faithfulguy
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2009
- Messages
- 13,651
- Reaction score
- -2
- Country
- Location
I was not replying to your post, I was comment on it.
Since you have ludicrously claimed that genealogical mapping via linguistic is infallible, there is nothing to argue.
The reality is that any "estimate" of genealogy based on linguistic is only their best Guesstimate since there are a thousand variables that could have affected linguistic. The ONLY infallible methodology is Genetic mapping.
But you OTOH has put them on equal pedestal. Now if that is not desperate, then I do not know what is.
Again, genetic mapping is next to impossible in north India because of a riots invaders, starting from Aryan invasion. So we rely on linguistic study. There are not thousand of variables when study linguistics. You just made up your own facts. There are scientific methods on determining human migration based on linguistics. And it points to Aryan invasion, the general view of western country.
Just because you disagree with the result doesn't mean the method is confusing or incorrect. You arguement are sad and incoherent.