India planning to send 15,000 troops to Afghanistan

[padamchen]

We don't need it. Few 100 casualties and indians will be in streets asking for retreat..We are only supportive when our own nation is under attack.
And besides foreign boots on ground,specially "kufr hindus" will be propaganda boost for Taliban.

Do you have any idea how many of our soldiers have died anonymously in peace keeping missions for the UN?

 

[Tea addict]

Do you have any idea how many of our soldiers have died anonymously in peace keeping missions for the UN?

UN is not something to be compared with foreign deployment..ANA need good JCO,Captain,Majors...well educated afghans studying in indian are best for that role..if they volunteer.

 

[kris]

we won't allow India to make another local on our western border.

it already is, u r not seeing it yet
getting into dirty war in afghanistan is a foolish thing to do, but by the mere presence it eases pressure of afghan forces a lot and gets them chance to improve

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

This is basically the handover from American to Indian forces that Obama spoke about towards the end of his second term.

The Afghans and us are partners now. And so are the Iranians.

Pakistan's attempt to pull out of the Saudi alliance is going to now be too late. You played your hand, and showed the Iranians where your loyalties lay.

 

[padamchen]

it already is, u r not seeing it yet
getting into dirty war in afghanistan is a foolish thing to do, but by the mere presence it eases pressure of afghan forces a lot and gets them chance to improve

Bro, the Pakistani forces know well who they have been fighting in the recent past.

The recent "ANA" successes and raids.

You do not have two armies fighting each other and stationed eyeball to eyeball for 70 years without knowing each others unique signatures.

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

Right now only we Pakistanis are geeting coffins because we can't secure our western borders ..Afghans love India and if they call India we just need to cut off and close our borders simple ..we will continue to blood if the borders are kept open

to stop next kalboshan you need to hit them in their nest

 

[kris]

no one dare to send their solders in that hell hole

true to some extent

 

[Crixus]

It will be better option if we pay the salaries of 15000 afghan troops instead of sending our soldiers there or we can open almost 70-80 hospitals in the same price of stationing 15000 soldiers there ....... seems like a fake news , we never send our soldiers unless until they are under UN flag

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

Don't worry after Chabahar project completes we are going to send troops & warships there too.

good. if Iranians do this then we will simply give bases to China and ksa.

 

[kris]

Bro, the Pakistani forces know well who they have been fighting in the recent past.

The recent "ANA" successes and raids.

You do not have two armies fighting each other and stationed eyeball to eyeball for 70 years without knowing each others unique signatures.

do you say that IA did/assisted these

 

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

This is basically the handover from American to Indian forces that Obama spoke about towards the end of his second term.

The Afghans and us are partners now. And so are the Iranians.

Pakistan's attempt to pull out of the Saudi alliance is going to now be too late. You played your hand, and showed the Iranians where your loyalties lay.

do inda have trillions of dollars to fight this war?
do Indians have any friendly relations with Pakistan to support you like we supported US?

do you have the guts to target alqaeda militants inside Pakistan without retaliation? you are not US.

how will you face stingers which we arent provided to Taliban yet?
what about unknown bakhar shikan in Afghanistan?

what about the fact that Pakistan will be free to Interfere in Afghanistan without any international pressure due to our security concerns?

and not to forget maulana sami ul haq can alone handle you in Afghanistan.

about Iran. I think you forgot what happened to them in Afghanistan last time they fought a proxy against us.

UN is not something to be compared with foreign deployment..ANA need good JCO,Captain,Majors...well educated afghans studying in indian are best for that role..if they volunteer.

Taliban who represent majority of afghans and control half of Afghanistan also needs good fighters and weapon suppliers. good army officers are urgently required too.

 

[Arsalan 345]

I think it's not only Indian decision.Americans are trying very hard to put some pressure over pak army and this decision shows that america is no more a friendly country.India might send troops and CIA might allow them to operate freely.this is just to put Pakistan under pressure from afghan border. If this happens,you can see Indian army near our afghan border which will create panic but we have our own methods.China and Russia are two major forces waiting to intervene in afghan conflict.China specially will not sit back.this will counter american intentions and for Indian chest thumping inside Afghanistan, Pakistan can simply use Kashmir. Pakistan knows Indian weakness as well.if you start a game of covering us from afghan border,we will counter it using pla on Kashmir border they are already there but huge number of indian soldiers on afghan border means huge number of pla troops on Kashmir border.

 

[Theparadox]

good. if Iranians do this then we will simply give bases to China and ksa.

It's not in your power anyway China is already there. I would love to see ksa doing the same.

 

[Tea addict]

Taliban who represent majority of afghans and control half of Afghanistan also needs good fighters and weapon suppliers. good army officers are urgently required too

You don't need good army officers to be sheeps of foreigners and mullahs.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Indian Army could use some international experience and Afghans think positively about India. Will be interesting to see where this goes.