How different a Bengali Muslim is from a Pakistani Muslim?

[Safada]

The difference between Bengalis and Punjabis is about 20-25% and its largely due to east Asian dna than ASI.The sample used in this chart is BEB from 100genome which is lower caste hindus sample from Dhaka,they lack indo Aryan related alleles and has slightly higher ASI than average Bangladeshis. There are three types of ANI in south Asian, one is from neolithic Iran and is present is every south Asians, another is from proto Indo aryans,which is only present in Afghans,Pakistanis,North Indians and Bangladeshis, but absent in South Indians and Balochis.There are some archaic ANI present in ASI as well.
ASI itself is around half ASE(ancestral south eurasian) and the other half contains archaic west eurasian dna, but the genealogist cant 100% confirm it because there arent any sample tested from paleolithic south Asia.
Based on some calculators on gedmatch,Bengalis have around 20-25% ASE compared to North Indian's 20-30%,South Indian's 28-40%,Pakistani-Punjabis 13-20% and Pashtun's 10-15%.

The Pakistani guys later told that he thought my cousin as a Pakistani Pathan, my cousin isnt darker skinned than pathans, he is olive skinned like many pathans or balochis,but the real reson he got mistaken as pathan is due to his hook nose,height and robust built and thick eyebrows, there are bengalis with fair skin as south Europeans as well.


The red coding is heavily western eurasian/ANI or Iran Neolithic alongside ASI.For example,Gujaratis have more red than south Indians.
Interestingly some Bengalis showing some kalash/yellow as well, Kalash has been so isolated that they become something unique.

Half of Bangladeshis are not local dalit convert lol only few bengali muslims are hindu convert.
Majority of Bangladeshi muslims never were Hindu, they were Mahayana and Vajrayana Buddhisht for thousands of years,for example under Pala Empire and buddhist dont believe in any caste system.
Genetically Bangladeshi muslims are like North Indian Kshatriyas or middle caste hindus,if you exclude 10-15% east Asian dna Bangladeshis score.

I've actually read that your average middle class bengali is genetically similar to gujratis with a shift towards burmese. However significant diversity does exist. I'm not really sure if a lot of bengalis know this or not, but in sylhet there are villages where zamindars of the villages are actually descendants of one of Shah Jalal's 360 followers who came from Persia and the Middle east to propagate Islam around the 14th century. As far as I know Shah Jalal stayed a bachelor all his life, but he gave his disciples the permission to marry the local people in the hills of sylhet after converting them to Islam - According to many sources including the book: Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier.

My mom's side of the family are descendants of Shah Helim Uddin Chowdhury who was from Yemen. Most of the people from my mom's side of the family including my mom are really fair skinned. My mom herself has been confused as an afgan occasionally by afgans themselves. Albeit, I know that a lot of Yemenis are dark skinned, but I think we got a fair skinned Yemeni in our family. All this is strictly anecdotal however as we don't have any genetic testings to prove it but a log/book in our family home that contains a family tree and ancestors. Our family book itself contains scriptures written in Farsi.

General Osmani is a descendant of Shah Nizamuddin Osmani, a 14th-century associate of Shah Jalal. We know some of Osmani's distant relatives in Canada, some of them actually show arab/persian phenotypes, which includes milk white skin and beautiful eyebrows.

Hell Zubaida Rahman the wife of Tarique Rahman is also sylheti and she looks a bit pathan, I'm sure she's got some afgan influence in her family as she comes from a high class family.

 

[Shahzaz ud din]

Markandey Katju - Pakistan has become a Jurassic park:... | Facebook
Pakistan is a 'fake' country: Markandey Katju - Times of India

Any thing said by an Indian !!!
---about India is actually a fact.
---about Pakistan is a propaganda.

 

[Asian.Century]

As different as Zimbabwe is to England!!!

 

[doorstar]

[----] Their similarity is that they have same religion.

Not quite same but similar, if I start pointing out differences of religion I'll certainly get banned again. Amusingly enough I'm finding they also have similarities with Hindus (whom they claim not to like) too.

Get me permission of mods and I'll gladly explain (I have found that even all Pakistanis --with the exception of Armed Services-- do not have same version of Islam let alone having the same one as banglas).

Anyhoo, enjoy this video and note the bindia and think which 2 countries it is most commonly worn and what is its significance.

 

[Trango Towers]

I read in PDF that Bengalis are way different from Pakistanis. I wonder how different are Bengalis compared to Pakistanis? Isn't Pakistan itself a multi ethnic country with several different cultures? Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashtun, Baloch, Tribal culture etc.

You title is very misleading and contrary to your opening question...
First let me answer your title.
How can 2 Muslims be different. Even sects in Islam are wrong and here is why.
1. What sect was prophet Muhammad? If he was just a Muslim then why are you in a sect. If you aretruly a Muslim then your would accept without reservation the revelations in the Quran and the teachings of the authentic hadith. You would only do as the prophet did and reject all the other mumbo jumbo of the jahil maulvis sheikhs and mullahs. So having said that can two Muslim from different parts forbthe world be different. Answer is NO....the absolutely cannot.

2. Pakistan comprises of many ethnic groups under one nations. Just making Bangladesh. You have Hindus, you have tribal you have seylhetis who do not like people from Dhaka but you are still one nation.

 

[Safada]

Not quite same but similar, if I start pointing out differences of religion I'll certainly get banned again. Amusingly enough I'm finding they also have similarities with Hindus (whom they claim not to like) too.

Get me permission of mods and I'll gladly explain (I have found that even all Pakistanis --with the exception of Armed Services-- do not have same version of Islam let alone having the same one as banglas).

Anyhoo, enjoy this video and note the bindia and think which 2 countries it is most commonly worn and what is its significance.

Yup, man that's the embarassing thing about our bengali people. They are highly influenced by west bengal culture who are Kafirs for the most part. The bengali people picked up some really bad habits from them which includes committing shirk by salaming their elders by the feet, celebrating Boishaki (bengali new year) when they really should only be following the Islamic calender exclusively. Dhaka has statues celebrating the Mukti Bahani as heroes everywhere including statues of Mujib Rahman. As far as I know Pakistan does not have any statues of Jinnah. The worst is the bindi wearing "fashion", our fellow muslim bengalis justify it by using culture as an excuse, on the contrary I read that it's got pure hindu origins and symbolism behind it everywhere on the internet; I personally find it ugly on girls no matter how beautiful the girl is. Finally the youth of bangladesh have adopted Holi into their culture recently, like WTF. Haseena and Awami have completely corrupted the minds of the bangladeshi youth. Not surprised, you can wiki that Haseena's neice- Tulip Siddiq- is pretty much a Jew now married to a white guy, with a child who attends a jewish nursery school.

It's a pretty fucked up family in general. I can totally see the reason why Mujib Rahman's assassins wanted to completely incinerate his family and generation.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Yup, man that's the embarassing thing about our bengali people. They are highly influenced by west bengal culture who are Kaffirs for the most part. The bengali people picked up some really bad habits from them which includes committing shirk by salaming their elders by the feet, celebrating Boishaki (bengali new year) when they really should only be following the Islamic calender exclusively. Dhaka has statues celebrating the Mukti Bahani as heroes everywhere including statues of Mujib Rahman. As far as I know Pakistan does not have any statues of Jinnah. The worst is the bindi wearing "fashion", our fellow muslim bengalis justify it by using culture as an excuse, on the contrary I read that it's got pure hindu origins and symbolism behind it everywhere on the internet; I personally find it ugly on girls no matter how beautiful the girl is. Finally the youth of bangladesh have adapted Holi into their culture recently, like WTF. Haseena and Awami have completely corrupted the minds of the bangladeshi youth. Not surprised, you can wiki that Haseena's neice- Tulip Siddiq- is pretty much a Jew now married to a white guy, with a child who attends a jewish nursery school.

It's a pretty fucked up family in general. I can totally see the reason why Mujib Rahman's assassins wanted to completely incinerate his family and generation.

Must be younger generation. Younger generation in Pakistan is also influenced by bollywood culture, but not as much as how you described. Anyways, those Pakistanis are mostly called 'burgers' and live in bigger cities.

 

[doorstar]

[---- ]committing shirk by salaming their elders by the feet, [----]

Once I went to a Pakistani (kashmiri + punjabi couple) wedding and saw bridegroom salaming his his new mother in law by by touching her feet.

 

[Safada]

Must be younger generation. Younger generation in Pakistan is also influenced by bollywood culture, but not as much as how you described. Anyways, those Pakistanis are mostly called 'burgers' and live in bigger cities.

The bangladeshi youth are disgusting. I can't even relate with them. We have a lot of bangladeshi fobs who come to Canada to attend university, believe me they are most despicable south asian kids I've ever seen. All of a suddenly you see these kids getting into drinking alcohol and committing all these harami acts and everything as if they are trying to fit in with North American society , to me they come off as pretentious and embarrassing. The boys think they are all garam masala and everything deluding themselves into thinking they can score white girls lol. As far as I know that shit only works in bangladesh. I can't count the amount of times I've seen an ugly bangladeshi guy marrying a pretty bangladesh girl finding out it was a love marriage!

 

[doorstar]

The bangladeshi youth are disgusting. I can't even relate with them. We have a lot of bangladeshi fobs who come to Canada to attend university, believe me they are most despicable south asian kids I've ever seen. All of a suddenly you see these kids getting into drinking alcohol and committing all these harami acts and everything as if they are trying to fit in with North American society , to me they come off as pretentious and embarrassing. The boys think they are all garam masala and everything deluding themselves into thinking they can score white girls lol. As far as I know that shit only works in bangladesh. I can't the count amount of times I've seen an ugly bangladeshi guy marrying a pretty bangladesh girl finding out it was a love marriage!

Many people from Sub-continent and arabia are like that. Since in their home countries they are told that we are promiscuous and drink alcohol etc. So upon arrival they soon go on a campaign of drunkenness and sexual assaults.

In 2015 UK invited some Libyan soldiers to train here, they soon went on a raping spree after being stopped and confined to barracks pending deportation they went on barracks wrecking rampage causing more than £472,000 in damage

 

[ashok mourya]

I read in PDF that Bengalis are way different from Pakistanis. I wonder how different are Bengalis compared to Pakistanis? Isn't Pakistan itself a multi ethnic country with several different cultures? Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashtun, Baloch, Tribal culture etc.

Bengalis are Bengali and Punjabi are Punjabi..culture is more prominent in these society than religion....

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Bengalis are Bengali and Punjabi are Punjabi..culture is more prominent in these society than religion....

Not true. I am a Punjabi and can get along with religious Bangladeshis more than Sikhs even If we speak the same language. There are two different sets of culture being played here. Ethnic and then religious.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

Not true. I am a Punjabi and can get along with religious Bangladeshis more than Sikhs even If we speak the same language. There are two different sets of culture being played here. Ethnic and then religious.

Was your earlier id razpak?

 

[Safada]

Not true. I am a Punjabi and can get along with religious Bangladeshis more than Sikhs even If we speak the same language. There are two different sets of culture being played here. Ethnic and then religious.

I get along pretty well with Pakistanis in Canada as well. Our local mosques rotate between Imams every week, my favourite one is the Pakistani one - He is very humble and humorous about South Asian culture. I've attended my fair share of weddings involving a Bangladeshi( more specifically sylheti) and Pakistani. Ummah symbolism is pretty strong when we stand for Maghrib prayers together at the weddings.

 

[waz]

Once I went to a Pakistani (kashmiri + punjabi couple) wedding and saw bridegroom salaming his his new mother in law by by touching her feet.

I've never seen that at any wedding from any Pakistani ethnicity, and I'm talking about hundreds of events.