What's new

India compels Pakistan to make difficult choices for survival: ex Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee retired Gen Zubair Hayat

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
ISLAMABAD: Continuing existential challenges due to hostile neighbourhood compel Pakistan to make difficult choices for survival.

This was the crux of a discussion on the first day of Islamabad Conclave-2022 themed ‘75 Years of Independence: Achieving Comprehensive National Security’, which was hosted by Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad (ISSI).

Former Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee retired Gen Zubair Hayat, in his keynote speech, said the threat from India, which has been reluctant to accept Pakistan’s existence and posed challenges at variety of fronts and spectrums, had not diminished.

He recalled the statements by Indian leaders in which they mentioned the 1947 partition as “a historic wrong” and “distortion of history” and more recently warned of “moving north,” which was seen here as a “blatant threat”.

He further reminded that over the past five years there were “phantom and fake” surgical strikes claim, the 2019 Balakot incident – the first attack on the mainland, and the so-called “accidental” launch of missile into the country’s heartland.


Gen Hayat said a range of conflicts was imposed on Pakistan — full scale war to insurgencies and terrorism and more recently hybrid warfare. He noted that importantly the country was well defended against those challenges except for the 1971 East Pakistan debacle.

On 1971 tragedy, he echoed former Army Chief Gen Qamar Bajwa’s line, who in one of his parting speeches, had termed the defeat in East Pakistan as a political failure rather than a military fiasco.

“In military sense there was status quo and had there been not a direct foreign intervention by India, the insurgency too would have failed,” he maintained.

Dr Adil Sultan, Dean of the Faculty of Aerospace and Strategic Studies (FASS), Air University Islamabad, said the external environment required Pakistan to maintain robust nuclear and conventional capabilities, while remaining cognizant of the limited economic resources.

He said introduction of new technologies by India like ballistic missile defence systems, Anti Satellite weapons (ASAT), hypersonic missiles, Pakistan-specific MIRV missiles, and operationalising sea-based nuclear capability were straining the deterrence.


Mr Javed Jabbar, writer and politician, called for major political and economic reforms and controlling population growth.


 
Pakistan will self-implode on it's own accord regardless of the hostile external environment if it continues on the current trajectory. 1971 was when the world received a glimpse of this, the greed for power internally caused them more damage than anything external.

The disregard for meritocracy and rampant nepotism is arguably the biggest risk to it's survival. National institutions continue to regress at alarming rates due to incapable people and careless individuals controlling them. It's like running a race backwards, you can't reach the finish line.
 
Former Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee retired Gen Zubair Hayat, in his keynote speech, said the threat from India, which has been reluctant to accept Pakistan’s existence

Gen. Zubair is right in his assertion. Here are some possible causes for his deduction.

Pakistan and India have recalled their respective ambassadors.

For the last few years there were no Pakistani movies and artists seen in India.

No bilateral sporting events between the two countries.

No cultural exchange or people to people contact. Zero tourism.

Worst is that Indian PM or Foreign Minister has never mentioned Pakistan by name.
 
He recalled the statements by Indian leaders in which they mentioned the 1947 partition as “a historic wrong”
Is there any evidence for this in the last 50 years? I can't imagine any Indian 'leader' making this statement today. BJP wants to unring partition as much as anyone wants a hole in their head.
 
Pakistanis Generals can turn even the US into a crap hole forget our country- Zaradaris and Sharifs don't help either but they are sideshows

they are too stupid for anything useful
 
Pakistan will self-implode on it's own accord
That is the dream on which india has been thriving since 47, later joined by Israel and some other entities.

Gen Hayat said a range of conflicts was imposed on Pakistan — full scale war to insurgencies and terrorism and more recently hybrid warfare. He noted that importantly the country was well defended against those challenges except for the 1971 East Pakistan debacle.
Pakistani Military is aware of the threats which Pakistan faces today, most of these threats are not exposed to public, some for the sake of national interest, however the backing of TTP and BLF by India is a testimony that India keeps pushing Pakistan's security apparatus against the wall, giving Pakistan no option but to bounce back.

Army, PAF and PN have grown in strength and equipment in past few years. It seems that Pakistan has been able to counter all what India throws at it, which is basically a never ending saga.
 
That is the dream on which india has been thriving since 47, later joined by Israel and some other entities.
And in 1971 they achieved half of it. Not woken up in the slightest, no desire to get things back in order in the right way.

I's the easiest, most effortless, and cheapest way. It's a dream for any enemy state.

And lumber 1 is handing it right to them and ignoring everyone else because they view themselves as superior to the civillians, they can never be wrong.
 
Of course, it's the easiest, most effortless, and cheapest way. It's a dream for any enemy state. 1971 India achieved half of that dream, they still haven't woken up.

And lumber 1 is handing it right to them and ignoring everyone else because they view themselves as superior to the civillians, they can never be wrong.
Military stands in the way, so those dreams cant see the light of the day.

The modus operandi is analogous to 1971 MB infiltration, but what worked in 10 months in 1971 has not been working since 20 years now, though the forms, the tactics, the handling, the infiltration, the funding, the organization and resources keep getting changed and modernized.
 
Of course, it's the easiest, most effortless, and cheapest way. It's a dream for any enemy state. 1971 India achieved half of that dream, they still haven't woken up.

And lumber 1 is handing it right to them and ignoring everyone else because they view themselves as superior to the civilians, they can never be wrong.
in reality, even a HS graduate is a better strategic thinker than them

I mean changing 4-5 PM in the last 6 years, can't get along with any PM, and when they come to power, we are usually in a bigger mess

why cant they accept that they are stupid af? leave it to someone else? how hard it is?

Military stands in the way, so those dreams cant see the light of the day.

The modus operandi is analogous to 1971 MB infiltration, but what worked in 10 months in 1971 has not been working since 20 years now, though the forms, the tactics, the handling, the infiltration, the funding, the organization and resources keep getting changed and modernized.
dude they are your enemy but you give them the ammo and help them along the way with your stupidity- why cant yall see it?
 
Back
Top Bottom