Hindutva outfit launches campaign to ban Fajr Adhan in India

[Secret Service]

Now there you go generalizing. I'm a Hindu and I earlier stated that I like the sound of the azaan

but the title of this thread says so ...

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

I didn't know there are so many muslims in Tamil nadu to warrant such measures

I hopee you know where mangalore is. It is in Karnataka.

 

[IndoUS]

and there is no harm with loud speakers..it is everywhere in the world..only hindus have problem...

No, there is a problem with that here in the US, there was even a case in the US when people in Detroit were angry at the city for allowing the Islamic center to use loud speakers 5 times a day for call for prayer. Dearborn near Detroit has the largest Muslim population in this part of the world, so yes it is not just Hindus.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

but the title of this thread says so ...

A few Hindus in a nation of millions of Hindus say they don't appreciate the azaan and you make a blanket statement

 

[Robinhood Pandey]

but the title of this thread says so ...

Its a doctored title. no one is asking to ban Adhan. all they are asking is to not to use loudspeakers early in the morning.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

I hopee you know where mangalore is. It is in Karnataka.

Try calling a Kanara a Tamil and see what will happen to you

 

[HAIDER]

That's very interesting question. If majority non Muslims raise objection about Azan then hiow to resolve this issue. ?.
To Hindu respected members can you give some example or any court jurisdiction ? .
@Joe Shearer

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

You are still a part of Subcontinent . Pakistan's Landmass has not drifted towards middle east or central asia after division .

Actually they are a part of Middle east

 

[Indischer]

I didn't know there are so many muslims in Tamil nadu to warrant such measures

Mangalore is in karnataka.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Try calling a Kanara a Tamil and see what will happen to you

I have noticed.. ! MAny north Indians club the entire South Indians under the name "Madarasis" and think, Tamil is the language of all the 4 states

 

[shuntmaster]

and there is no harm with loud speakers..it is everywhere in the world..only hindus have problem...

Mosques in Australia don't have loudspeakers...

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

That's very interesting question. If majority non Muslims raise objection about Azan then hiow to resolve this issue. ?.
To Hindu respected members can you give some example or any court jurisdiction ? .

Court Jurisdiction is not to use loud speakers from 10pm to 6am. Its actually general in nature. All Loud speakers are banned. So Azaan. Nobody have thought about it, yet. Either they can go to SC and get a reprieve telling about religious sensitivities, or follow the guidelines regarding the use of loud-speakers.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

That's very interesting question. If majority non Muslims raise objection about Azan then hiow to resolve this issue. ?.
To Hindu respected members can you give some example or any court jurisdiction ? .

Freedom of religion and religious activities are guaranteed in India. Unless a dictator takes over, it is highly unlikely that the Supreme Court of India will uphold any law banning the Azaan

 

[Indischer]

I have noticed.. ! MAny north Indians club the entire South Indians under the name "Madarasis" and think, Tamil is the language of all the 4 states

I find that funny.
But I can never reconcile with those North Indians who call us South Indians as Rakshashaas, Ravan's progeny etc etc.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

I have noticed.. ! MAny north Indians club the entire South Indians under the name "Madarasis" and think, Tamil is the language of all the 4 states

When I was a little kid we visited Bangalore. I made the mistake of asking a person speaking Kanara whether he was speaking Tamil. He told me that I was lucky to be a kid or else he would have thumped me