India & China seek to remove LAC: Breaking News

[RajputWarrior]

that may work but Pakistan and its ISI don't believe in status quo

Yup, a slower death prevails.

 

[LiberalAtheist]

Yup, a slower death prevails.

if the gov't was in power over there it might be feasible but PA and ISI get final say on any strategic issues

 

[pmukherjee]

It is good news, in the sense that it means that the bureaucrats will be busy earning their pay. Beyond that, the news has no significance at all. The resolution of the Indo Chinese border dispute is not going going to happen anytime soon. The reason is that China does not want the issue to be resolved. And why should they??? China is much stronger than India, they will be foolish to resolve the dispute to remove the sword of Damocles that they keep dangling over us. Why should they not wish to keep India on its toes and sweating?? 1962 continues to haunt us and the Chinese know this too well. Remove the border dispute and the ghosts go away.This is also the reason why India will never abandon the Tibetan exiles or their descendants.

I read some one remark that India lost opportunities in the past to resolve the issue to its favor as supposedly, those opportunities came at a time when China was 'weak'. I think that the reverse is really true. China is the loser as India will never again be as weak as it was in 1962. If China had been wiser, it could have had a friend on its South which left it free to handle the enemies on its East and North. Now China has to face hostilities from all corners of its borders.

 

[Norboo]

^^^^^ hell to the NO we keep Arunachal they keep Aksai Chin or else just keep the status quo there is no way in hell we are giving up AP or Tawang

It's not the whole of Arunachal that the Chinese really want. It's only a bargaining chip. They want the Tawang subdivision. Stressing on the whole of AP they think India would probably at least settle for Tawang. Here's the map...

Extreme left corner is Tawang which includes the famous
monastery.

 

[Tshering22]

once again wake me up when it happens i think only way to resolve issue is how we did in 2004 India recognized Tibet as apart of China, China did the same by recognizing Sikkim as apart of India, if we recognize Aksai Chin apart of China would they recognize Arunachal as apart of India?

Sorry but Sikkim willingly became a part of Indian Union just as in ancient times. We were never forced to do so by the Army as what CCP and their host sidekicks parade here. So China's recognition of Sikkim being Indian matters a little to us. They can consider the whole country disputed and we wouldn't give a rat's rear to it.

East Ladakh (what's called Aksai Chin) is a legal and ancient part of Ladakhi people and culture. Despite being almost completely barren, it was a part of Ladakh and hence by extension a part of India. Because of Nehru's madness, we lost that land to the CCP (Had Sardar Patel had been the PM, things would have been very different). So it would be giving up our land to have our own land (Arunachal) being recognized by a threat to the nation. Tibet was also never theirs, but our coward government gave in. Now they freaking want us to accept our territory as theirs? NEVER.

---------- Post added at 04:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:20 PM ----------

It's not the whole of Arunachal that the Chinese really want. It's only a bargaining chip. They want the Tawang subdivision. Stressing on the whole of AP they think India would probably at least settle for Tawang. Here's the map...

Extreme left corner is Tawang which includes the famous
monastery.

Not even AN INCH of Arunachal will go to the CCP and for that, we're ready for any consequence. This is the stand. Take it or leave it.

 

[my name is arya]

first they ask for tawang then ap then delhi


govt has to understand reality war is reality of life yes we can avoid war for few time but at some day we have to face earth

death and life, war and peace are two reality which we cant afford

and we can win war by kill our enemy not killed by themself

 

[LiberalAtheist]

Sorry but Sikkim willingly became a part of Indian Union just as in ancient times. We were never forced to do so by the Army as what CCP and their host sidekicks parade here. So China's recognition of Sikkim being Indian matters a little to us. They can consider the whole country disputed and we wouldn't give a rat's rear to it.

East Ladakh (what's called Aksai Chin) is a legal and ancient part of Ladakhi people and culture. Despite being almost completely barren, it was a part of Ladakh and hence by extension a part of India. Because of Nehru's madness, we lost that land to the CCP (Had Sardar Patel had been the PM, things would have been very different). So it would be giving up our land to have our own land (Arunachal) being recognized by a threat to the nation. Tibet was also never theirs, but our coward government gave in. Now they freaking want us to accept our territory as theirs? NEVER.

---------- Post added at 04:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:20 PM ----------



Not even AN INCH of Arunachal will go to the CCP and for that, we're ready for any consequence. This is the stand. Take it or leave it.

had we been prepared in 1962 things would be very different today......

prior to 1962 India never really controlled Aksai Chin but nonetheless they have it which leaves us in a bad position

there is no way any part of AP will go to China whether it be Tawang or the entire state

 

[huzihaidao12]

Sorry but Sikkim willingly became a part of Indian Union just as in ancient times. We were never forced to do so by the Army as what CCP and their host sidekicks parade here. So China's recognition of Sikkim being Indian matters a little to us. They can consider the whole country disputed and we wouldn't give a rat's rear to it.

East Ladakh (what's called Aksai Chin) is a legal and ancient part of Ladakhi people and culture. Despite being almost completely barren, it was a part of Ladakh and hence by extension a part of India. Because of Nehru's madness, we lost that land to the CCP (Had Sardar Patel had been the PM, things would have been very different). So it would be giving up our land to have our own land (Arunachal) being recognized by a threat to the nation. Tibet was also never theirs, but our coward government gave in. Now they freaking want us to accept our territory as theirs? NEVER.

---------- Post added at 04:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:20 PM ----------



Not even AN INCH of Arunachal will go to the CCP and for that, we're ready for any consequence. This is the stand. Take it or leave it.

Directly to say, a compromise only occur for both, if you want all, need to do to prepare for the loss of all, as long as you know it, then that is good.

 

[itaskol]

They are interested in keeping aksai chin and getting Tawang for us in return for which they plan to give up claim on rest of Arunachal even if it is absurd .

that is true!

the logic is very simple
1) tawang is historically one of holly place for Tibetans. india took tawang in 1951 illegal.

2) indias in this Forum will say that china also take tibet illegal.
but In fact India Goverment has ALREADY accepted Tibet as a part of China. so tawang belong to china legally.
and chinese Goverment never accepte that Tawang belong to india.
what we done for exchange was we accepted sikkim as part of india. even it was illegal occupy.

3) why we dont keep tawang after 1962. sadly fact is, that it was impossible for us to supply army in winter through mountains. and we did/do not really want big war with india. at that time we must end the war quickly and retreat.......
but it does not mean we dont want get tawang back.
4) most important is: WAR is not a solution!

in fact, the best way for both side:
that is india “sell” tawang to china with good and fair price. （ the price could be money, politic support and lot of things.)
and india goverment also know it exactly.

PS：
1.Tawang dispute can be solved as first step and only need to be conferenced between china and india.
a big step!
2.the dispute in rest of AP could be solved without problem after Tawang problem be solved first.
2.the akai chin problem ist much more komplex! it is part of kashmir problem.
and kashmir problem can not be solved by only china and india. this must be a 3 party negotiation include Pakistan.
all this should not be solved parallelly. first things first, one after another.