What's new

India's Sanskrit speakers seek to revive 'dead' language

Kashmiri Pandit

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 12, 2015
Messages
3,023
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
India
In a tiny flat in a rundown alley in New Delhi, Rakesh Kumar Misra is working against the odds to bring India's ancient Sanskrit language to the country's millions.

The 4,000-year-old classical language was traditionally used by Brahmin intellectuals and Hindu priests. Rarely spoken as a mother tongue in India, Sanskrit is often dismissed as a dead language.

But Misra is undeterred, spending up to 12 hours a day hunched over his computer, translating and writing articles for a weekly 16-page newspaper in the script.


Image: Firstpost



"My aim is to take Sanskrit to the masses, to make it accessible to everyone," Misra, who has a masters in Sanskrit studies and sees the language as indelibly linked to India's heritage, told AFP.

Hopes of a Sanskrit revival, long pushed by Hindu hardliners, have been rising since India's Hindu nationalist Prime Minister Narendra Modi stormed to power at last year's general election.

Several ministers, although not Modi himself, took an oath of office in the revered language and a national "Sanskrit week" was later declared to promote its teaching in schools.

The first Sanskrit movie made in more than two decades (and only the third ever) was shown at a leading film festival in November in the tourism state of Goa.

Vinod Mankara, director of "Priyamanasam", about a 17th century-poet from the southern state of Kerala, said he hoped to secure government help to show the film overseas to "mesmerise foreigners" with the language.

"It's been my desire from long back to propagate the beauty of the Sanskrit language," he told AFP.

- Intolerance rising -

But the focus on Sanskrit has sparked a debate about its role in India, which has 22 official languages, many spoken by sizeable minorities.

Critics fear Hindu hardliners are promoting Sanskrit as a way of imposing Hindu superiority on the country's religious and linguistic minorities.

Mankara has rejected criticism that his film promotes Hindu ideology, calling it "pure art".

It comes at a time of raging controversy over whether the Modi government is failing to uphold India's tradition of secularism and diversity, amid rising fears of growing intolerance towards Muslims and others.

Education Minister Smriti Irani, responsible for promoting the language, denies the right-wing government has any hidden agenda and describes Sanskrit as the "voice of India's soul and wisdom".

But she faces an uphill battle popularising it in schools, where it is offered as an optional language, and where some believe it's linked with India's past not its future.

"There are a lot of languages on offer and it's difficult to deliver it everywhere," KC Tripathi, head of languages at the National Council of Educational Research and Training, a government body that advises on school curriculums.

Tripathi said the council was forming a new education policy, at the Modi government's request, that includes updating and improving the way Sanskrit is taught in schools.

India's heritage

Only 14,100 people speak Sanskrit as their main language, according to the latest census figures, less than one percent of India's 1.25 billion population.

Still used in Hindu prayers and chants in temples, Sanskrit is the root of many but not all Indian languages and descends from the Indo-Aryans.

It was used thousands of years ago by India's intellectuals whose manuscripts covered everything from philosophy to astronomy and medicine, not unlike Latin or Greek in the West.

"You can't think about India without thinking of Sanskrit. The intellectual heritage of India for the last 5,000 years is rooted in Sanskrit," said Ramesh Bhardwaj, head of Delhi University's Sanskrit department, the world's largest with 4,000 undergraduate students.

"This is not a dead language," he added.

Bhardwaj said he is disappointed the government has not done more to revive Sanskrit, including making it compulsory in schools, so younger generations can understand India's roots.

"They (the government) came to power in the name of nationalism which includes Sanskrit, but nothing has been done," the professor said.

Misra, who draws no salary for producing his newspaper, one of only a handful in India and distributed mainly outside Hindu temples, is under no illusions about the scale of his task.

But he said India, like any country, cannot progress without all its people, not just its elite, understanding its past.

"It shouldn't just end up becoming a language of textbooks and research."
 
.
We must look into how Israel successfully accomplished near 100% Hebrew movement for their country (from a similar status that Hebrew had like Sanskrit before Israel was formed) and adopt the relevant measures for India.

Indians must strive to be trilingual from young age: Sanskrit (national language) + Local mother tongue + English.

Children are very good at picking up languages at young age...but we need a large education overhaul and reform (in how children are taught + quality) plus some pilot projects before this can be attempted on mass scale.
 
. .
We must look into how Israel successfully accomplished near 100% Hebrew movement for their country (from a similar status that Hebrew had like Sanskrit before Israel was formed) and adopt the relevant measures for India.

Indians must strive to be trilingual from young age: Sanskrit (national language) + Local mother tongue + English.

Children are very good at picking up languages at young age...but we need a large education overhaul and reform (in how children are taught + quality) plus some pilot projects before this can be attempted on mass scale.

Why were U banned ?

I agree .
My case . Koshur is Mother Tongue . Hindi and English is used to converse with people outside The Linguistic Group .
Any way the Hindi Spoken here is just the mixture of words from Hindi , Urdu , English , Koshur etc .

I like Japanese School system .
Where High schools , Junior Schools and Middle Schools are separate unlike India where we have Classes 1 to 12 in same school . I like the School Club structure of Japan , that can help Indian students of same qualities come together and show case their talents .
 
. .
From what i've heard grammatical Sinhala language is more closer to Sanskrit than modern day Hindi

@Godman @HeinzG @Saradiel @Azizam.. Any clarifications on this ?

Thought Sinhala is more linked to Pali Prakrit? That's somewhat different from Sanskrit (especially in grammar)....but there links for sure.

Why were U banned ?

I got into a heated exchange with a Chinese troll about Bullet train and I slipped up in one of the posts (very narrowly but it is what it is)

I am going to avoid that subforum as much as possible from now on.

Enjoy the entertainment:

Japan poised to build India's first bullet train: report | Page 4

What Are You Listening to Right Now - Round 2 | Page 385
 
.
From what i've heard grammatical Sinhala language is more closer to Sanskrit than modern day Hindi

@Godman @HeinzG @Saradiel @Azizam.. Any clarifications on this ?

I don;t know much on Sankrit but I am very suprised the similarity between numbers

In sinhala Number one is "Eka" while in Sanskrit its "Ekam"
But it looks like modern Sinhala has changed but Sanskrit words are still used

While modern Sinhala word for 100 is "Siyaya" the Sanskrit word shatam can be found for example century is called a Shatawarshaya. Warshaya means year. So its "Hundred Years"

Most Sanskrit words for numbers are used but not used in counting.

For example octagon is called Ashtathalaya (Ashta is 8 in Sanskrit) while Pentagon is Panchashraya (Pancha being 5 in Sanskrit), Dodecagon is Dwadasathalaya (Dwadasa being 12 in Sanskrit)

Sanskrit based words in Sinhala aren't used commonly now
 
.
@Gibbs I find Sinhala script very similar to Odia script

Yes, I think Odiya script is the most similar to Sinhala

5 OF THE WORLD’S MOST BEAUTIFUL AND ENDANGERED ALPHABETS…

Thought Sinhala is more linked to Pali Prakrit? That's somewhat different from Sanskrit (especially in grammar)....but there links for sure.

No idea mate, i just heard it or read some where that grammatical Sinhala is still very close to Sanskrit than Hindi.. I'm not very fluent in the Language anyway

I don;t know much on Sankrit but I am very suprised the similarity between numbers

In sinhala Number one is "Eka" while in Sanskrit its "Ekam"
But it looks like modern Sinhala has changed but Sanskrit words are still used

While modern Sinhala word for 100 is "Siyaya" the Sanskrit word shatam can be found for example century is called a Shatawarshaya. Warshaya means year. So its "Hundred Years"

Most Sanskrit words for numbers are used but not used in counting.

For example octagon is called Ashtathalaya (Ashta is 8 in Sanskrit) while Pentagon is Panchashraya (Pancha being 5 in Sanskrit), Dodecagon is Dwadasathalaya (Dwadasa being 12 in Sanskrit)

Sanskrit based words in Sinhala aren't used commonly now

Thanks.. Yeah that quite intriguing.. Yeah i think it's the more grammatical Sinhala not the spoken version these days
 
.
No idea mate, i just heard it or read some where that grammatical Sinhala is still very close to Sanskrit than Hindi.. I'm not very fluent in the Language anyway

Yes compared to Hindi, definitely. Hindi/Urdu has been influenced heavily by Persian among other languages.

There are Sanskrit loanwords/influence in even Tamil that no typical Hindi speaker would understand (unless he/she has learnt Sanskrit itself).
 
.
Yes compared to Hindi, definitely. Hindi/Urdu has been influenced heavily by Persian among other languages.

There are Sanskrit loanwords/influence in even Tamil that no typical Hindi speaker would understand (unless he/she has learnt Sanskrit itself).

Did Tamil originate from Sanskrit as well ?
 
.
Did Tamil originate from Sanskrit as well ?

No. Its origins (along with the other South Indian "Dravidian" languages) lie elsewhere...some have speculated an Indus Valley Civilisation link, others an austronesian one....and others simply a different domestic origin...or some combination of them.

Whatever it is, its different at a core level to the Vedic origins of Sanskrit....its why south indian languages sound so different from north indian ones.

But there are so many loanwords from Sanskrit in Tamil, especially in Brahmin Tamil...given Sanskrit was and is the liturgical language of Hinduism and the long history of cultural contact with the other parts of India.

This has of course, in relatively more recent years, led to the politicization of "pure" "correct" tamil which has been very ridiculous some years (often words were artificially made just to replace a Sanskrit one). But they have not been able to expunge Sanskrit/prakrit influences totally....given these links have lasted 1000s of years.

Its like expunging every single tamil loan word in Sinhala (I don't know if thats even been tried)....languages are such a complicated subject to do that especially when they have been part of very long cultural contact with other neighbours.

Sanskrit itself however is probably the closest living link (arguably along with Avestan) to the original root Indo-European language which has no official name since it is still a large mystery to us given it had no written form.
 
.
Did Tamil originate from Sanskrit as well ?

No ,Tamil is unique and an entire different systems .
But half part of our mother tongue ,Malayalam ,is Sanskrit and other half is Tamil.

On topic.I think we should use Sanskrit instead of Hindi in our education system .Sanskrit , Mother tongue and English.
 
.
We must look into how Israel successfully accomplished near 100% Hebrew movement for their country (from a similar status that Hebrew had like Sanskrit before Israel was formed) and adopt the relevant measures for India.
That seems much harder for India to implement considering the population size.
 
.
No ,Tamil is unique and an entire different systems .
But half part of our mother tongue ,Malayalam ,is Sanskrit and other half is Tamil.

On topic.I think we should use Sanskrit instead of Hindi in our education system .Sanskrit , Mother tongue and English.

But I thought like Telugu is the one having influences from Proto Tamil and Sanskrit. If I am correct, Telugu is the first one to get separated from Proto Tamil and from Early Telugu, formed the early proto Kannada.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom