What's new

IMF is not willing to sign the contract without the opposition party.

Pakistan can avoid default. There is no doubt in it. It only need resolve, It needs to take drastic steps. What we can do is to completely reduce our non-essential expenses. Immediately cut free petrol, drastically reduce non-combat expenditures in military, fire over staff at huge loss making entities like steel mills, railways etc. But the thing is current govt has ZERO WILL and ZERO capacity to do such things.
 
Thank you for sharing this video and clarifying the issue for me.

Having watched this video, I agree whole heartedly with the speaker, IK and PTI should NOT sign ok to the IMF’s deal. Stick to demanding elections ASAP, so they can raise taxes and funding from our own people by borrowing from them, so we can subsidize those things we need to in order to keep our most vulnerable 88% of our population alive.

88% of the population doesn’t even use 300 units of a electricity a month, which should indicate that if INF demands are agreed upon, millions may die trying to afford the necessities of life.

After being re-elected, the PTI should have an alternative plan that gets the nation stabilized and immediate enact revolutionary reforms (economic and political), and then appeal to the same partner nations waiting for an IMF bailout to still loan the money, to buy the nation time till the reforms take effect, because the people of Pakistan have loaned the money to the state instead.
 
Last edited:
Pakistan can avoid default. There is no doubt in it. It only need resolve, It needs to take drastic steps. What we can do is to completely reduce our non-essential expenses. Immediately cut free petrol, drastically reduce non-combat expenditures in military, fire over staff at huge loss making entities like steel mills, railways etc. But the thing is current govt has ZERO WILL and ZERO capacity to do such things.
FoJktLaWAAEOpsV
 
They are calling bloody revolution. Sucking poor and fill the pockets of their loved ones. They already knows well, Sharif and Zardari always keep bureaucracy and judges in their pockets.
 
Last edited:
I bet your predecessors used the same lines for the past seven decades while sipping tea and hookah on every Friday night.

And they said the exact same thing when Gandhi and Nehru were leading - India is genocidal state, Gandhi is anti-muslim and stuff. And look at them now. Repeated;y complianing to world community that India is no longer the country of Gandhi and Nehru :rofl: :rofl:
 
Surrender was the only option.
Pakistani people are going to feel the pain, thank you PML.


Pakistan agrees to IMF conditions, staff-level accord still pending: Dar

Tahir Sherani | Dawn.com Published February 10, 2023 Updated a day ago




0
<p>Finance Minister Ishaq Dar addresses a press conference in Islamabad on Monday. — DawnNewsTV</p>

Finance Minister Ishaq Dar addresses a press conference in Islamabad on Monday. — DawnNewsTV
1x1.2x1.5x
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar said on Friday that the government had received the Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) related to the completion of the ninth review of a $7 billion loan programme, indicating that a staff-level agreement with the lender was still pending.
The MEFP is a key document that describes all the conditions, steps and policy measures on the basis of which the two sides declare the staff-level agreement.
Once the draft MEFP has been shared, the two sides discuss the policy measures outlined in the document. Once these are finalised, a staff-level agreement is signed, which is then forwarded to the Fund’s Executive Board for approval.
The minister made these remarks in an early morning press conference after an IMF delegation, which left Pakistan last night after holding talks with the government for 10 days, issued a statement that virtual talks would continue.
The IMF and the government held talks between January 31 and February 9. As the visiting delegation left without a concluding statement, there was some confusion about the outcome of the talks and whether a draft MEFP had been shared.
However, Dar insisted in his press conference today that there was no confusion. “We insisted that they (the Fund delegation) give us the MEFP before leaving so we could look at it over the weekend,” he said, adding that the government and Fund officials would hold a virtual meeting in this regard on Monday.
“I am confirming that the MEFP draft has been received by us at 9am today,” he added. “We will completely go through the [MEFP] over the weekend and will hold a virtual meeting with [Fund officials]. It will obviously take a few days.”
During his presser today, the finance minister acknowledged that reforms in certain sectors required by the IMF were in Pakistan’s interest. He criticised the previous PTI-led government for “economic destruction and misgovernance”.
“It is necessary to fix those things,” he said. “These reforms are painful but necessary.”
He vowed to keep making efforts to ensure Pakistan completed the IMF programme.
“Once the MEFP has been finalised, they (IMF) have their own internal process and then a Board meeting is held. And then finally, when approval is given, the [tranche] is disbursed.
“It is a standard process which can neither be shortened, and hopefully they won’t extend it unnecessarily,” Dar added.
The finance minister shared that the country would receive a $1.2bn disbursement in the form of Special Drawing Rights after the review’s completion.
SDRs are international reserve assets created by the IMF in 1969 and are allocated to member states to supplement existing official reserves.

What Pakistan has agreed to with the IMF​

  • Imposing taxes amounting to Rs170 billion
  • Minimising untargeted subsidies in the gas and energy sectors
  • Ensuring that there is zero addition to gas sector’s circular debt
  • Raising the petroleum development levy on diesel to Rs50 through two Rs5 hikes on March 1 and April 1
  • Increasing allocation of BISP to Rs400bn

Policy measures​

Outlining the policy measures agreed upon between the government and the IMF, Dar said taxes amounting to Rs170bn would be imposed. He added, however, that the government would try to ensure that the taxes did not directly burden the common man.
To impose the taxes, the government would introduce a finance bill or ordinance, depending on the situation at the time, he said. Preparations for the bill or ordinance would begin once matters were finalised. If both houses of parliament were in session at the time, then a bill would be presented, otherwise, an ordinance would be promulgated, he said.
“Secondly, we will implement the agreed-upon energy reforms through the federal cabinet,” he said, adding that the primary focus would be on minimising untargeted subsidies and reducing the “flow” in the gas sector to zero so there was no addition to the circular debt.
The minister noted that the government had already fulfilled the commitment to raise the petroleum development levy (PDL) on petrol to Rs50 per litre whereas the PDL on diesel would also be raised to Rs50 in the coming months.
He said the government and IMF had agreed that there would be no sales tax on petroleum products. However, the general sales tax would be “tinkered” with in the upcoming finance bill.
“We have agreed to increase the allocation to the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) to Rs400bn from Rs360bn currently to [help] the most vulnerable people hit by inflation.”
Talking about electricity prices, Dar said the country’s generation cost was around Rs2-3 trillion while only Rs1.8tr was recovered, which resulted in an increase in either the circular debt or fiscal deficit. However, the entire difference in amount would not be recovered by increasing the tariff, he said.
The IMF was working out everything in accordance with a plan, he said. “Our numbers have been agreed upon. The process will obviously be followed and the cabinet, ECC, etc [will be involved].”
In response to a question, he said the finance team was “satisfied” with the negotiations with the IMF related to the power tariff.
Talking about the precarious foreign exchange reserves situation, the minister said commitments with friendly countries would be fulfilled and inflows would be received. “There is nothing to worry about. This country has also survived on $414m in foreign reserves.
“The State Bank is managing,” he assured.
Dar said there was a credibility gap as the IMF did not trust the government because of the PTI government’s actions. “They say not only did the previous government not implement the agreement but also reversed when the vote of no-confidence was brought [against Prime Minister Imran Khan].
“The negotiations were hard but we agreed only to what was doable,” he said.

IMF statement​

The concluding statement issued by IMF Mission Chief Nathan Porter stated, “The IMF team welcomes the prime minister’s commitment to implement policies needed to safeguard macroeconomic stability and thanks the authorities for the constructive discussions.”
“Considerable progress was made during the mission on policy measures to address domestic and external imbalances,” the statement said.
The statement underlined key priorities that include strengthening the fiscal position with permanent revenue measures and reduction in untargeted subsidies, while scaling up social protection to help the most vulnerable and those affected by the floods; allowing the exchange rate to be market determined to gradually eliminate the foreign exchange shortage; and enhancing energy provision by preventing further accumulation of circular debt and ensuring the viability of the energy sector.
“The timely and decisive implementation of these policies along with resolute financial support from official partners are critical for Pakistan to successfully regain macroeconomic stability and advance its sustainable development,” the statement added.
It further said that virtual discussions would be held in the coming days to finalise the implementation of these policies.
Pakistan’s foreign exchange reserves fell to $2.916bn during the week ending on Feb 3. Experts believe that the country’s reserves are enough for only 16 or 17 days of imports.
In such a situation, the country urgently needs to complete the ninth review to unlock the disbursement of $1.2bn from the IMF and inflows from friendly countries and other multilateral lenders.
 
Surrender was the only option.
Pakistani people are going to feel the pain, thank you PML.


Pakistan agrees to IMF conditions, staff-level accord still pending: Dar

Tahir Sherani | Dawn.com Published February 10, 2023 Updated a day ago




0
<p>Finance Minister Ishaq Dar addresses a press conference in Islamabad on Monday. — DawnNewsTV</p>

Finance Minister Ishaq Dar addresses a press conference in Islamabad on Monday. — DawnNewsTV
1x1.2x1.5x
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar said on Friday that the government had received the Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) related to the completion of the ninth review of a $7 billion loan programme, indicating that a staff-level agreement with the lender was still pending.
The MEFP is a key document that describes all the conditions, steps and policy measures on the basis of which the two sides declare the staff-level agreement.
Once the draft MEFP has been shared, the two sides discuss the policy measures outlined in the document. Once these are finalised, a staff-level agreement is signed, which is then forwarded to the Fund’s Executive Board for approval.
The minister made these remarks in an early morning press conference after an IMF delegation, which left Pakistan last night after holding talks with the government for 10 days, issued a statement that virtual talks would continue.
The IMF and the government held talks between January 31 and February 9. As the visiting delegation left without a concluding statement, there was some confusion about the outcome of the talks and whether a draft MEFP had been shared.
However, Dar insisted in his press conference today that there was no confusion. “We insisted that they (the Fund delegation) give us the MEFP before leaving so we could look at it over the weekend,” he said, adding that the government and Fund officials would hold a virtual meeting in this regard on Monday.
“I am confirming that the MEFP draft has been received by us at 9am today,” he added. “We will completely go through the [MEFP] over the weekend and will hold a virtual meeting with [Fund officials]. It will obviously take a few days.”
During his presser today, the finance minister acknowledged that reforms in certain sectors required by the IMF were in Pakistan’s interest. He criticised the previous PTI-led government for “economic destruction and misgovernance”.
“It is necessary to fix those things,” he said. “These reforms are painful but necessary.”
He vowed to keep making efforts to ensure Pakistan completed the IMF programme.
“Once the MEFP has been finalised, they (IMF) have their own internal process and then a Board meeting is held. And then finally, when approval is given, the [tranche] is disbursed.
“It is a standard process which can neither be shortened, and hopefully they won’t extend it unnecessarily,” Dar added.
The finance minister shared that the country would receive a $1.2bn disbursement in the form of Special Drawing Rights after the review’s completion.
SDRs are international reserve assets created by the IMF in 1969 and are allocated to member states to supplement existing official reserves.

What Pakistan has agreed to with the IMF​

  • Imposing taxes amounting to Rs170 billion
  • Minimising untargeted subsidies in the gas and energy sectors
  • Ensuring that there is zero addition to gas sector’s circular debt
  • Raising the petroleum development levy on diesel to Rs50 through two Rs5 hikes on March 1 and April 1
  • Increasing allocation of BISP to Rs400bn

Policy measures​

Outlining the policy measures agreed upon between the government and the IMF, Dar said taxes amounting to Rs170bn would be imposed. He added, however, that the government would try to ensure that the taxes did not directly burden the common man.
To impose the taxes, the government would introduce a finance bill or ordinance, depending on the situation at the time, he said. Preparations for the bill or ordinance would begin once matters were finalised. If both houses of parliament were in session at the time, then a bill would be presented, otherwise, an ordinance would be promulgated, he said.
“Secondly, we will implement the agreed-upon energy reforms through the federal cabinet,” he said, adding that the primary focus would be on minimising untargeted subsidies and reducing the “flow” in the gas sector to zero so there was no addition to the circular debt.
The minister noted that the government had already fulfilled the commitment to raise the petroleum development levy (PDL) on petrol to Rs50 per litre whereas the PDL on diesel would also be raised to Rs50 in the coming months.
He said the government and IMF had agreed that there would be no sales tax on petroleum products. However, the general sales tax would be “tinkered” with in the upcoming finance bill.
“We have agreed to increase the allocation to the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) to Rs400bn from Rs360bn currently to [help] the most vulnerable people hit by inflation.”
Talking about electricity prices, Dar said the country’s generation cost was around Rs2-3 trillion while only Rs1.8tr was recovered, which resulted in an increase in either the circular debt or fiscal deficit. However, the entire difference in amount would not be recovered by increasing the tariff, he said.
The IMF was working out everything in accordance with a plan, he said. “Our numbers have been agreed upon. The process will obviously be followed and the cabinet, ECC, etc [will be involved].”
In response to a question, he said the finance team was “satisfied” with the negotiations with the IMF related to the power tariff.
Talking about the precarious foreign exchange reserves situation, the minister said commitments with friendly countries would be fulfilled and inflows would be received. “There is nothing to worry about. This country has also survived on $414m in foreign reserves.
“The State Bank is managing,” he assured.
Dar said there was a credibility gap as the IMF did not trust the government because of the PTI government’s actions. “They say not only did the previous government not implement the agreement but also reversed when the vote of no-confidence was brought [against Prime Minister Imran Khan].
“The negotiations were hard but we agreed only to what was doable,” he said.

IMF statement​

The concluding statement issued by IMF Mission Chief Nathan Porter stated, “The IMF team welcomes the prime minister’s commitment to implement policies needed to safeguard macroeconomic stability and thanks the authorities for the constructive discussions.”
“Considerable progress was made during the mission on policy measures to address domestic and external imbalances,” the statement said.
The statement underlined key priorities that include strengthening the fiscal position with permanent revenue measures and reduction in untargeted subsidies, while scaling up social protection to help the most vulnerable and those affected by the floods; allowing the exchange rate to be market determined to gradually eliminate the foreign exchange shortage; and enhancing energy provision by preventing further accumulation of circular debt and ensuring the viability of the energy sector.
“The timely and decisive implementation of these policies along with resolute financial support from official partners are critical for Pakistan to successfully regain macroeconomic stability and advance its sustainable development,” the statement added.
It further said that virtual discussions would be held in the coming days to finalise the implementation of these policies.
Pakistan’s foreign exchange reserves fell to $2.916bn during the week ending on Feb 3. Experts believe that the country’s reserves are enough for only 16 or 17 days of imports.
In such a situation, the country urgently needs to complete the ninth review to unlock the disbursement of $1.2bn from the IMF and inflows from friendly countries and other multilateral lenders.
The heavy lifting is being done here:
“The timely and decisive implementation of these policies along with resolute financial support from official partners are critical for Pakistan to successfully regain macroeconomic stability and advance its sustainable development,” the statement added.
It further said that virtual discussions would be held in the coming days to finalise the implementation of these policies.

Translation: until the agreed upon terms and conditions are implemented on the ground and the new taxes and rates go into effect, IMF funds will not be coming in. Dar's or Sharif's autographs on paper have exactly zero value.
 
Borrowing money is not a solution but a problem in itself. We need capable leaders to run industries and the government not smooth talkers, corrupts and thugs. Pakistan is stuck and entrapped and is going to sink further into a failed state to exactly where the Hindjews want us to be. Pakistan is being setup to implode in exactly the same manner as Libya and Syria and it will be a disaster for Muslims and the region. Not sure how much the people can take and the present gov needs to be careful.
 
implode in exactly the same manner as Libya and Syria
Those are not good analogs. Both of them failed due to civil war after long rule by dictators/authoritarian regimes. Long periods of dictatorships atrophied polity and people have no ability to peacefully negotiate their differences and arrive at a compromise. You are seeing early signs of that breakdown in Pakistan where each side calls the other side as enemy and not opposition. Absent Civil War, the closer analog is Lebanon where the State collapsed under the sheer weight of incompetence. Pakistan is slumping towards a failed state, not because of any external actors, but by the sheer lack of competence needed to run a nation of 220 million. Another country in this league (collapse without a Civil War) is Haiti.
 
I don’t think Pakistan is heading to a collapse. It’s just that what the IMF and the world considers to be solid economic policies is anathema to our political economy. Whichever party implements the needed economic policies pays for it with their political capital.

Both PTI and Miftah had paid the price, floated the rupee and had presided over economic adjustments. The difference this time around is the weight of stupidity around Ishaq Dar- whose entire politics revolves around the price of the dollar. The IMF knows this and has no faith in him.
 
there is no pakistan. there is only punjabistan. whatever they want will be done.
 

Back
Top Bottom