Indian Secularism: majoritarian playground?

[S_O_C_O_M]

Indian Secularism: majoritarian playground?​

By Mushtaque Madni, The Milli Gazette
Published Online: Dec 25, 2010
Print Issue: 16-31 December 2010

Immediately after the ‘Headlines Today’ TV channel, in a sting operation, exposed the ‘Terror Faces’ of the Sangh leaders, a huge hue and cry erupted from the defiant RSS, accusing the channel to have conspired against its ‘innocents’ with an active connivance of the Congress. The next day, a violent mob of RSS goons, surprisingly with some Sikh youths, attacked the office of the channel where some security guards were seriously injured and the office furniture damaged. Few days later, CNN-IBN, headed by a Brahmin Editor-in-Chief, Rajdeep Sardesai, held a debate on the issue of ‘Hindu Terror’ under the anchorship of Ms. Sagarika Ghose and a ‘simple’ question was displayed on the screen for the audience to answer. ‘Is it ‘unfair’ to term Sangh activities as Hindu terror?’ (Conspiracy to cause blasts and kill Muslims). The obvious answer was an overwhelming ‘YES’. Does one really need to be an intellectual to understand the underlying message that the channel intended to send by throwing a ‘suggestive’ question so that the sentiments of the Hindu majority did not get hurt? On July 26, Indian Express carried an exhaustive news item, where the investigation agencies officials, probing in the bomb blast cases, confessedly admitted to have been carried by the ‘Traditional Assuming Strategy’ that the people behind Mecca Masjid, Ajmer Sharif Dargah and Malegaon bomb blasts ought to be “Local Muslims’, who, with the help of Bangladeshi, Pakistani or even Al-Qaida terror outfits must have carried these blasts. In Pune, after the blast in German Bakery, ATS arrested a youth Abdul Samad from Bhatkal, who seemed to resemble the accused shown in the CCTV camera, despite the fact that the poor boy was attending a marriage ceremony in his village in Karnataka on the day of the blast. Subsequently, Samad was released honorably by the Court giving a fine punch to the ATS who was unfailingly and reportedly congratulated by the Hon’ble Home Minister ( A Tamil Brahmin) for nabbing the ‘culprit’ in just 100 days of the blast. But surprisingly, no newspaper reported Home Minister congratulating Rajasthan ATS when they arrested Devendra Gupta, an RSS pracharak, in connection with Ajmer blast. Given the above cited stray incident, ostensibly a straw from the huge ocean of our system’s systematic and well programmed torture tactics against Muslims, one is forced to believe that in the guise and garb of secularism India seems to have virtually become a playground for the majoritarians.

Do the investigating agencies world over probe cases on the basis of ‘Assumption or Presumption' or this special privilege is bestowed upon only on the Indian Agencies who, in many a case have actually acted like ‘Hindu Agencies’? Whether it is Kashmir, Gujarat or even Maharashtra, who can forget an ambitious role of CRPF or police personnel actively siding and helping RSS, VHP or Shivsena goons to target, burn and kill Muslims during state sponsored ‘Nationalist’ carnages?

Those who to this day couldn’t fathom India’s Brahminical politics, still wonder how a ‘Sober’, ‘Gentle’ or a ‘Saintly’ person like A.B. Vajpayee allowed the Gujarat carnage with such calm? They forget the fact that Vajpayee was nothing but a ‘Wolf in the guise of a Lamb’, as pointed out by Anil Dharkar, an eminent journalist in his Sunday column in ‘DNA’. Vajpayee, a staunch Brahmin successfully played the age old casteism card by using a Kshatriya, L. K. Advani (Home Minister of India) and a Shudra, Narendra Modi (Chief Minister of Gujarat) against general ‘Hindus’ by getting them ‘engaged’ in killing Muslims so that all the Bahujan Samaj and minorities remain engaged in constant battles of hatred against each other and no one should ever think of the Brahminical conspiracies and tyrannies against them. It is not surprising that today, the two ‘Crowned Heroes’, actually victims of Babri Mosque demolition and Gujarat carnage, are the most repentant figures in the Indian polity.

But the culprits of the nation, however ‘Nationalistic’, can’t be provided protection for a long time in the traditional misleading phenomenon of ‘Nationalism’. Weekly Outlook in its 19th July edition, carried an exhaustive story titled ‘Conspiracy of Silence’ about ‘Hindu Terrorism’, covering extensively from Samjhouta Express blast to Malegaon blast of 2008, which, under the honest and professional investigations of shaheed Hemant Karkare, proved to be the last nail in the coffin of the Brahminical Terror conspiracies. Outlook, in its eight page long story, unearthed the shocking truth about Samjhouta Express blast, which earlier was ‘presumably’ blamed on Pakistan’s ISI, exposing that when the office of the National Security Advisor, M. K. Narayanan was informed of the definite involvement of Hindu Terror Group from Madhya Pradesh in the Samjhouta blast, they immediately ‘Advised’ the agencies to stop the probe. And lo, the probe, in the ‘National interest’ was immediately stopped!

And, who can forget the brutal murder of Karkare, who also became the target of ‘National Interest’ on 26/11? It was evident from his investigations that some ‘High Profile’ Hindu leaders were not only involved in many of the bomb blasts, but were secretly conspiring against the very constitution of India. Former I.G.P. Maharashtra, S. M. Mushrif, in his landmark book, ‘Who Killed Karkare?’(Translated in seven languages so far) has categorically blamed Brahminical ‘IB’ for the killing of Karkare with the sole aim to protect the identities of those ‘Patriotic Leaders’. To this day, main stream TV channels, who keep on harping on minor issues like Burqa, Triple Talaq, Dowry and sex scandals who by splashing glorified debates like ‘Big Fight’, ‘Face the Nation’ and ‘Devil’s Advocate’, dared not invite or challenge Mushrif for his ‘Anti-National Stand’ on killing of Karkare. After the stormy release of its Marathi version in Pune recently, some committed ‘Nationalists’ demanded an immediate ban on the book. They even seem to have met the Police Commissioner of Pune with a firm demand to arrest Mushrif. But even the Commissioner doesn’t seem to take cognizance of an ‘Anti National’ right under his nose. What does this prove? Not only the commissioner, even the highest office bearers of this country that include Home Minister of India are religiously maintaining a ‘stunned silence’ on this vital issue that speaks volumes about our system’s credibility and commitment to the ‘TRUTH’, especially, when it comes to contradict majoritarians anti national sentiments. Jai ho.

Indian Secularism: majoritarian playground?

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

Just because some one wears "turban" and have beard, doesn't mean he is sikh. I have see pictures where a person with SIKH appearance attending RSS camp. In reality they are hindus from UP and Bihar, trying to creat confussion. Just few years back muslims and Sikh leaders in Delhi held a meeting to make sure everybody is aware of this. They even had sikh parade go through muslim dominated area of delhi.

Please don't try to portray that there are no sikhs in the RSS. I myself have quite a few sikh friends who have been active members of the RSS. It's just that some sikhs don't agree with their choice of RSS as an organization and try to distance themselves from the sikhs who DO join RSS.

 

[Gabbar]

Please don't try to portray that there are no sikhs in the RSS. I myself have quite a few sikh friends who have been active members of the RSS. It's just that some sikhs don't agree with their choice of RSS as an organization and try to distance themselves from the sikhs who DO join RSS.

I was merely telling what I know. You can share you opinion if you know more than I do.

 

[PakiiZeeshan]

Please don't try to portray that there are no sikhs in the RSS. I myself have quite a few sikh friends who have been active members of the RSS. It's just that some sikhs don't agree with their choice of RSS as an organization and try to distance themselves from the sikhs who DO join RSS.

Why would Sikhs join a hindu nationalist party ?

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

Why would Sikhs join a hindu nationalist party ?

This is only an example, but it clearly shows how much knowledge people have of the RSS. FYI, RSS, BJP and VHP are all different organizations. The RSS is NOT a party, BJP is.

There is a paranoia created about the RSS in our media and everyone seems to be blindly following it without doing some basic background research.

To answer you question, the RSS does not discriminate amongst its members on the basis of religion. It does not discriminate amongst those who receive their help either. It's a volunteer organization. Why would sikhs be averse to joining the RSS?

 

[Masterchief]

@pakiizeeshan: there are very few sikhs in RSS, and i see going by your posts that you dont like hindus much(just an assumption if i misinterpreted your earlier post than you can correct me on thir)

 

[S_O_C_O_M]

Is that our fault if pakistanis in america portray themselves to be indians because of the mess your politicians have put your country into?

That is the most disgusting thing I have ever heard.

Anyways no one would believe this because we don't look like you people.

Now tell me who looks more like a terrorist:

Shah Mahmood Qureshi

Fareed Zakaria

 

[jayron]

Indian Secularism: majoritarian playground?​

By Mushtaque Madni, The Milli Gazette
Published Online: Dec 25, 2010
Print Issue: 16-31 December 2010

Few days later, CNN-IBN, headed by a Brahmin Editor-in-Chief, Rajdeep Sardesai, held a debate on the issue of ‘Hindu Terror’ under the anchorship of Ms. Sagarika Ghose and a ‘simple’ question was displayed on the screen for the audience to answer. ‘Is it ‘unfair’ to term Sangh activities as Hindu terror?’ (Conspiracy to cause blasts and kill Muslims). The obvious answer was an overwhelming ‘YES’. Does one really need to be an intellectual to understand the underlying message that the channel intended to send by throwing a ‘suggestive’ question so that the sentiments of the Hindu majority did not get hurt? On July 26, Indian Express carried an exhaustive news item, where the investigation agencies officials, probing in the bomb blast cases, confessedly admitted to have been carried by the ‘Traditional Assuming Strategy’ that the people behind Mecca Masjid, Ajmer Sharif Dargah and Malegaon bomb blasts ought to be “Local Muslims’, who, with the help of Bangladeshi, Pakistani or even Al-Qaida terror outfits must have carried these blasts. In Pune, after the blast in German Bakery, ATS arrested a youth Abdul Samad from Bhatkal, who seemed to resemble the accused shown in the CCTV camera, despite the fact that the poor boy was attending a marriage ceremony in his village in Karnataka on the day of the blast. Subsequently, Samad was released honorably by the Court giving a fine punch to the ATS who was unfailingly and reportedly congratulated by the Hon’ble Home Minister ( A Tamil Brahmin) for nabbing the ‘culprit’ in just 100 days of the blast. But surprisingly, no newspaper reported Home Minister congratulating Rajasthan ATS when they arrested Devendra Gupta, an RSS pracharak, in connection with Ajmer blast. Given the above cited stray incident, ostensibly a straw from the huge ocean of our system’s systematic and well programmed torture tactics against Muslims, one is forced to believe that in the guise and garb of secularism India seems to have virtually become a playground for the majoritarians.

Do the investigating agencies world over probe cases on the basis of ‘Assumption or Presumption' or this special privilege is bestowed upon only on the Indian Agencies who, in many a case have actually acted like ‘Hindu Agencies’? Whether it is Kashmir, Gujarat or even Maharashtra, who can forget an ambitious role of CRPF or police personnel actively siding and helping RSS, VHP or Shivsena goons to target, burn and kill Muslims during state sponsored ‘Nationalist’ carnages?

Those who to this day couldn’t fathom India’s Brahminical politics, still wonder how a ‘Sober’, ‘Gentle’ or a ‘Saintly’ person like A.B. Vajpayee allowed the Gujarat carnage with such calm? They forget the fact that Vajpayee was nothing but a ‘Wolf in the guise of a Lamb’, as pointed out by Anil Dharkar, an eminent journalist in his Sunday column in ‘DNA’. Vajpayee, a staunch Brahmin successfully played the age old casteism card by using a Kshatriya, L. K. Advani (Home Minister of India) and a Shudra, Narendra Modi (Chief Minister of Gujarat) against general ‘Hindus’ by getting them ‘engaged’ in killing Muslims so that all the Bahujan Samaj and minorities remain engaged in constant battles of hatred against each other and no one should ever think of the Brahminical conspiracies and tyrannies against them. It is not surprising that today, the two ‘Crowned Heroes’, actually victims of Babri Mosque demolition and Gujarat carnage, are the most repentant figures in the Indian polity.

But the culprits of the nation, however ‘Nationalistic’, can’t be provided protection for a long time in the traditional misleading phenomenon of ‘Nationalism’. Weekly Outlook in its 19th July edition, carried an exhaustive story titled ‘Conspiracy of Silence’ about ‘Hindu Terrorism’, covering extensively from Samjhouta Express blast to Malegaon blast of 2008, which, under the honest and professional investigations of shaheed Hemant Karkare, proved to be the last nail in the coffin of the Brahminical Terror conspiracies. Outlook, in its eight page long story, unearthed the shocking truth about Samjhouta Express blast, which earlier was ‘presumably’ blamed on Pakistan’s ISI, exposing that when the office of the National Security Advisor, M. K. Narayanan was informed of the definite involvement of Hindu Terror Group from Madhya Pradesh in the Samjhouta blast, they immediately ‘Advised’ the agencies to stop the probe. And lo, the probe, in the ‘National interest’ was immediately stopped!

Indian Secularism: majoritarian playground?

WAHT A LOAD OF BULL SH1T!

He just thinks all Indians in power are Brahmins? To start with P. Chidambaram is not a brahmin but a Chetti who tend to be anti-brahmin. He is one who first voiced his concern for saffron terror, right in time for elections. I agree that some Hindus have Fascistic ideologies but it has nothing to do with caste.

Nice way to twist the facts to feed the target audience what they want to hear and spread hate.

 

[LURKER]

Why would Sikhs join a hindu nationalist party ?

muslims aslo join RSS.
RSS has its muslim wing .

Muslim Rashtriya Manch - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Gabbar]

Seriously?? No i mean seriously?

Of course, he is entitled to his own opinion as everyone else is but if that opinion offends or mentions anyone else than that individual has every right to debate!!

And this wasn't HIS OPINION!! An opinion is a subjective statement or thought about an issue or topic, and is the result of emotion or interpretation of facts.

Look at the heading and you'd find a question mark [and i'm sure it wasn't rhitorical question either] ??!!

I can't believe you're taking his side!! Have you even been reading his threads lately??!

You should also read my response(s) to his threads. I know what you talking about but proper response is the best remedy. We DEBATE on this site, if your response is proper, he will stop debating you. Personal response will only derail the thread.

 

[somebozo]

Western democracy would not be complete without the christian influence simply because they are the majority..same applies to india..after all democracy is the rule of majority if the majority wants to adopt a hindu culture then there is nothing stopping them...We have our own country to manage to let us not sneak peek into our neighbor..if we work towards developing our political system our democracy will also express the colors of Islam.

 

[TechLahore]

Discuss the article. If there's any more off topic ranting I will now hand out bans. I am extremely amazed to see supposedly serious posters indulging in the most petty racist dialog. Shame.