What's new

India rejects Pakistan's help in SAARC satellite project

The Huskar

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 3, 2014
Messages
1,395
Reaction score
2
Country
India
Location
India
NEW DELHI: India has rejected Pakistan's offer to provide "technical" and "monetary" support to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's ambitious SAARC satellite project, maintaining that it was a "gift" by the country to its neighbours.

During a meeting of space experts from SAARC countries to discuss the modalities of the project last week, India also did not favour suggestions that it should be brought under the ambit of SAARC, asserting that deliberations at bloc level would delay the launch of the satellite on December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day when the government intends to do so.

Modi, during last SAARC Summit in Nepal in November, had announced India's decision to develop the satellite which will benefit all SAARC countries in various fields including telecommunication and tele-medicine.

After giving "cold response" to the project, an eight- member Pakistani delegation attended the Space Technology meet on June 22 which saw the presence of experts from all SAARC member states. Among the South Asian nations, Sri Lanka and Pakistan have fairly advanced space programmes.

"There was a proposal from the Pakistani side that it was ready to offer monetary and technical support. We politely declined it as the project is a gift from India to its SAARC neighbours," said a senior government official.

It has also declined demands from Pakistan that the satellite project should be taken up at the regional level. India said since it was a "gift" to its neighbours, it did not want to make it a "SAARC project".

"This would have meant deliberations and opinions from other countries and that would have taken time. The Prime Minister has specifically said that it was India's gift to its neighbours.

"There are so many other aspects that are involved. For instance, with the project comes the cost. Not all countries would be able to pay the cost and that would have held up the project. And we intend to complete by December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day," the official said.

However, the official said India was very much "open" to consultations from other SAARC nations on their requirements from the project. Several countries have given their "wish list", but the satellite would primarily be for communication purposes, the official added.
 
If not for monetary support , atleast we should have accepted their technical support
 
NEW DELHI: India has rejected Pakistan's offer to provide "technical" and "monetary" support to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's ambitious SAARC satellite project, maintaining that it was a "gift" by the country to its neighbours.

During a meeting of space experts from SAARC countries to discuss the modalities of the project last week, India also did not favour suggestions that it should be brought under the ambit of SAARC, asserting that deliberations at bloc level would delay the launch of the satellite on December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day when the government intends to do so.

Modi, during last SAARC Summit in Nepal in November, had announced India's decision to develop the satellite which will benefit all SAARC countries in various fields including telecommunication and tele-medicine.

After giving "cold response" to the project, an eight- member Pakistani delegation attended the Space Technology meet on June 22 which saw the presence of experts from all SAARC member states. Among the South Asian nations, Sri Lanka and Pakistan have fairly advanced space programmes.

"There was a proposal from the Pakistani side that it was ready to offer monetary and technical support. We politely declined it as the project is a gift from India to its SAARC neighbours," said a senior government official.

It has also declined demands from Pakistan that the satellite project should be taken up at the regional level. India said since it was a "gift" to its neighbours, it did not want to make it a "SAARC project".

"This would have meant deliberations and opinions from other countries and that would have taken time. The Prime Minister has specifically said that it was India's gift to its neighbours.

"There are so many other aspects that are involved. For instance, with the project comes the cost. Not all countries would be able to pay the cost and that would have held up the project. And we intend to complete by December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day," the official said.

However, the official said India was very much "open" to consultations from other SAARC nations on their requirements from the project. Several countries have given their "wish list", but the satellite would primarily be for communication purposes, the official added.

SAARC satellite will help integrate the region even further
 
If not for monetary support , atleast we should have accepted their technical support

They don't have technical knowledge of developing there own satellite then how can they help for this one ! I believe India does not want pakistan input so not to delay further project and/or we don't want satellite designs leaks and its purpose.
 
The reason why modi rejected is clear...

1)

2) This is India's gift to SAARC countries
[QUOTE="The Huskar, post: 7334657, member: 156691"]India also did not favour suggestions that it should be brought under the ambit of SAARC,
[/QUOTE]

I would personally hate this condescending attitude of India, unless it is politics and getting back at Pakistan.
 
"Dehati Aurat" is never satisfied.


All this time they were whining why Pakistan was not giving any sort of help for the SAARC satellite project.

And now they are whining why Pakistan is giving help?

What should we call it? Hormonal mood swings? :lol:
 
It is not about Money and Technical support, it is about politics.

This is India's way of getting back at Pakistan for its initial rejection in participating in the project.
Is it a SAARC project or not? India says it's not a SAARC project, so how could Pakistan refuse involvement in it under the aegis of SAARC?

And when did Pakistan refuse to collaborate on this satellite project?
 
I would personally hate this condescending attitude of India, unless it is politics and getting back at Pakistan.
whoa!
This is supposed to be India's gift to SAARC so am not surprised that India did not accept Pakistan's monetary help with alacrity.
Lets face it, no other SAARC country has a space agency as developed as ISRO, so the contribution to such a project would have largely come from Indian side.
Also involving other agencies would mean delaying the project further, so it sounds completely logical to me that Modi decided to keep this project under India's wings.
 
NEW DELHI: India has rejected Pakistan's offer to provide "technical" and "monetary" support to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's ambitious SAARC satellite project, maintaining that it was a "gift" by the country to its neighbours.

During a meeting of space experts from SAARC countries to discuss the modalities of the project last week, India also did not favour suggestions that it should be brought under the ambit of SAARC, asserting that deliberations at bloc level would delay the launch of the satellite on December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day when the government intends to do so.

Modi, during last SAARC Summit in Nepal in November, had announced India's decision to develop the satellite which will benefit all SAARC countries in various fields including telecommunication and tele-medicine.

After giving "cold response" to the project, an eight- member Pakistani delegation attended the Space Technology meet on June 22 which saw the presence of experts from all SAARC member states. Among the South Asian nations, Sri Lanka and Pakistan have fairly advanced space programmes.

"There was a proposal from the Pakistani side that it was ready to offer monetary and technical support. We politely declined it as the project is a gift from India to its SAARC neighbours," said a senior government official.

It has also declined demands from Pakistan that the satellite project should be taken up at the regional level. India said since it was a "gift" to its neighbours, it did not want to make it a "SAARC project".

"This would have meant deliberations and opinions from other countries and that would have taken time. The Prime Minister has specifically said that it was India's gift to its neighbours.

"There are so many other aspects that are involved. For instance, with the project comes the cost. Not all countries would be able to pay the cost and that would have held up the project. And we intend to complete by December 8, 2016, the SAARC Day," the official said.

However, the official said India was very much "open" to consultations from other SAARC nations on their requirements from the project. Several countries have given their "wish list", but the satellite would primarily be for communication purposes, the official added.
Wow!, satellite is for SAARC countries but they are not allowed to cooperate in SAARC project..
 
I would personally hate this condescending attitude of India, unless it is politics and getting back at Pakistan.

You can either have your pride or you can sacrifice your pride and get the money. You can't have both.

India is paying for the satellite, so there is no reason to allow others to call the shots.
 
Back
Top Bottom