India formally start exports to Afghanistan via Chabahar with 1.1m tons of wheat

[Max]

Who cares if India joins or not ,they will be collecting 3 times the Pakistans GDP as tolls from Chinese trucks .it's already a success according to Pakistanies even though they don't have money to pay the instalment in March


You can build a wall ,but the recruts have been coming from the 165 million Pakistanies inside

they recruited bcoz govt never enforced writ on those regions for 65 years, they were open for all which was biggest crime of our rulling elite. Now we have established our writ for the first time in fata and building fence on the border.. Things are already improving but we need fence on war footing, i cant wait for 2 more years.

Great.



Well Iran has been waiting for years for Pakistan to complete its side of the pipeline and it's still waiting. Not sure how "open" you are.

we can not pay you for rich Iranian energy.. @Raghfarm007 @Fafnir said so.. Let us poor deal with GCC for cheap oil and gas.

You should worry about losing exisiting marke to Yanks, Yanks are offering cheap merican oil to our eastern neighbour so they stop imports from Iran.

 

[Guardians of the Galaxy]

Wheat?!!!!
They cant even grow there own food in Afghanistan? with such a tiny population and pretty Huge landmass comparing to the population.

Bring out a map. Locate the arable regions. Identify those of them that are still stable and peaceful and conducive. You will get the answers you want.

90% of the country is captured by separate groups, if any feasible land is available thet is being used for growing opium & other high cash drugs for financially aiding the ongoing war.

 

[Tom M]

We were waiting for your trade route to start so we can send them to you... they come from a place called Hindu-Kush... will make lovely neighbours...

Come on you love them folks.... Or is it more of the "moo par ram ram baghaal may chooree" for the afghans?

We may just have to dump them on you border... have fun...

The refugee crisis whatsoever is your own, I mean Pakistan also have a major hand in that. So bare with it and be happy.

they recruited bcoz govt never enforced writ on those regions for 65 years, they were open for all which was biggest crime of our rulling elite. Now we have established our writ for the first time in fata and building fence on the border.. Things are already improving but we need fence on war footing, i cant wait for 2 more years.

Now who's mistake is that ????? But did Pakistan learn a thing or two from that ?? I'm afraid not.

If 15 out of the 20 Points in your NAP is not touched, let alone Implemented I'm sorry to say, your government and establishment is not serious enough to tackle these menace. For example;

• After the Peshawar incident, government decided to proceed with the execution of extremists convicted in terror related cases. The Government has already started implementation.
• Special courts, headed by the officers of the armed forces, will be established for the speedy trial of terrorists. These courts will be established for a term of two years.
• Formation of armed militia will not be allowed in the country.
• National Counter Terrorism Authority will be revived and made effective
• There will be a crackdown on hate-speech, and action will be taken against newspapers, magazines contributing to the spread of such speech.
• Financial sources of terrorists and terror organisations will be cut.
• Banned outfits will not be allowed to operate under different names.
• Special anti-terrorism force will be raised.
• Measures will be taken to stop religious extremism and to protect minorities.
• Madrassas will be regularized and reformed.
• Print and electronic media will not be allowed to give any space to terrorists.
• Keeping the rehabilitation of IDPs as the top-most priority, administrative and development reforms in FATA will be expedited.
• Communication systems of terrorist organisations will be destroyed.
• Social media and the Internet will not be allowed to be used by terrorists to spread propaganda and hate speech, though exact process for that will be finalized.
• Like the rest of the country, no space will be given to extremism in any part of the Punjab.
• Operation against terrorists in Karachi will be taken to its logical conclusion.
• In the interest of political reconciliation, Baluchistan government will be given complete authority by all stakeholders.
• Elements spreading sectarian violence will be prosecuted.
• Comprehensive policy will be formed for registration of Afghan refugees.
• To give provincial intelligence agencies access to communication of terrorists and to strengthen anti-terror agencies through basic reforms in the criminal justice system. Constitutional amendments and legislation will be carried out for this purpose.

And I'm not the one who says so, there are lot of saner voice in Pakistan who also say so, I'm just highlighting things they keep on saying.



we can not pay you for rich Iranian energy.. @Raghfarm007 @Fafnir said so.. Let us poor deal with GCC for cheap oil and gas.

You should worry about losing exisiting marke to Yanks, Yanks are offering cheap merican oil to our eastern neighbour so they stop imports from Iran.[/QUOTE]

Don't worry, now who knows if we Indian's become the mediator in making a great deal between Iran and the Yankees. If that is successful ever. That will be a great thing for India-Iran-Afghanistan. I know it's highly unlikely given the opposition from GCC and Israel, but still there are rooms for healthy engagements which can be a win-win for all you know.

 

[Baby Leone]

so mighty india exporting her food to Afghanistan meanwhile in India:

https://scroll.in/article/819052/hu...-even-today-so-why-dont-we-ever-hear-about-it

is that chabahar port's grave in the start

 

[prashantazazel]

Any thing which can be cultivated is used to grow bumper crops of charas and opium

There is a scarcity of medicinal opium in the world.

 

[Tom M]

so mighty india exporting her food to Afghanistan meanwhile in India:

https://scroll.in/article/819052/hu...-even-today-so-why-dont-we-ever-hear-about-it

Yes, we are, while some people wish to believe that they are better off in GHI rankings.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1529406/pakistans-20-population-underfed-report-reveals/

 

[Han Patriot]

Yes, we are, while some people wish to believe that they are better off in GHI rankings.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1529406/pakistans-20-population-underfed-report-reveals/

One question, the Indian berth is not ready yet, so does it mean India is just exporting grain to Iran and then transporting it to Afghanistan? Then India wouldn't need a special berth in the first place right?

 

[egodoc222]

so mighty india exporting her food to Afghanistan meanwhile in India:

https://scroll.in/article/819052/hu...-even-today-so-why-dont-we-ever-hear-about-it


is that chabahar port's grave in the start

I get that you don't have roads where u come from...that is called a 'milestone'!

 

[Tom M]

One question, the Indian berth is not ready yet, so does it mean India is just exporting grain to Iran and then transporting it to Afghanistan? Then India wouldn't need a special berth in the first place right?

Politely, It's non of anyone's business either way, I guess ???

 

[jaiind]

Can we also send India the 5 to 7 Million Afghan refugees in Pakistan to India please?

As a Muslim nation why don't you take rohingyas from myanamar and Bangladesh to appease them.

 

[Han Patriot]

Politely, It's non of anyone's business either way, I guess ???

Ok, jus wondering why waster a few hundred million$ when you could have just rented a berth from the Iranians.

 

[Max]

The refugee crisis whatsoever is your won, I mean Pakistan also have a major hand in that. So bare with it and be happy.



Now who's mistake is that ????? But did Pakistan learn a thing or two from that ?? I'm afraid not.

If 15 out of the 20 Points in your NAP is not touched, let alone Implemented I'm sorry to say, your government and establishment is not serious enough to tackle these menace. For example;

• After the Peshawar incident, government decided to proceed with the execution of extremists convicted in terror related cases. The Government has already started implementation.
• Special courts, headed by the officers of the armed forces, will be established for the speedy trial of terrorists. These courts will be established for a term of two years.
• Formation of armed militia will not be allowed in the country.
• National Counter Terrorism Authority will be revived and made effective
• There will be a crackdown on hate-speech, and action will be taken against newspapers, magazines contributing to the spread of such speech.
• Financial sources of terrorists and terror organisations will be cut.
• Banned outfits will not be allowed to operate under different names.
• Special anti-terrorism force will be raised.
• Measures will be taken to stop religious extremism and to protect minorities.
• Madrassas will be regularized and reformed.
• Print and electronic media will not be allowed to give any space to terrorists.
• Keeping the rehabilitation of IDPs as the top-most priority, administrative and development reforms in FATA will be expedited.
• Communication systems of terrorist organisations will be destroyed.
• Social media and the Internet will not be allowed to be used by terrorists to spread propaganda and hate speech, though exact process for that will be finalized.
• Like the rest of the country, no space will be given to extremism in any part of the Punjab.
• Operation against terrorists in Karachi will be taken to its logical conclusion.
• In the interest of political reconciliation, Baluchistan government will be given complete authority by all stakeholders.
• Elements spreading sectarian violence will be prosecuted.
• Comprehensive policy will be formed for registration of Afghan refugees.
• To give provincial intelligence agencies access to communication of terrorists and to strengthen anti-terror agencies through basic reforms in the criminal justice system. Constitutional amendments and legislation will be carried out for this purpose.

And I'm not the one who says so, there are lot of saner voice in Pakistan who also say so, I'm just highlighting things they keep on saying.



we can not pay you for rich Iranian energy.. @Raghfarm007 @Fafnir said so.. Let us poor deal with GCC for cheap oil and gas.

You should worry about losing exisiting marke to Yanks, Yanks are offering cheap merican oil to our eastern neighbour so they stop imports from Iran.

Don't worry, now who knows if we Indian's become the mediator in making a great deal between Iran and the Yankees. If that is successful ever. That will be a great thing for India-Iran-Afghanistan. I know it's highly unlikely given the opposition from GCC and Israel, but still there are rooms for healthy engagements which can be a win-win for all you know. [/QUOTE]

another wet dream, anyways good luck in convincing the yanks, its not yanks which see Iran as problem, its your zionist freinds and GCC Arabs... Try to convince them instead..

well, its not like we are not doing anything and security situation improving itself, we are doing right things too. Govt regularly hold meetings on National action plan with all provincial govts and things will further improve gradually.

 

[Tom M]

another wet dream, anyways good luck in convincing the yanks, its not yanks which see Iran as problem, its your zionist freinds and GCC Arabs... Try to convince them instead..

well, its not like we are not doing anything and security situation improving itself, we are doing right things too. Govt regularly hold meetings on National action plan with all provincial govts and things will further improve gradually.

Thanks for wishing us good luck.

But don't be so naive to think that avoiding Afghanistan market and providing it exclusively to India is a good Idea, an in this case it will be both Afghanistan and Iran down the road.

Please listen to the below video and find who people in Pakistan are concerned, especially the traders and chamber of commerce.

 

[RoadRunner401]

Ok, jus wondering why waster a few hundred million$ when you could have just rented a berth from the Iranians.

The only reason Iranians allowed the Indians to build this port is because they themselves needed deep seaport, renting out a berth to Indians wouldn't have achieved the end results Iranians were looking for.

 

[Max]

Thanks for wishing us good luck.

But don't be so naive to think that avoiding Afghanistan market and providing it exclusively to India is a good Idea, an in this case it will be both Afghanistan and Iran down the road.

Please listen to the below video and find who people in Pakistan are concerned, especially the traders and chamber of commerce.

since when you start caring about us, Afghanistan mubarak ho.