Importance of Karachi and Karachiites for Pakistan

[Pakhtoon yum]

Then all Pakistan is going back to India including Fata and Kpk

Do you even speak sindhi?

So if In next election Sindhis, Pashtoons and Baloch vote for Nationalist parties, then they should move back to Afghanistan, Iran and India?

I'm not from Afghanistan mostly all pakhtoons are not. We are the sons of the soil we live on. We arent immigrants

 

[Ultima Thule]

Yes you do. You live in a democracy. That's a very poor excuse to hide your failures

then They start to damging our propertties, and gives all kind of threats of peoples of Karachi @Pakthtoon yum

 

[Crusher]

Wtf are you talking about? That was the British empire. See people like you do reek of ignorance

Exactly, that is where I miss the user "indus pakistan", he always used to give a reality check to all those who say that before 1947 modern paksitan was part of "india" (in the sense of modern bjp ruled india) which is absolutely baseless as pakistan was part of "British india" that was ruled by Queen of England before 1947 and before the British it was either ruled by muslim Mughals or Turkic rulers with a brief 50 year period of Sikhs before the British. These paksitani territories have never been under the rule of the modern indian Hindus since at least 1000 AD when Mehmood Ghanzawi defeated the then hindu rulers of ghandara (KPK) and punjab and pushed them eastwards.

 

[Pakistani Fighter]

They are gangster we have no choice to support MQM @Pakhtoon yum

Lol What??

 

[Ultima Thule]

Wtf are you talking about? That was the British empire. See people like you do reek of ignorance

You get Pakistan at home not struggling/sacrifices like Indian Muslims were at TEHREK-E-PAKISTAN, and Pakistan is not only for locals of Pakistan at the time of independence @Pakhtoon yum

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

What next?

Importantance of Lahore and lahori
Importance of Peshawar and Peshwari
Important of Quetta and its residence
Importance of Photohar and Photohari

Such self glorifying thread serve no purpose because every city and ethnicity is important for existence of Pakistan and they are nothing without Pakistan so cannot we simply respect every other fellow Pakistani irrespective of his language/caste/ ethnicity/religion ? My city is better than others. I feed all Pakistan and Pakistan. I generate more revenue than others. I am highly competent and educated city while others cities have all paindoo villagers in them . Pakistan is nothing if minus my great city etc such comparison thread are useless because they give impression that being karachite is stronger identity than being Pakistani

We all know importance of Karachi and we have no doubt about its greatness or patriotism of its residence irrespective of their ethnicity so there was no need to create this special thread for karachi in defence of stupid remarks of Indus Pakistani where he associated Karachi with India

 

[Kabira]

because punjabi muhajir were not discriminated by punjabis! in khi jahil sindhi was preferred over educated Muhajir

Its not like one need to have PHD to qualify for government job in Pakistan. Karachi have huge private sector jobs which it leech of from rest of Pakistan, see how many headquarters there are in Karachi of companies working all over Pakistan. This is why muhajirs are easily richest ethnicity in terms of per capita. Before you repeat your tax collection BS, its mostly through exports/imports which again 80% is from rest of Pakistan.

Crying for not getting 100% of government jobs in Sindh is getting old.

 

[criticalerror]

I can only shake my head at the obviously idiotic topic of discussion. Ethnicity. Can we please leave this nonsense behind. We are all Pakistanis. Let’s leave it at that and move forward.

 

[Ultima Thule]

Lol What??

Yeah they gangster without a doubt, they closed the city of Karachi so many time, and destroyed properties risk the life of common people of Karachi @syed Hammad Ahemed

 

[Crusher]

Its not like one need to have PHD to qualify for government job in Pakistan. Karachi have huge private sector jobs which it leech of from rest of Pakistan, see how many headquarters there are in Karachi of companies working all over Pakistan. This is why muhajirs are easily richest ethnicity in terms of per capita. Before you repeat your tax collection BS, its mostly through exports/imports which again 80% is from rest of Pakistan.

Crying for not getting 100% of government jobs in Sindh is getting old.

I think one analogy that comes to my mind with regards to Karachi and rest of Sindh is that of London and rest of England. Unlike Karachi London genuinely generates 60 percent of GDP of England and I am sure most of that wealth is not spent on London but is spent uniformly on all cities of England. How would it be if London starts demanding that they want to separate themselves from the rest of backward England so that they can spend 100% of their GDP/money on themselves and reserve 100% of the jobs in London only for the liberal open-minded Londoners, because rest of England is a racist backward POS.

 

[SQ8]

Maybe PTM, BLA and JSQM have a point.. every other ethnicity in Pakistan seems to have to justify itself to this central province and its occupants.

 

[criticalerror]

Maybe PTM has a point.. every other ethnicity in Pakistan seems to have to justify itself to this central province and its occupants.

PTM was made by non-state actors to exploit these very fault lines. It wouldn’t work if there were no fault lines. Ajit Doval at work , Pakistanis more than happy to assist him in this.

 

[SQ8]

PTM was made by non-state actors to exploit these very fault lines. It wouldn’t work if there were no fault lines. Ajit Doval at work , Pakistanis more than happy to assist him in this.

Maybe its better to let those fault lines go?
I see racist pieces of crap talking away- why should I consider them countrymen?
Maybe a different country where people consider each other equal is needed?

Maybe India or ideally the United States can assist?

 

[criticalerror]

Maybe its better to let those fault lines go?
I see racist pieces of crap talking away- why should I consider them countrymen?
Maybe a different country where people consider each other equal is needed?

Maybe India or ideally the United States can assist?

I see where you are coming from. The sudden uptick in racism(or people climbing out of their closets) especially on this forum is sad. But at the same time , i would argue going crazy along with retards is not the way to go. For better or worse, Pakistan is our country and it’s the only one we have and will have. We can make it a better place by educating the said retards on why racism is bad.
Giving to India or the US is not a solution anyone can be ready to face. May it never reach those levels.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Maybe its better to let those fault lines go?
I see racist pieces of crap talking away- why should I consider them countrymen?
Maybe a different country where people consider each other equal is needed?

Maybe India or ideally the United States can assist?

Racists are there only in one community and ethnic group? If few individual in a group or community show racism toward me then should I paint entire group or community with one brush and should start playing ethnic card? I am sure you will never consider altaf hussain as representative of all Muhajir/Urdu speaking community . similarly comment of Indus Pakistan don't mean all Pakistani Pashtun share same views as him