What's new

How come Iran/Persia never became an Arab/Arabized Nation?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Conversions were discouraged as they resulted in loss of revenues..so much for Jihad to spread islam or rather Jihad to loot plunder kill r@ape and orgy! What were khalifas thinking anyways?

You really do suit your name. You know as well as I do that war was the norm back in the day, how many years did the Byzantines and Persians fight out their battles in the middle east?? Did you know that the Byzantines tried to invade Arabia and it were stopped by the Persians?? That was a rhetorical question, of course you do not know because you are just full of hot air. The Persians have moved on but for some reason your *** is still burning.
 
.
But then how would you explain countless examples where a superior civilization fall victim to inferior albeit militarily stronger one.

An example would be destruction of IVC by invading Aryans.

The IVC had poor metal works compared to the Aryans, who carried the wheeled Chariot and the Infamous long Sword.
 
. .
The people in Mesopotamia and whole the western area until Morocco were arabized after the Muslims conquered Middle East and North Africa.


But the Persians still speak Farsi and Arabs in Persia/Iran number only 1-2 million out of 70 million Parsi, Azeris, Lurs etc ? Despite being practically the first Major power the Caliphate'ul Rashidun had defeated.



Obviously, you have never visited QOM.:D
 
.
I heard it was because it was an Indo-European speaking culture, thus too difficult to arabize them to the same extend as the Aramaic of Iraq/Levent, the Berbers of N.Africa and the Copts of Egypt, which speaks an Afro-Asiatic Language like Arabic.

It depends on your definition of Arabize. The arabs did not even enter their cities for anything but taxes after they had captured Persia and kept to their garrisons they built for themselves. The Ummayads when they took over wanted the money the taxes were providing so they did not encourage any conversions but eventually Persians started converting anyway.
 
.
I heard it was because it was an Indo-European speaking culture, thus too difficult to arabize them to the same extend as the Aramaic of Iraq/Levent, the Berbers of N.Africa and the Copts of Egypt, which speaks an Afro-Asiatic Language like Arabic.

Wrong..Arabic language was extensively enforced while local culture and languages were suppressed by force..the Berbers of Africa never came to accept Arabs and the tensions continue to this day.


Berbers (Amazigh) are the descendants of the original inhabitants of North Africa, going back at least to the fifth century B.C. Punic settlement was the first challenge to Berber culture. Roman, Vandal, Byzantine and Arab rule followed. The Arab invasion of the seventh century brought about the Arabization of several cities and most of the coastal area, but most of Algeria’s countryside remained Tamazight-speaking well into the 12th century. The Arabization of the countryside accelerated during the invasion of Arab nomads from Egypt in the late 11th century and by the late 18th century Berber speakers were limited to the least accessible parts of the country – high mountains, distant oases and desert plateaus, and mountain areas where the vast majority of Berbers live today. These areas include: Kabylia (Djurdia Mountains) southeast of Algiers, the Aures Mountains southeast of Constantine and Ouarseni Massiv, southwest of Algiers.

Berbers have a long history of resisting Arab rule, despite being converted to Islam in the 8th century. They were periodically able to maintain independent kingdoms and empires from shortly after the time of the Arab invasion until the 16th century. They resisted the rule of the Ottoman Turks. They also opposed French colonial rule despite a policy of preferential treatment by the French. In 1857, almost 30 years after conquering Algeria from the Ottomans, France finally took administrative control over Kabylia (AUTLOST = 1). Even once the French took control, the Berbers in Kabylia continued to resist, In 1876, 1882 and 1897, the Berbers in Kabylia staged massive uprisings against French forces. Kabylians also participated heavily in the Algerian War of Independence.

The majority of Algerians have at least some Berber heritage, and many are descendents of Arabized Berbers (RACE = 0). However, only roughly 20 percent of the population identify themselves as Berber (GPRO06 = 22). Due to their shared heritage, the primary distinguishing characteristic of Berbers is linguistic, although some cultural traits are also relevant (CUSTOM04-06 = 1). Linguistic distinctions, along with territorial concentration, have resulted in a strong identity forming among Berbers.

The ruling Arab majority decided to Arabize Algeria following independence in 1963 to counter the French colonial influence on their state. This included making Arabic the only official language of Algeria. While the Berbers were not the direct target of this policy, they suffered from it. Linguistic discrimination became the driving force behind the formation of Berber political parties. In 1963, the Socialist Forces Front (FFS) split off from the National Liberation Front (FLN), which has been Algeria’s dominant political party both during the revolution and for most of Algeria’s history. The FFS, which continues to be a Berber-dominated party, consistently calls for official status for Tamazight (the Berber language) and for a secular, pluralist polity. The FFS also calls for greater autonomy for Berber-dominated regions and more Berber input into central policy decisions (POLGR06 = 3). The FLN, which has controlled Algeria’s government since independence, has virtually excluded Berbers from high-ranking positions within the party. This policy has effectively excluded Berbers from high-ranking positions in Algeria’s government.

In 1989, the Rally for Culture and Democracy (RCD) was formed as a Berber political party, focusing on Berber cultural rights as well as broader democratization issues. The RCD and the FFS have also jointly formed the Berber Cultural Movement (MCB) as an umbrella organization under which the two parties undertake joint action. In 1999, RCD joined the coalition government, marking the first time since independence a Berber-dominated party has been part of a ruling coalition. While this is an important signal of increased Berber inclusion, the RCD has not been successful in pushing Berber linguistic issues (CULGR04-06 = 2). Since the violence of 2001, the FFS and the RCD have been joined by two more influential parties, the Berber Citizens Movement and the Movement for the Autonomy of Kabylie (MAK), which is based primarily in France due to its illegal status (GOJPA04-06 = 2).

During the 1980s and 1990s, the challenge to the Algerian government by the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) and other Islamic parties constituted a new challenge for the Berbers. These parties call for the Islamization of Algeria which includes the mandatory use of Arabic in schools and government. This has resulted in both governmental concessions in that area and sporadic direct confrontations between the secular Berber parties and Islamic fundamentalists. While the fundamentalists were forced into a tactical retreat by the late 1990s, they still constitute a major threat to Berber populations and aspirations for several reasons. First, their appeal is strong among the Algerian population. Second, several fundamentalist militants retreated into the Berber-dominated Kabylia region, one of the more inaccessible regions to security forces and also one of the most staunchly secular regions. Sporadic attacks, which have resulted in the deaths of several Berbers, have continued up through 2006 (CCGROUPSEV106 = 3).

MAR | Data | Assessment for Berbers in Algeria
 
.
The IVC had poor metal works compared to the Aryans, who carried the wheeled Chariot and the Infamous long Sword.


Well that was my point.

Military strength,if superior enough to dominate whole demography could even overcome superior cultures.
 
.
Persia has a very strong culture, heritage and language and Arabs have actually plagiarized a lot from Romans, Semites and Persians. There is no way a strong civilization could be become dominated by an inferior one. Hence why Persia never became Arabized while countries like Roman-Arabia and Egypt lost their language due to massive exodus, genocide and suppression - a large part of their culture still survived.

Arabs are Semites. Think before you speak bozo. :rolleyes:
 
.
Why wasn't Iran Arabized? Mainly because of this guy:
Ferdowsi - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Ferdowsi.jpg




Not just Firdousi.

How about Rumi, Omar Khayyam, Hafiz, Saadi, Jami and whole lot more of the the World renowned Persian Poets.
 
.
It depends on your definition of Arabize. The arabs did not even enter their cities for anything but taxes after they had captured Persia and kept to their garrisons they built for themselves. The Ummayads when they took over wanted the money the taxes were providing so they did not encourage any conversions but eventually Persians started converting anyway.

I would like to learn more about how the Rashidun caliphate colonized and managed Iran during their rule. Do you have any academic sources regarding that? Something about the policies and Rashidun caliphate governance over Persia.
 
.
It depends on your definition of Arabize. The arabs did not even enter their cities for anything but taxes after they had captured Persia and kept to their garrisons they built for themselves. The Ummayads when they took over wanted the money the taxes were providing so they did not encourage any conversions but eventually Persians started converting anyway.

Again the false feel-good Islamic history propaganda...The invading Arab forces engaged in extensive genocide of Persians, looting. plundering and enslavement of children. There are famous stories about how Persian crown jewels were chopped with swords and shared as war booty and the taking of Yazgerd daughter Sherbano as a war booty. It is proudly taught how Islamic invasion demolished every brick in Persia.

Abo Lolo plotted for the murder of Khalifah Umar after he became dishearten by the enslavement and poor treatment of Persian children by Arabs.

The Arab invasion of Persia created massive exodus of Persians into India who would come to be known as Parsi's later on.

Arabs are Semites. Think before you speak bozo. :rolleyes:

No they are not. The only Arabized Semitic country is Yemen while there are also many Arabized Semitic tribes like the Quraysh of Makkah!

You wouldn't called them Arabized Semites if they were the same people!
 
.
I would like to learn more about how the Rashidun caliphate colonized and managed Iran during their rule. Do you have any academic sources regarding that? Something about the policies and Rashidun caliphate governance over Persia.

You should read the book 'The Great Arab conquest'. Find it on Ebay or Amazon.
 
.
Not just Firdousi.

How about Rumi, Omar Khayyam, Hafiz, Saadi and whole lot more of the the World renowned Persian Poets.

Yes, but Ferdowsi is the one who came first. His whole mission was to save the Persian language, which he accomplished with the Shahnameh. The rest of the poets you mentioned built on the foundations that Ferdowsi laid.
 
. .
Again the false feel-good Islamic history propaganda...The invading Arab forces engaged in extensive genocide of Persians, looting. plundering and enslavement of children. There are famous stories about how Persian crown jewels were chopped with swords and shared as war booty and the taking of Yazgerd daughter Sherbano as a war booty. It is proudly taught how Islamic invasion demolished every brick in Persia.

Abo Lolo plotted for the murder of Khalifah Umar after he became dishearten by the enslavement and poor treatment of Persian children by Arabs.

The Arab invasion of Persia created massive exodus of Persians into India who would come to be known as Parsi's later on.

If that was the case why is it that when they removed the Ummayads, they remained Muslim? When they removed the Abbasids, they remained Muslim? When they removed the Samanids, they remained Muslim? When they removed the Ghaznavids, they remained Muslim?? When the Mongols destroyed the Khwarazmian dynasty and allowed Persians to choose their own religion why then did they once again choose Islam?? Would they have not finally rid themselves of its yoke if Islam was the problem??

Instead what happened? Persians remained proud Muslims and not only retained Islam but spread it to the Indian subcontinent, to the Turks, to China even. Islam is not an Arab religion, if it was it would have collapsed from within long ago. You may take your leave bozo.

I would like to learn more about how the Rashidun caliphate colonized and managed Iran during their rule. Do you have any academic sources regarding that? Something about the policies and Rashidun caliphate governance over Persia.

You can google it for starters, google islamization of Iran. Next google conversion of Iran to shia islam. You will then see what happens when force really is applied on a losing nation back in those days.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom