I'm both Hindu and Muslim: Salman Khan

[pak-marine]

Who fckn cares .. Bulleya ki jana main kaun ya tu kaun .. Idiot judge and idiotic question .. Wtf does it have to do with the case

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

agree
elders are good as long as they mean well, not so good once they put on their Khap masks and bring the cane out
but no, even with the monies, I think the elders thing is deeply engrained, sometimes even to people's own detriment.
we will evolve, not ape.

No one care if elders mean well or is out to ruin our lives. People value their INDEPENDENCE, and that comes from either being RICH or having Courage. Both are rare.

 

[ashok321]

Then the question should have been about the religion, not caste. How would you justify religious angle in here anyway? Is he going to get away with what he did if he successfully convinces the court that being Muslim he intended to do Halal?

He was asked about his religion..

Salman Khan hit the right note today when a court in Jodhpur asked him about his religion.

After some thought, he answered: "Hindu and Muslim".

Salman Khan pleaded 'not guilty' in an arms case being heard at the Jodhpur court.

Before recording Salman's statement, Chief Judicial Magistrate Anupama Bijlani asked him his name, father's name, profession and other details required by the court's form.

Salman answered everything, but was left confused when the court asked about his religion.

As the actor looked puzzled, his counsel and bodyguard, someone from the crowd suggested he say 'Muslim.'

1. Hindus CAN, its Indian constitution which prevents Hindus. I have said this earlier. you are just too stupid or lazy to understand it when I say in only once.

2. Law was CHANGED in 1955 to prevent more than 1 wife for Hindus.

3. A Hindu with a wife converts to islam, marries a second time, and then converts back to Hinduism. What part of this do you not understand ? Do I have to replete everything 2 times for you grasp it ?

You said the following absurd stuff:
Why can't he be a Hindu & a Muslim at the same time ? ............ Who issues that certificate ?
And with your -18 negatives that I did not see, makes you a perfect candidate for my ignore list.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

You said the following absurd stuff:
Why can't he be a Hindu & a Muslim at the same time ? ............ Who issues that certificate ?
And with your -18 negatives that I did not see, makes you a perfect candidate for my ignore list.

LOL. More nonsense. The Religion column in your passport is your Political religion. Not your practising religion.

This is because India has different laws for different religion.

A man can be a practising muslim and a practising Hindu at the same time.

 

[gau8av]

No one care if elders mean well or is out to ruin our lives. People value their INDEPENDENCE, and that comes from either being RICH or having Courage. Both are rare.

I've seen cases, including where people, fully in control of substantial financial assets have caved to societal or family pressure when it comes to inter-religious unions.

but there are many where things go smooth, or people take extreme measures and full bollywood style elope etc

and you'll find very ultra conservatives even within the monied, educated and urban population but this is changing, 'Hinduism' is also constantly evolving.. no set in stone 'commandments', list of 'haram' etc, right ?

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

Farhan Akhtar is an atheist I reckon, read somewhere Javed Akhar raised his children as atheist. What's your point anyway?

Farhan Akhtar mother was a Parsi and his father was a muslim. Javed Akhtar is himself not a practising muslim, but is a political muslim.

 

[gau8av]

A man can be a practising muslim and a practising Hindu at the same time.

yes, it's possible in India if you must.. sarv dharm sambhav

 

[monitor]

I pray to Allah he show him true path

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

I've seen cases, including where people, fully in control of substantial financial assets have caved to societal or family pressure when it comes to inter-religious unions.

but there are many where things go smooth, or people take extreme measures and full bollywood style elope etc

and you'll find very ultra conservatives even within the monied, educated and urban population but this is changing, 'Hinduism' is also constantly evolving.. no set in stone 'commandments', list of 'haram' etc, right ?

What is the point of being in control of financial assets but living in a society or economic community that will not let you leverage that assets. Hinduism has nothing to do with this. As long as its dharmic, Hinduism does not interfere.

In the creative sector/field where your mind and attitude have to be more open, you will find larger acceptance of all kinds of diversity.

 

[Emmie]

He was asked about his religion..

Salman Khan hit the right note today when a court in Jodhpur asked him about his religion.

After some thought, he answered: "Hindu and Muslim".

Salman Khan pleaded 'not guilty' in an arms case being heard at the Jodhpur court.

Before recording Salman's statement, Chief Judicial Magistrate Anupama Bijlani asked him his name, father's name, profession and other details required by the court's form.

Salman answered everything, but was left confused when the court asked about his religion.

As the actor looked puzzled, his counsel and bodyguard, someone from the crowd suggested he say 'Muslim.'

I was making a comment considering details shared in OP, I think you didn't read OP.

The actor appeared in the court to record his statement in the case. As part of the process, Khan was required to answer questions about his father’s name, profession and caste.

The court witnessed an interesting exchange when the judge asked Khan to state his caste. Khan was confused by the judge’s question and someone in the court suggested he should say he was a Muslim.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

yes, it's possible in India if you must.. sarv dharm sambhav

Yes, only in India and non islamic countries.

Indian Couple Refuses to Give Child a Religious Identity

It wasn’t a spur-of-the-moment decision. “A few months into my pregnancy, we had decided that we would not give our child any religious identity,” says Aditi. “We are not against religion, but who are we to choose a religion on our baby’s behalf? We will expose him to the values of different faiths and cultures, and when he grows up he will be free to follow any faith — or none if he wishes.”


But its not easy in India.

No religion please, we're liberals - The Times of India

 

[gau8av]

What is the point of being in control of financial assets but living in a society or economic community that will not let you leverage that assets. Hinduism has nothing to do with this. As long as its dharmic, Hinduism does not interfere.

In the creative sector/field where your mind and attitude have to be more open, you will find larger acceptance of all kinds of diversity.

it's a south asian (Hind) cultural thing, not religious but for some people it's all about gotra and this and that and religion, changing slowly.

'vedic' society was way more evolved, something all the recent 'vedic' mania somehow misses.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

it's a south asian (Hind) cultural thing, not religious but for some people it's all about gotra and this and that and religion, changing slowly.

'vedic' society was way more evolved, something all the recent 'vedic' mania somehow misses.

There is no culture that forces one to abandon his own freedom just to appease the desire of someone else. That is just a twisted assumption of a enslaved mind.

Indian culture has swayamvar, the right of women to choose their own husband. No elders gets any vote.

Finally the day and age of Vedic culture is gone, its time to adapt or die. Varna is no longer sustainable and soma is not available. Agni is not worshipped anymore and quantum of knowledge has expanded beyond the Vedas.

 

[Ryuzaki]

Nice to see he is acknowledging his ancestry

 

[Al Bhatti]

The new sect, Hindu Muslim.

A son/daughter of "Hindu Muslim" marries a "Christian Jew" or "Hindu Christian"
When their son or daughter grows up he/she will say what ? I am "Hindu Muslim Christian Jew" or "Hindu Muslim Christian"?