How can Pakistan Navy defend itself from Brahmos cruse missile ?

[Mitro]

Ofcourse IN will defend and are very professional navy no doubt about it. but PN has Missile that are proven in war and Brahmos is not proven so cannot say same for them.



QUOTE="ni8mare, post: 6844492, member: 146128"]we do know that brahmos is 300+km .............what ever
ok lets agree with you .............
now consider this when PN do same ..........means PN use AShm will IN will able to defend or IN will be in the bottom of the sea?


so we dont have NCW...........

 

[wiseone2]

Phalanx, Goalkeeper etc can all hit supersonic targets. It is just that with those speeds, even if you destroy the missile close in, the debris (including unspent missile fuel) will still hit and damage your ship. Hence the need to put the moment of kill farther out, away from the ship.

Brahmos, like Moskit or Krypton or Club 3M-54 are all dangerous. But relatively easy to detect by radar, IIR/Thermal and ESM, and all rely mainly on active radar for hitting their target, thus are susceptable to ECM. Not invincible.

CM-400AKG makes a terminal dive to mach 5 rather than just mach 2-3 and imho is more difficult to kill in the terminal stage. However, prior to reaching terminal stage, it flies a high(er) flight path, which makes it more detectable sooner. So, there is a trade off. It is not a simple comparison.

can you defend against multiple missiles ?

 

[Penguin]

can you defend against multiple missiles ?

Why do you think we got VLS systems for SAMs and multifunction radars like APAR.

 

[QAMARSHAZADQURESHI]

It is known that India already develop Brahmos supersonic cruse missile for its Navy and also develop a version for its air-force .How can Pakistan Navy defend with its current arsenal and what will be the future requirement to defend itself from both air launch and ship launch Brahmos cruse Missile .here is a relevant thread regrading how USN can defend Brahmos
How to defend Brahmos?- American analysis.

[

 

[monitor]

 

[John Reese]

ok

 

[kaonalpha]

By not giving an F****.

 

[Mangus Ortus Novem]

Brahmos is not the wonder super weapon its being made out to be. It is a decent weapon system no denying it.

It is not like now PNS and for that matter any one standing in the way of this CM is just helpless. Nonsense.

The best defence PNS has is ECM and jammers. But these systems are for overall defensive sepctrum.

PNS is already developing counter strategies only they won't say much... given their budget they will never go ship for shop but more 20/80 configuration. Which is quite smart.

SPD/PNS needs to come up with an umbrella of solutions for their coastal defences... no one is going to do any blockades... apart from rhetorical. Deterence is quite solid for now.

 

[Bratva]

By Reciting these ayat - e - Kareema

 

[Delnavaz B]

By Reciting these ayat - e - Kareema

Plus retaliating with C802, Harpoon and CM-400AKG or before Indian attack we would unleashed what best we have.

 

[Super Falcon]

Pakistan defence think tank completely forgets navy when modernizing it's focus on army this is why only 1 missile like sarbjeet made for navy but for army so many missile

Fact is enemy will attack from sea after it our army can't do anything once PN destroyed army has to fight at sea shores too

Better equip navy and specially Marines do wonders for us

For time being army should stop it's modernization pace let nave have some funds

 

[90ArsalanLeo]

Umm, Nirbhay. BrahMos-2 and Barak-8 ER.

Umm even nirbhay prototype hasnt hit 1 target it keeps deviating from trajectory and crashing. Its not ready. Nirbhay & Brahmos are not SAM missiles lol

And the IN aircraft carrier is for show? LOL!! IN will take the fight to Pakistan. PN will always be fighting a defensive war.

Brahmos is anti-ship not land-attack. Nirbhay with a range of 1500 km is for that role. By the time you induct C-602 IN will induct Brahmos-2. PN cannot match IN in at least another 20 years. PN frigates weigh 2,200 tonnes. IN Shivalik class is 6,000 tonne.

Like IN took the show in 65 & 71 wars in 65 war ur majority navy ships didnt even left the mumbai port. I have to given IN the credit of being superior in technology but its not everything in battle. Nirbhay isnt ready ur 3rd trial in 2015 was a failure. We already have C-602 missiles since 2014-15

 

[Tamilnadu]

Umm even nirbhay prototype hasnt hit 1 target it keeps deviating from trajectory and crashing. Its not ready. Nirbhay & Brahmos are not SAM missiles lol



Like IN took the show in 65 & 71 wars in 65 war ur majority navy ships didnt even left the mumbai port. I have to given IN the credit of being superior in technology but its not everything in battle. Nirbhay isnt ready ur 3rd trial in 2015 was a failure. We already have C-602 missiles since 2014-15

Now that India has entered the missile tech restriction group,not just nirbhay ,many other missiles will be tested and inducted.

 

[Mangus Ortus Novem]

The balance of power in the region will always be maintained. The beligerent hegemon will remain constrained. For peace, stabilit and development. PNS has been the most neglected force. But things have been changing without much brovado. Within five years the results on the ground i.e. surface/subsurface will demonstrate this. PNS won't waste money on ship for ship build up rather a doctronal change making all these rhetorical advantage null and void.

Pak forces will keep the possibility of any agression unbearably costly for the beligerent hegemon. No worries.

 

[tarrar]

India is obsessed & going nuts on only functional missile in their arsenal.