If states want UP migrant workers back they have to seek our permission: Yogi Adityanath

[Naofumi]

sarkari Hindus

The terminology feels wrong here, Sarkar to Hinduo ki hi hai!

 

[padamchen]

The terminology feels wrong here, Sarkar to Hinduo ki hi hai!

If you really are a Muslim be careful about your engagement with Afrazul.

 

[Naofumi]

If you really are a Muslim be careful about your engagement with Afrazul.

Hindus have a pass in this?

 

[padamchen]

Don't get defensive.

 

[Naofumi]

 

[padamchen]

Even the likes you give to a post would be analysed.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

Hindus have a pass in this?

Yes, as long as you have a Hindu Reichspass, you are okay.

 

[Andhadhun]

These people are stalwarts and have done a lot to stem the tide of reactionary historiography. Without them, Indian history would read very different and there would be a lot more Islamophobia and violence.

TRUTH and RECONCILIATION leads to LESS violence, not more.

However infantilizing of readers of history leads to MORE violence.

Democracy works when you treat the people as grown up's.

Don't be a Nehru and his ilk who though he could patronize Hindus with condescending historical narratives. We have one such nauseating Indian in pdf.

You can only fool some people for some time, not everybody for all times.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

TRUTH and RECONCILIATION leads to LESS violence, not more.

However infantilizing of readers of history leads to MORE violence.

Democracy works when you treat the people as grown up's.

Don't be a Nehru and his ilk who though he could patronize Hindus with condescending historical narratives. We have one such nauseating Indian in pdf.

You can only fool some people for some time, not everybody for all times.

And justify Islamophobia and eviction of Muslims?

 

[Andhadhun]

And justify Islamophobia and eviction of Muslims?

"Phobia" is an Irrational fear.

A Rational fear is NOT a phobia.

Din't muslims ask for pakistan and bangladesh for self eviction ? Now they can't complain when we believed them and follow their instructions.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

"Phobia" is an Irrational fear.

A Rational fear is NOT a phobia.

Din't muslims ask for pakistan and bangladesh for self eviction ? Now they can't complain when we believed them and follow their instructions.

No. These places were to be separated because they did not trust you to rule them in a just way.

Besides, it was impractical to leave everything and move to a new country especially when the local conditions were relatively peaceful.

 

[Andhadhun]

No. These places were to be separated because they did not trust you to rule them in a just way.

Besides, it was impractical to leave everything and move to a new country especially when the local conditions were relatively peaceful.

They are welcome not to trust Hindus.

It was impractical to draw a line in the sand and create an border. But muslims rioted, killed and looted to make that happen. Now you can't complain that it was "impractical". That ship has left the harbor.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

They are welcome not to trust Hindus.

It was impractical to draw a line in the sand and create an border. But muslims rioted, killed and looted to make that happen. Now you can't complain that it was "impractical". That ship has left the harbor.

As if Hindus did not! Sikhs cleared East Punjab entirely except Malerkotla.

@Naofumi, you are more tactful. May be you can handle this better.

 

[Naofumi]

They are welcome not to trust Hindus.

It was impractical to draw a line in the sand and create an border. But muslims rioted, killed and looted to make that happen. Now you can't complain that it was "impractical". That ship has left the harbor.

As if Hindus did not! Sikhs cleared East Punjab entirely except Malerkotla.

@Naofumi, you are more tactful. May be you can handle this better.

What's there to handle? The population transfer was nearly equal - 7 million to 7 million. No one owes anything to anyone.

 

[Andhadhun]

As if Hindus did not! Sikhs cleared East Punjab entirely except Malerkotla.

@Naofumi, you are more tactful. May be you can handle this better.

Once "direct action" started, did you expect the Hindus and Sikhs to remain silent spectators and victims ?

What's there to handle? The population transfer was nearly equal - 7 million to 7 million. No one owes anything to anyone.

That is pure speculation. There are no actual verifiable numbers available.

What is known is the decimation of Hindu population in pakistan and Bangladesh post 1947. So no, there is a debt that is owed. And if you choose to forget it, I will always be around to remind you.