How likely is Iran's direct involvement in Iraq?

[F117]

The Iraqi matter is so comlicated hence all the problem we face. So I want to comment about the issue in two seperate lines IRAQ. and IRAN.

For Iraq the problem start from the day one when they wrote the constitution and accept to divide the the authoreties between three parts thad none of them trust the other.

The SHIITE.

wanted a democracy regime so they can participate in controlling their country as a right they have since they are the majority. Now their mistake is that accept the form of
Government sectarian quotas. They should never accept that since the country just got out of decades of dectatorship that was supported by the loosers of war and power.

SUNNI. on the other hand Sunnis never supported a democracy regime in Iraq since they will loose ruling the country a prevelige they had for centuries Plus in general the Sunni views about Shiite never been fair let alone good and accepting the Shiite as a rival all that we can see today chrystal clear.

Kurds. are not interested in been Iraqi neither united Iraq nor Iraq under a strong central government so they change their support between the Shiite and Sunni whenever its in their favour.

So what is the solution for this mess? In my opinion its should be done this way.

FIRST. form a government of majority and send home all other ministers home.

SECOND. clean the army from the Baathist also clean the security branches from them too.

THIRD. make a strong line that separate the cities under IS this way you defend what you have also you can start train your forces and prepaire for the libration of the rest of country.

IRAN. Iran's policy in Iraq come from.

First. fear they fear the move of the unrest in Iraq to their home so they try to help to contain that abroad.

Secon. Religiously they think they should defend the religious sites.

Third. Iran want to keep what they call the resistive front and keep some allies in the region absolutely the fall of Iraq in the hand of Sunnis will break or damage that front.

I think Iran should help in a way were make Iraqis the fighting with supporting them with better training and directing of some fighting plan.

For those who say that shia melitia should be under the army comand I would say you were wrong since the army is corrupted to the bones and must of it's generals are incompetants actually those generals even didn't feed the volunteers they should be executed publicly I mean those generals.

That's how I see it.

Iraq need to start acting now they need to put aside all the sunnis kurds rights for an interim period they need to builed a strong army in cooperation with the US, Russia and China.

they need to put the country pride the country safety the country prosperity first while keep the sectarian quote for future I say that because baath and terrorists enetrated this government deeply I'm sure many PM's and officers are working hand to hand with the terrorists.
Eonough with playing they need to start acting seriously.

Some good ideas here, but it looks like the current government still holds on to quotas to appease the minorities. About a week ago:

Iraq MPs approve two key ministers - Middle East - Al Jazeera English
Sunni Muslim approved as new defence minister

 

[1000]

Some good ideas here, but it looks like the current government still holds on to quotas to appease the minorities. About a week ago:

Iraq MPs approve two key ministers - Middle East - Al Jazeera English
Sunni Muslim approved as new defence minister

At least this time ministers with brains are appointed in contrary to the previous regime, the def minister is from Mosul himself he's not happy with foreigners ruling his city.

 

[haman10]

The Iraqi matter is so comlicated hence all the problem we face. So I want to comment about the issue in two seperate lines IRAQ. and IRAN.

For Iraq the problem start from the day one when they wrote the constitution and accept to divide the the authoreties between three parts thad none of them trust the other.

The SHIITE.

wanted a democracy regime so they can participate in controlling their country as a right they have since they are the majority. Now their mistake is that accept the form of
Government sectarian quotas. They should never accept that since the country just got out of decades of dectatorship that was supported by the loosers of war and power.

SUNNI. on the other hand Sunnis never supported a democracy regime in Iraq since they will loose ruling the country a prevelige they had for centuries Plus in general the Sunni views about Shiite never been fair let alone good and accepting the Shiite as a rival all that we can see today chrystal clear.

Kurds. are not interested in been Iraqi neither united Iraq nor Iraq under a strong central government so they change their support between the Shiite and Sunni whenever its in their favour.

So what is the solution for this mess? In my opinion its should be done this way.

FIRST. form a government of majority and send home all other ministers home.

SECOND. clean the army from the Baathist also clean the security branches from them too.

THIRD. make a strong line that separate the cities under IS this way you defend what you have also you can start train your forces and prepaire for the libration of the rest of country.

IRAN. Iran's policy in Iraq come from.

First. fear they fear the move of the unrest in Iraq to their home so they try to help to contain that abroad.

Secon. Religiously they think they should defend the religious sites.

Third. Iran want to keep what they call the resistive front and keep some allies in the region absolutely the fall of Iraq in the hand of Sunnis will break or damage that front.

I think Iran should help in a way were make Iraqis the fighting with supporting them with better training and directing of some fighting plan.

For those who say that shia melitia should be under the army comand I would say you were wrong since the army is corrupted to the bones and must of it's generals are incompetants actually those generals even didn't feed the volunteers they should be executed publicly I mean those generals.

That's how I see it.

Iraq need to start acting now they need to put aside all the sunnis kurds rights for an interim period they need to builed a strong army in cooperation with the US, Russia and China.

they need to put the country pride the country safety the country prosperity first while keep the sectarian quote for future I say that because baath and terrorists enetrated this government deeply I'm sure many PM's and officers are working hand to hand with the terrorists.
Eonough with playing they need to start acting seriously.

Iranian interests in iraq gets limited to :

1- trying to keep one of its allies on its feet

2- protecting iraqi people (although , who are we kidding ? from iraqi people i mostly mean shias in iraq due to ISIS's targeted terrorism)

so you are so right on those points that u made . iran tried its best to show everyone it does NOT hold sectarian view of the muslim world by allying itself with Hamas , the regime in turkey , pakistan and so forth . our views have not changed and will never do , although we have to do what we gotta do , for Ex. the issue of amerli and the shia turkmen there who were on the verge of being massacred . now everyone is free to call us safavid shia (rafidha as those terrorists say) army . they are so dumb to understand that we are freaking proud of it .

iran's sincere actions can be not only seen on the ground but also on the skies : where iranian heavily upgraded Su-25s are bombing the shyte out of terrorists with their iranian made laser/TV guided munitions .

those aircraft's upgrades took a decade to complete , and now they are considered as a gift to the iraqi AF .

please note that no one is a saint , we all have our mistakes , sometimes grave , sometimes not .

but till now , i am so freaking proud of my country's performance regarding the issues in iraq and syria .

=============

on the issue of iraq : the newly appointed cabinet and the new govt. leader himself , are doing a much better job than Mr.maliki and his cabinet IMHO .

not being much of an expert on iraq , i could see the results of this new cabinet on the war already : the war in which both Sunni and Shia muslims are on one side :

kicking the terrorists out of their nation

 

[jack 86000]

Jalula or Saadia