What's new

Indonesia woos Japan as China-led high-speed-rail project stalls

striver44

BANNED
Joined
Jul 25, 2016
Messages
4,832
Reaction score
-16
Country
Indonesia
Location
Indonesia
Tokyo lost to Beijing in bidding, but construction delay creates new opening

https%3A%2F%2Fs3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com%2Fpsh-ex-ftnikkei-3937bb4%2Fimages%2F9%2F4%2F8%2F7%2F27527849-6-eng-GB%2FCropped-1591554347photo.JPG

A high-speed train linking Beijing and Hong Kong. China won the Jakarta-Bandung high-speed-rail project in 2015, but work has been plagued by delays and cost overruns. © Reuters
KOYA JIBIKI, Nikkei staff writerJune 8, 2020 03:27 JST
JAKARTA -- The Indonesian government has begun discussions on possible Japanese participation in a planned high-speed railway between Jakarta and Bandung, hoping to spur progress on the delayed Chinese-led project as costs mount.

The new proposal would combine that rail link -- which Japan lost out on in 2015 -- with a Japanese-Indonesian project upgrading an existing 750 km connection between Jakarta and Surabaya.

Discussions have begun on extending the high-speed Jakarta-Bandung railway to Surabaya and whether it would be possible to include Japan in the consortium, Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi told an online news conference Thursday.

Japan is an important partner in Indonesia's infrastructure development, and cooperation will help further connect Indonesian cities and promote faster economic growth, she said.

Many in the Indonesian government have argued that a single railway running through Bandung to Surabaya would be more efficient than separate routes going east and southeast from the capital. Cost overruns on the Bandung project have given a boost to this view.

https%3A%2F%2Fs3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com%2Fpsh-ex-ftnikkei-3937bb4%2Fimages%2F_aliases%2Farticleimage%2F4%2F8%2F3%2F2%2F27542384-1-eng-GB%2F20200608-Indonesia-Railway-Map.png

The Ministry of State-Owned Enterprises is expected to draw up a new plan and officially propose it to Japan once it is complete.

China won the Jakarta-Bandung project with a plan requiring no financial contribution from the Indonesian government. The proposed 140 km railway would slash travel time between the two cities to 45 minutes from three and a half hours. The groundbreaking ceremony was held in January 2016, with the launch slated for 2019.

Beijing regards it as an important part of its Belt and Road Initiative. In June 2019, Chinese President Xi Jinping said in a meeting with his Indonesian counterpart Joko Widodo, "We must steadily build and improve the quality of cooperation under the One Belt, One Road Initiative."

But delays in securing the necessary land -- a condition of financing from the China Development Bank, which was to provide 75% of the funding -- bogged down the project, pushing back the opening to 2021. More recently, construction was temporarily halted as a precaution to avoid spreading the coronavirus.

Airlangga Hartarto, coordinating minister for economic affairs, has indicated that the project will be delayed by another year. A review of the country's infrastructure development projects raised the projected cost of the Jakarta-Bandung link to $6 billion from the previous estimate of $5.5 billion.

This led to the idea of extending the railway to Surabaya and bringing Japan into the project. The proposal came to light May 29, after Widodo and members of his cabinet met to reevaluate national strategic projects.

"To be more economical, President Jokowi has instructed that the project not stop at Bandung but be extended to Surabaya" and also asked to add Japan to the consortium, Airlangga said after the meeting, as reported by The Jakarta Post.

The change in plans has baffled the Japanese side, which has already launched a feasibility study for the Jakarta-Surabaya link and would have trouble shifting gears. That project uses existing track and has different specifications from China's high-speed rail line.

"We can't imagine" what the new Indonesian proposal will look like, a source from Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said.

The proposal for Japan to join a project for which it and China had competed comes amid a recent push for Sino-Japanese cooperation on infrastructure in third countries

https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Tr...n-as-China-led-high-speed-rail-project-stalls
 
.
Next Indonesia should make a underwater tunnel connecting Java and our 2nd largest economic powerhouse ,Sumatra.
 
.
Ugh, we should just go with Japan in the past and have high speed railway connecting Jakarta-Bandung-Semarang-Surabaya.

Next Indonesia should make a underwater tunnel connecting Java and our 2nd largest economic powerhouse ,Sumatra.
Java-Sumatra bridge idea was proposed during SBY era but shelved by Jokowi, but why underwater?
I am more interested with Bali-Java bridge.
 
.
Java-Sumatra bridge idea was proposed during SBY era but shelved by Jokowi, but why underwater?
I am more interested with Bali-Java bridge.
Well I prefer tunnels like the channel tunnel.
 
. .
It got delayed due to covid-19, if the Japanese were in charge it will still be delayed and cost a lot more. Look like the USA media did a nice job brainwashing.
The project was stalled due to immediate impacts of covid-19, but also land acquisition problems due to rising prices. "construction delays" are just an ineviteable sideeffect not the cause.

Obviously our troll knows, thats why he put extra effort to emphasise and shift blame on "construction delays", adding his personal commentary into the post hoping nobody would notice its not part of the article.

Indonesia is considering to pull Japan into the fray along with China to ease the burden of fullfilling the obligations of the Indonesion side of the contract.
 
. .
Well I prefer tunnels like the channel tunnel.

Channel tunnel sit on convenient geography, meanwhile Sunda Strait lies on the most dangerous spot on earth. Even if i got nine souls within, i still not dare to challenge myself for such undertaking.

The tunnel aside, Japan offer is not benefitting us much like the Chinese do in long term.
 
.
Obviously our troll knows, thats why he put extra effort to emphasise and shift blame on "construction delays", adding his personal commentary into the post hoping nobody would notice its not part of the article.
.
I never added those .lol
IMG_20200611_083843.jpg
 
.
.
.
Indonesia should choose Japan on the basis that Japan is the world leading anime producing country.
 
. . .
The main reason of the delay is previously due to land acquisition issues and local red tape bureaucracy (even Covid-19 didn't slow the work as much)... Physical work that should have started in 2016 only started in late 2018 and only accelerated in 2019... The actual construction time so far is only about 1,5 years and the progress is actually quite impressive..

With all regards to Japan, even if they had gotten this project, they will still face the same delays... Simply put, no land no construction... Just like what Japan is currently facing with the Indian HSR project... I believe what the article is talking about is for the possible future extension of the HSR line (Bandung - Surabaya line) which is actually outside the scope of the current ongoing project (Jakarta - Bandung line).

If true, it would also be interesting to see how the gov plans to fund the HSR extension project, as currently the project is funded purely under the Business-to-Business scheme (between Indonesian and Chinese SOEs) with no gov funding (APBN) at all... Japan previously lost out due to their insistence for gov guarantees in this project (also higher price tag and longer construction time).
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom