Indian Govt Warns Pakistan; Asks To Vacate Gilgit Baltistan

[Jackdaws]

so you also vacate IOK Pakistan always saying that, you have a verbal not us

This is a circular argument. Have it with someone else.

 

[Ultima Thule]

first of all its not occupied, its signed and integrated with India with instrument of accession. and you vacate the entire GB to conduct a fair plebiscite.

instrument of accession is nothing, its incomplete agenda of independence of the subcontinent, you not give the right of choosing of which country they wanna live Pakistan or India in 47

 

[Jackdaws]

It is not as straightforward. Nothing really is in the subcontinent.

If I recall correctly, Gilgit was administered by a British political agent since late 1800s. The Maharaja on J&K appointed Ghansara Singh at the end, when he sensed the end of British rule in India. There was no Dogra governor previously. The British political agent took offense to the attempt of the Maharaja to establish his rule over territory that was controlled by the British, and deposed Ghansara Singh as you note.

I think it is safe to say was disagreement between the Maharaja and British over whose jurisdiction Gilgit came under.

Will read up

 

[drumstick]

instrument of accession is nothing, its incomplete agenda of independence of the subcontinent, you not give the right of choosing of which country they wanna live Pakistan or India in 47

that is why no one takes you seriously... when you reject such documents it leads to more serious escalations. And where does your official statement says what you mentioned? and BTW is this the same stand of you FO or government?

 

[Ultima Thule]

that is why no one takes you seriously... when you reject such documents it leads to more serious escalations. And where does your official statement says what you mentioned? and BTW is this the same stand of you FO or government?

That's why world takes its seriously and this issue had UN resolutions on it

 

[Sheikh Rauf]

buddhist heritage sites should be saved .

You worry not we will hand over dalai lama once occupied Kashmir we librate.

 

[wali87]

To complete that project you need to get Burma [Myanmar] integrated, British flag hoisted and convince Prince Charles to occupy Vicroy House as new Viceroy.

And get the Queen designated as Emperor of India.

In order to do that, they have to make United Kingdom a superpower again. Now that they are one as well.

 

[doorstar]

shit the fcuk up raja was nothing but planted by Britishers

was maharaja kana singh of Punjab a "Britisher"?

Governor named Ghansara Singh who was deposed by a British officer leading the Gilgit Scouts.

on what date did mr. singh become the governor of GB? and was it not more like he was arrested on his way to becoming a governor rather than deposed as a sitting one??

I am now doubting that such a clown was ever in charge of a tea stall let alone a country of a billion.

it has been debunked, chronology is all wrong.

it was never true, was just a gimmick to raise the morale of the countless 100s of million starving to make them believe that if a tea-seller can become the PM they too would be someone big one day.

 

[xeuss]

on what date mr. singh become the governor of GB? and was it not more like he was arrested on his way to becoming a governor rather than deposed as a sitting one??

It was in Aug 1947....just days before independence from the British. I am not sure about the circumstances.

 

[doorstar]

It was in Aug 1947....just days before independence from the British. I am not sure about the circumstances.

knew that, was just trying to figure out the mentality of your sanghi akhand bharati compatriot. looks to me as if he is rearranging the chronology of events

 

[xeuss]

knew that, was just trying to figure out the mentality of your sanghi akhand bharati compatriot. looks to me as if he is rearranging the chronology of events

@Jackdaws is not a Sanghi. Use that nomenclature on those that deserve the tag.

 

[GHALIB]

This is BS....I know this area very well and Buddhist site as well as hindu temples are safe as anything. Here is a picture of a hindu temple near Chakwal and Julian monastery. But we would love for india to interveneView attachment 638394 View attachment 638395
I took these pictures

sad state of preservance of hindu mandir and water body .

 

[PakGuns]

 

[doorstar]

@Jackdaws is not a Sanghi. Use that nomenclature on those that deserve the tag.

so just a liar then? I thought rewriting history was a sanghi pass-time. I stand corrected, so...it is a common trait of you all?

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

The entire Narendra Modi cabinet is an embarrassment to India. Particularly these worthless stupid uneducated ministers such as Rajnath Singh, Harshvardhan, Rajvendra Singh Rathore, Piyush Goyel, and others. Indians should now know the real reasons why we are being taken less seriously on the international stage ever since BJP came to power. It is these stupid ministers in high ranks. They are completely useless for all purpose.

Sure India has been claiming Gilgit-Baltistan since 1947. But a diplomatic protocol used to be followed. On all official memorandums, those areas were collectively referred by Indian ambassadors abroad as "Pakistan Occupied Kashmir" (even GB) and the official word was to resolve the areas under UN Resolution. The same with Pakistan that claims Indian side of Kashmir as 'Indian Occupied Kashmir".

I don't think Indian government made empty threats like these for those territories before 2014. Both countries followed an unspoken code of conduct on how to refer the territories in their respective media.

Just because Donald Trump is being Modi's adopted father, these brainless twits of BJP think that now time is ripe to issue empty threats to Pakistan, that too when it will be backed by China. No Uncle Sam is going to fight India's battles in Kashmir.

There are many other disputed territories in this world. Northern Cyprus is claimed by both Greece and Turkey, Taiwan is claimed by the People's Republic of China. But no countries issue empty threats to take over unless they seriously plan to do it.

The more Narendra Modi exposes himself as a hot air balloon, the more India's international image suffers. I don't think India can take over GB or AJK militarily, so all this posturing is doing more harm than good. It might win BJP the 2024 election but it will also cost India some of its territories in Kashmir and Ladakh.

When will Indians stop living in denial and fire the entire Narendra Modi cabinet, and replace them with more capable persons.

Too Bee Fair as much as I hate india and indians, I have to admit that between the 1960s & 2010s, india produced excellent, high quality educated leaders who did an impressive job for their nation and people. During those times, it was possible for india to potentially be able to compete with China. Not anymore. Despite what modi and other indian leaders say nowadays, everything they do seems to be bad for india. It's almost as if they are working for powers who are anti-indian. Stranger things have happened.