ICHR member calls Indian Leftists Jihad-friendly

[uparyupari]

If India in this present time doesn't have any muslim problem ( as your kind claims) or christian missionary issues, the civilized Hindus ( just for the sheer fact that they are human beings) will go back to the days of fighting among themselves probably using caste-ism. When you have no one else to fight against, you among yourselves. The upper caste will find a way to rule the lower causing a fracture in the fragile unity.

The mongols destroyed Arabiya when Muslim civilization was probably at its zenith. The Mongols were barbarians or not is irrelevant, they were out there to conquer nations. They did just that.

Far less fighting than what the rest of the world would have had. Indian civilization had evolved enough to find a path out of war, Buddha and his popularity was the living embodiment of that sentiment and civility.

Still all that is Speculation and Fiction, so I have no interest in it. Your prejudiced jaundiced view of Hindu civilization and caste wars is just wishful thinking. Muslim civilization itself was a predatory invasion that destroyed the local culture of Iran to Turkey to spain. Civilizations that are still reeling under the effects of that invasion includes your nation and Pakistan. That is the reality.

 

[fallstuff]

Far less fighting than what the rest of the world would have had. Indian civilization had evolved enough to find a path out of war, Buddha and his popularity was the living embodiment of that sentiment and civility.

Still all that is Speculation and Fiction, so I have no interest in it. Your prejudiced jaundiced view of Hindu civilization and caste wars is just wishful thinking. Muslim civilization itself was a predatory invasion that destroyed the local culture of Iran to Turkey to spain. Civilizations that are still reeling under the effects of that invasion includes your nation and Pakistan. That is the reality.

Indian civilization as you claim it was easy picking. Its a shame that a nation of hundreds of millions of people were simply pushed over by a few folks coming down from foreign lands for a thousand years. The fact remains without a strong military or for that matter an effective deterrence, you will always get pushed around.

Your leaders have realized that point and now armed India with nukes.

 

[Razia Sultana]

Indian civilization as you claim it was easy picking. Its a shame that a nation of hundreds of millions of people were simply pushed over by a few folks coming down from foreign lands for a thousand years. The fact remains without a strong military or for that matter an effective deterrence, you will always get pushed around.

Your leaders have realized that point and now armed India with nukes.

Indian Civilization includes Bangladesh and Pakistan. So when you are refering to history before 1947, call it our, not your.

 

[Ammyy]

Indian civilization as you claim it was easy picking. Its a shame that a nation of hundreds of millions of people were simply pushed over by a few folks coming down from foreign lands for a thousand years. The fact remains without a strong military or for that matter an effective deterrence, you will always get pushed around.

Your leaders have realized that point and now armed India with nukes.

You people was first to surrender, and we are still hindu nation.

 

[magudi]

You people was first to surrender, and we are still hindu nation.

Hindu nation?

 

[vegav]

I would ask the the RSS fan boys to give it a a rest. You are literally engaging a person with a history major, with a knack for history !!

for a bangladeshi with no native intuition or common sense,some degree may mean some pedigree but not for us.

India was conquered because they were militarily weak. When muslim rulers were weak they were defeated by the Mongols in Arabia and by a few hundreds Brits in India. This is how the world was, and to some extent remain so these days.

Stop whining about some events that happened because your ancestors were not strong enough to defend themselves.

yeah but things are reversed now.

If India in this present time doesn't have any muslim problem ( as your kind claims) or christian missionary issues, the civilized Hindus ( just for the sheer fact that they are human beings) will go back to the days of fighting among themselves probably using caste-ism. When you have no one else to fight against, you fight among yourselves. The upper caste will find a way to rule the lower causing a fracture in the fragile unity.

The mongols destroyed Arabiya when Muslim civilization was probably at its zenith. The Mongols were barbarians or not is irrelevant, they were out there to conquer nations. They did just that.

arabia's zenith would be like india's knee.

 

[uparyupari]

Indian civilization as you claim it was easy picking. Its a shame that a nation of hundreds of millions of people were simply pushed over by a few folks coming down from foreign lands for a thousand years. The fact remains without a strong military or for that matter an effective deterrence, you will always get pushed around.

Your leaders have realized that point and now armed India with nukes.

It was no easy picking at all ......... India is the place where the Islamic invasion STOPPED. IT was FOUGHT to a stand still. Then Pushed back.

Better still, it was the only civilization that fought it and won. India is still majority Hindu. THAT is strength. Our Values are still intact and our beliefs are still sacred.

India was almost rid of the islamic invaders when the British gained strength. British rule was FAR shorter.

India was not a single political union when the invaders arrived. The invaders had a larger army and a more barbaric way of conduct.

EVERY nation in the world has been defeated in some war or the other ....... There is not a single nation which has not be invaded by others. But India remains the few civilizations that retained its continuous civilization and WON the civilization and Religious wars. China being the other one.

Europe turned christian. Arab turned muslim. Australia, America, Africa turned muslim and christian. Only India and China retained its civilizational values. LOL at your feeble understanding of history.

 

[Nicky G]

Every single time I hear or read the term sanghi or Internet Hindu, I can help but be amused at the burning unease and desperation underneath the condescension.

Just my personal experience, one should ignore seriously engaging Macaulaite historians; they are much too narrow minded for any debate to be worth the time.

 

[fallstuff]

for a bangladeshi with no native intuition or common sense,some degree may mean some pedigree but not for us.



yeah but things are reversed now.



arabia's zenith would be like india's knee.

Yeah , I know what you mean , I heard versions of Modi's sermons.

Indians had planes or space crafts making inter planetary/galactic travels. Modi claims Ganesha is the proof that Indians performed reconstructive/plastic surgeries since the ancient times.

Did I miss something ?

You people was first to surrender, and we are still hindu nation.

Contrary to what you believe as true, you were permitted to carry on with your lives as long as you paid your taxes. You gotta pay your taxes buddy !!!!

 

[Joe Shearer]

@Joe Shearer

Leftists in India are presently fighting for their own political survival
So leftist historians have become fossilized and irrelevant

Anyway there is a BIG India outside Bengal which cares for the truth
not the distilled version of leftist historians

It is not clear whom this homily is directed towards. I am not a leftist; those who are members of more than a few weeks standing will have known from my posts that I have criticised the left in India for forty years now. I speak for the BIG India which INCLUDES Bengal, and a whole host of historians within Bengal and in every part of India which cares for the truth, and does not define the truth as the kind of crap brought out by the Sangh Parivar.

Move on; try the next street.

Why people inside bengal aren't interested ?

@Mike_Brando kya ye sach he ?

That was an ignorant attempt at being provocative.

I propose @joe shearar for ASHISH NANDY AWARDS 2015.

He's the closest we've got to ashish nandy here on PDF, in fact he may well even be the real Ashish nandy in disguise who knows

I actually have issues with Ashish Nandy and his sometimes flippant, sometimes abrasive approach to the Dalit issue.

Well,the truth is the average "intellectual" Bengali man is still a die-hard commie in his heart.It's only that the TMC is in the power now and hence the "Intellectual" Bengali class has no other option than to support the ruling party for their very own survival.The roots of communism has already spread too deep inside the middle class "Intellectual" Bengali society to be wiped out at any time soon.These "Bhadrolok"(gentlemen) Bengalis are still living inside their wet dreams where they are still able to implement the ideas of communism among the entire society(something which even the USSR failed to do despite being an official communist country).Bengali "Bhadroloks" are still dreaming of a spectacular comeback by the CP(I)M led Left Front coalition in the upcoming assembly election.

Simplistic.

Nobody within Bengal who has lived through the horror of the maladministration by the CPM for thirtyfive years retains even the shreds of sympathy with the CPM, just to be simplistic back. It is another matter that the Trinamul has proved to be medicine worse than the disease it was hoped to cure.

 

[Ammyy]

Contrary to what you believe as true, you were permitted to carry on with your lives as long as you paid your taxes. You gotta pay your taxes buddy !!!!

It seems truth hurts you a lot

You people were only one who surrender

 

[Joe Shearer]

It seems truth hurts you a lot

You people were only one who surrender

@fallstuff, are you seriously wasting your time with this Internet Hindu troll? Must be a dull day.

 

[Screambowl]

India is land for those who believe in these principals

1)Gyan Yog
2)Raja Yoga
3)Karma Yoga
4)Bhakti Yoga

Vedas.

 

[magudi]

India is land for those who believe in these principals

1)Gyan Yog
2)Raja Yoga
3)Karma Yoga
4)Bhakti Yoga

Vedas.

Wrong thread?

 

[Screambowl]

Wrong thread?

reply to post #87