Indus civilization and it's true inheritance

[MultaniGuy]

Even just going by your post with you agreeing Punjabis, Gujaratis, Rajastanis etc having rights to shared IVC heritage, Punjabis, Gujaratis, Rajastanis are Indians. Hence the shared claim by Indians and Pakistanis to IVC heritage stands.

Hypothetically if British India had remained undivided after the British left provinces of current day Pakistan would have been individual states with their unique language and culture intact under a central federal governing setup.

You are adding nothing new to the conversation saying Pakistanis are unique.

Gujaratis, Punjabis or Bengali in modern day India are unique with their own language, food and culture.

lol India cannot claim IVC civilization. Most of Indus River valley civilization is in Pakistan.

The same way that Pakistan cannot claim the Taj Mahal.

 

[UnitedPak]

We have nothing to do with Indians. Indians are a completely different race to us.

The thing about race and origin is that it cannot be attributed to any specific nation. Most of Middle East and South Asia was settled by the same African group who developed into local hunter gatherers. These populations then mixed with other groups. In Pakistanis case, it was the Iranian neolithic farmers followed by Central Asian Steppe people.
North Indians experienced something similar but not to the same extent, and South Indians even less so. But on the other hand, they received populations from the south east Asia and some native Australian components that never made it to Pakistan. Its a complex topic, but I don't see how this even relates to Indus valley identity, which is entirely Pakistani.

 

[MultaniGuy]

The thing about race and origin is that it cannot be attributed to any specific nation. Most of Middle East and South Asia was settled by the same African group who developed into local hunter gatherers. These populations then mixed with other groups. In Pakistanis case, it was the Iranian neolithic farmers followed by Central Asian Steppe people.
North Indians experienced something similar but not to the same extent, and South Indians even less so. But on the other hand, they received populations from the south east Asia and some native Australian components that never made it to Pakistan. Its a complex topic, but I don't see how this even relates to Indus valley identity, which is entirely Pakistani.

Pakistanis have nothing to do with Indians, and Indus River Valley Civilization has nothing to do with India.