being a product of some polyandrous relationship..which is not so uncommon in India and we have seen Indian friends defending it robustly.

PS: Even in a polyandrous relationship a single sperm from a single male would fertilises the egg

 

[Hamza913]

Hey Guy,
I am opening this thread to discuss the legality of inheritance of indus civilization to pakistan in the context of history,culture,religion and other social aspects and why do most of indians deny the fact that pakistan is true inheritor of indus civilazation and claim that indus civilization was derived by them.
All the inputs are welcomed from Pakistani and indian brothers but my request is to make them objective. Thank you.
@dsr478@Joe Shearer @Kaptaan @Talwar e Pakistan @Sher Shah Awan@django.

Asalamu Alaikum

My take is this, the civilisation is one for Pakistanis and Hindustanis in bordering provinces to take as their heritage first and foremost, however, these early civilisations are so far back in time, almost everyone alive today will have ancestry from them, so these early civilisations should be considered the heritage of humanity as well, but Pakistanis and Hindustanis in bordering provinces have a special connection since they come from the actual area of the civilisation.

http://www.stat.yale.edu/~jtc5/papers/CommonAncestors/NatureAncestorsPressRelease.html
http://www.foxnews.com/story/2006/0...ancestor-all-humans-lived-5000-years-ago.html

 

[django]

Excellent observation. How can a single person have so many ethnicities...except for being a product of some polyandrous relationship..which is not so uncommon in India and we have seen Indian friends defending it robustly.

PS: Even in a polyandrous relationship a single sperm from a single male would fertilises the egg (ovum)...except... but I don't want to go discuss or imagine the scenario.

In one of his other ids he wished he could breed his daughters with iranic/Pashtun/Ghandarans so that they could maintain coloured eyes in the family, I kid you not, this is the kind of psycho we are dealing with.Kudos bro

 

[gangsta_rap]

Within the west when they study Indian history the topic always begins with the Indus Valley, even appropriating Mehrgarh into the subject. Take a look at how this britannica article goes about it as an example:

https://www.britannica.com/place/India/History

The same kind of trend is present within Western history. It always begins with discussing the mesopotamian civilization as a birthplace of western civilization...how do these trends work?

 

[war&peace]

In one of his other ids he wished he could breed his daughters with iranic/Pashtun/Ghandarans so that they could maintain coloured eyes in the family, I kid you not, this is the kind of psycho we are dealing with.Kudos bro

There are two Gangadeshis..one claims that they are offsprings of Iran while the other is trying hard to merge India with China, while the latter's people dismissing it as a ludicrous offer, and according to him the process has already started
SO Gangadeshis are really confused. The cheaters are looking to shamelessly cheat...copycats and most of their music has been plagiarised from Pakistani music .... so much for their so called film industry.

 

[Hamza913]

Within the west when they study Indian history the topic always begins with the Indus Valley, even appropriating Mehrgarh into the subject. Take a look at how this britannica article goes about it as an example:

https://www.britannica.com/place/India/History

The same kind of trend is present within Western history. It always begins with discussing the mesopotamian civilization as a birthplace of western civilization...how do these trends work?

Asalamu Alaikum

IVC is appropriated as Hindustani because Pakistan doesn't care about it.

How many Pakistanis do you know outside of PDF who care that much about IVC? I doubt you know very many.

Mesopotamia is appropriated as an achievement of humanity, which I actually agree with but I don't like how the same rule isn't applied to Ancient Egypt or IVC.

 

[django]

There are two Gangadeshis..one claims that they are offsprings of Iran while the other is trying hard to merge India with China, while the latter's people dismissing it as a ludicrous offer, and according to him the process has already started

In this case we are dealing with the former, I swear he would rather look like Pashtun/Dadic than have all the money in the world, such is his insecurity.Kudos

 

[El Sidd]

Asalamu Alaikum

IVC is appropriated as Hindustani because Pakistan doesn't care about it.

How many Pakistanis do you know outside of PDF who care that much about IVC? I doubt you know very many.

Mesopotamia is appropriated as an achievement of humanity, which I actually agree with but I don't like how the same rule isn't applied to Ancient Egypt or IVC.

I can solve your riddle but i wont

 

[Ahmad Sajjad Paracha]

Asalamu Alaikum

My take is this, the civilisation is one for Pakistanis and Hindustanis in bordering provinces to take as their heritage first and foremost, however, these early civilisations are so far back in time, almost everyone alive today will have ancestry from them, so these early civilisations should be considered the heritage of humanity as well, but Pakistanis and Hindustanis in bordering provinces have a special connection since they come from the actual area of the civilisation.

http://www.stat.yale.edu/~jtc5/papers/CommonAncestors/NatureAncestorsPressRelease.html
http://www.foxnews.com/story/2006/0...ancestor-all-humans-lived-5000-years-ago.html

Walaikumsalam, Brother i was waiting for your comment but the main thing that i wanted to discuss is that what culture did they have, what was their languages, the parental linkage of pakistani with ivs and their religion and how did it influence pakistan and India culturally (nd to what extent) ?

 

[Hamza913]

Walaikumsalam, Brother i was waiting for your comment but the main thing that i wanted to discuss is that what culture did they have, what was their languages, the parental linkage of pakistani with ivs and their religion and how did it influence pakistan and India culturally (nd to what extent) ?

Their language is undeciphered, we don't know how much they influenced us in that regard. This also makes any cultural influence they may have had difficult to find.

What we can confirm is that they lived in modern day Pakistan/north-west Hindustan, and that they probably did influence the Aryan invaders to some degree as well as intermarry with them.

As for ancestry, as said before, almost everyone has ancestors from these ancient civilisations since they are from so long ago, so that point is almost irrelevant.