Indians being brainwashed into believing Pakistan is the enemy: Naseeruddin Shah

[RAMPAGE]

i see them as sensible humans who want to bring progress to indian society.

So you are an Indian Muslim?

 

[ravi kiran]

One who doubts his/her spouse's fidelity can never live in peace. Trying to know the secret loves of people is akin to peeping in their bathrooms. I regret the harsh words but such type of thinking does not reflect a healthy mental state.

exploding fire crackers when pakistan wins match against India.
Raising Pakistani flag on Indian soil.
Inviting pakistani president but not inviting Indian PM.
Issuing fatawa that muslims should not sing National anthem and should not bow before national flag.
Insulting Hindu gods.
threatening Hindus to kill.
all the above type of thinking does reflect a healthy mental state. right?

 

[Lord ZeN]

You have a gun in your hand. It is war with Pakistan. I am an Indian soldier (i will be 3 years from now anyways).

So you intent to serve as a military doctor huh. Kudos to you .. mate

 

[Stephen Cohen]

@Razia Sultana

Naseeruddin Shah could have said that he wishes to see
better relations between India and Pakistan

He could have said that he was very sad with the current state of affairs

But why use the term " being brainwashed"

Cant we Indians think for ourselves ; dont we have the ability to distinguish between friends and enemies

Brainwashing is a derogatory word

And BTW what has Pakistan done to stop the Anti India Anti Hindu campaign
that has been going on since 1947 in the country

Is Mr Shah so naive not to know all that

 

[doppelganger]

So you intent to serve as a military doctor huh. Kudos to you .. mate

Yes I do. Hope I come towards the top and get the Navy though.

 

[ravi kiran]

Yes I do. Hope I come towards the top and get the Navy though.

good luck.

 

[doppelganger]

good luck.

Thanks. I need it. Right about now, with my marks, I am headed to an extended vacation in Siachen.

 

[jamahir]

So you are an Indian Muslim?

rather late in the day to ask that, yes?? i have been on pdf for about eight months.

but yes... though i will emphasize the word "socialist".

 

[ravi kiran]

Thank. I need it. Right about now, with my marks, I am headed to an extended vacation in Siachen.

just try and never give up.
Siachen is not bad though

So you are an Indian Muslim?

@jamahir do not consider himself Indian.

 

[doppelganger]

just try and never give up.
Siachen is not bad though

Less Pakstanis with guns pointed at you in the Navy though. Chinese too, though those guys are pretty cool most of the time.

 

[ito]

sure... i am not saying pakistan army is a socialist revolutionary force... it is of course their responsibility too to delete any hostility.

solutions are there... what have not been there are courageous leaders on both sides to forward those solutions to their own people, much less proposing it to the other side.

as example of solution, you may know of my "kashmir - a definitive solution" thread of the solution thought of by muammar gaddafi, who of course spoke from a neutral and socialist perspective.

If I were you, I would not compromise on territorial integrity to gain peace. Because such 'solutions' only lead to more problems in future.

@ On topic...I don't hate Pakistan, because I know that there are many Pakistanis who like many Indians are fighting daily for roti kapda aur makaan, but you cannot ignore that all of Pakistani military is India centric,and that make Pakistan an enemy state to India.

 

[Razia Sultana]

You will admit being a Muslim in India is not the same as being Advani in India right?

Advani does not come with Partition baggage. Muslims do.

Naseeruddin Shah can sell his book by praising Pakistan. Without putting down the country his elder brother fights for.

In fact Advani has the baggage of partition as he came from Pakistan. Muslims in India remained in their homeland just like other Indians. I disagree that Naseer has said something completely untruth. He goes to Pakistan and always gets warm welcome, love and regards from the Pakistanis. What he hears in India does not match with what he sees there and so he gave the statement. He could be naive or just being a good salesman is a bit different thing.

 

[ravi kiran]

Less Pakstanis with guns pointed at you in the Navy though. Chinese too, though those guys are pretty cool most of the time.

you are lucky you will get chance to kill some Pakistanis. just kidding.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

Actually he is doing brain wash of pakistani people to sell his book. Lol. We are proud on Nsir saab.

 

[doppelganger]

In fact Advani has the baggage of partition as he came from Pakistan. Muslims in India remained in their homeland just like other Indians. I disagree that Naseer has said something completely untruth. He goes to Pakistan and always gets warm welcome, love and regards from the Pakistanis. What he hears in India does not match with what he sees there and so he gave the statement. He could be naive or just being a good salesman is a bit different thing.

Forget Naseer for a bit. What about you? You are living here only no? You think he's right?