What's new

Indian police wrongly target Muslims

53fd

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
A recently retired judge from the Indian Supreme Court has launched a blistering attack on the country's police, accusing them of falsely implicating local Muslims in bomb attacks.

Markandey Katju, who retired from the top court last month, said Indian police were poorly trained in forensic investigations which meant they were unable to crack terror attack cases.

"The point is that they cannot catch the real culprits, so whomever they think may have committed the crime they catch hold of them," he said in an interview with cable news network NDTV broadcast late on Monday.

Training and equipment to conduct scientific investigations "is absent in India so it is done by suspicion. Some bomb blast takes place, they catch hold of the local Muslims and young people and implicate them," he added.

A string of bombings over the last two years have gone unsolved, including attacks on the IT hub of Bangalore, the holy city of Varanasi, the western city of Pune, commercial capital Mumbai and most recently New Delhi.

Katju said torture was regularly used to extract confessions, particularly in rural areas where local police inspectors needed to show quick results after a crime.

In the most recent miscarriage of justice highlighted in the Indian media, Imran Kirmani, a Kashmiri Muslim, was released after four and half years in jail after being falsely accused of plotting a major terror strike in 2006.

Katju, who is now head of the Press Council of India, said he was still in favour of the death penalty despite the problems in catching the real culprits.

During his time in the top court, he argued in favour of the death penalty for policemen found to have executed suspects, as well as perpetrators of so-called "honour killings" and murders motivated by dowry payments.

Capital punishment can be handed down by an Indian judge as a sentence for the "rarest of rare" crimes.

Indian bomb probes wrongly target Muslims: judge - Yahoo! News
 
.
Here we go again , where are the disoriented Ind muslims on the board ? Expect Ejaz , Fateh , Raiz Mhd to come and 'deny' this report. Where can i find the ostrich hiding its head in the sand pic bilal ;)
 
. .
Which police force in the world picks up the correct susects in the first atttempt ?

LOL and BTW Pakistanis must be the last ones gloating over this as we very well know how their elite constables are (Qadri), the supposedly super dooper Rangers are (Karaachi shooting) and their FC is (Karotabad massacre).

Please guys we know what to do east of the Inddo-pak border. Worry about the badlands in the west.

Here we go again , where are the disoriented Ind muslims on the board ? Expect Ejaz , Fateh , Raiz Mhd to come and 'deny' this report. Where can i find the ostrich hiding its head in the sand pic bilal ;)

He is not a Muslim AFAIK.

But then even if he is a Muslim whats wrong in he defending India as here people think first as indians and then as Hindus/Muslims etc.

Oh,I get it ..I am talking to a Pakistani..who is Muslims first, Punjabi/Baloch/Sindhi second and Pak third.
 
. .
Which police force in the world picks up the correct susects in the first atttempt ?

LOL and BTW Pakistanis must be the last ones gloating over this as we very well know how their elite constables are (Qadri), the supposedly super dooper Rangers are (Karaachi shooting) and their FC is (Karotabad massacre).

Please guys we know what to do east of the Inddo-pak border. Worry about the badlands in the west.



He is not a Muslim AFAIK.

But then even if he is a Muslim whats wrong in he defending India as here people think first as indians and then as Hindus/Muslims etc.

Oh,I get it ..I am talking to a Pakistani..who is Muslims first, Punjabi/Baloch/Sindhi second and Pak third.

Discrimination and injustice towards minorities exist in every society. But to try to correct them is a sign of a civilized nation.
Can u tell the same thing about u guys in Pakistan?

Hindus have been routinely targeted. Hindu women are kidnapped, raped and forcibly converted in Pakistan. That is one messed up country.

Sorry for being offtopic. But iam fed up with Pakistanis holier than thou attitude here. Or do pakistanis think the muslims have the right to exist peacefully every where and hindus to be murdered.


Thread has nothing to do with Pakistan.
 
.
All said and done we have to modernise and improve the training standards of our police force. Forensic techniques are lacking here, After an incident, the police should immediately cordon off the area to preserve all evidence, instead, they allow people to trample all over the blast site thereby losing crucial clues. Also this trend of VIPs rushing to the site, whether of a bomb blast or earthquake has to be stopped forthwith.
 
.
Because of a few retards who try their level best to portray their terrorism as something "islamic",other innocent muslims needlessly come under suspecion.Good to see supreme court urging police to be more careful in these matters.
 
.
All said and done we have to modernise and improve the training standards of our police force. Forensic techniques are lacking here, After an incident, the police should immediately cordon off the area to preserve all evidence, instead, they allow people to trample all over the blast site thereby losing crucial clues. Also this trend of VIPs rushing to the site, whether of a bomb blast or earthquake has to be stopped forthwith.

Thank you for the succinct post.

As you are one of the most respectable members here, I'll just ask you (rather than others who have posted on this forum) on your opinion here:

I've always thought that Indian Muslims were more prone to being targeted wrongfully than other groups. This article, along with the Swami Aseemanand trial, the exposed Hindutva activities in Rajasthan (Ajmer Sharif), Hyderabad (Mecca Masjid), Malegaon, Samjhota Express bombing etc seem to support my argument.

Do you agree with my assertion, that Indian Muslims are more prone towards being targeted by police? And what about their court indictments & convictions?
 
.
Discrimination and injustice towards minorities exist in Indian society.
Indian Police always want to find Muslims as a scrape goat.
They will arrest a Muslim guy and end his carrer and family and later release him with no evidence found and that too without any compenstation.
No Action on Police for falsely Implicating that Person.

Mangalore/ Hydrabad / Samjhautha all Muslim were arrested, even they had no hand all done by Hindu Orthadox.

Sometime I feel sad about these, and scared about this may lead to some Spring in India as well.

End of the day Blame the Congress for this Mess
 
.
Policing is always bad in S. Asia. Our police still lives in the pre-British era.

Thats the problem.
 
.
The now well tamed indian muslim brigade- where are they?-
 
.
targeting innocent muslim is wrong but you cannot tell a person is innocent or not just by looking at him,its the extremists muslim organisations like simi,im,let,etc which fuel the distrust with muslims
 
. . .

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom