Govt asks economist Atif Mian to step down from Economic Advisory Council

[LeGenD]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1020448115621580800

lo ji .... Jibran Nasir is the greatest and the most competent political leader according to this economic expert that some are crying over!

Remember your Earth is Flat thread?

What is your point?

If you want to assess him then read his publications.

@T-Faz

Indeed Sir. I get similar impression now.

 

[BHarwana]

Mr Verve and Mr Bharwa seem to be in an on going character defamation circle jerk mode, liking everything they post.

CPEC needs to be transparent because the terms of it can worsen Pakistan's economic condition. Atif's suggestion for Pakistan is to improve domestic productivity, grow exports and develop a sustainable economy. Not solely focus on projects by foreign entities which are susceptible to foreign factors and dictation.

Remember kids, economy is X + C + I + G - M.

X for exports, C for domestic consumption, I for investment, G for government expenditure - M for imports. CPEC could end up being an import heavy project and Pakistani's would end up crying themselves to sleep every night.

As I said I am not against this guy at all bro. Just went through his tweets and there was a lot of stuff about CPEC. I just don't like that stuff by him. Put another Ahmadi in the panel I will be fine. Please read my previous posts they are all in his favor but after some digging I came across his tweets which I have shared.

I love the minorities in my country but the concerns I have raised are valid.

 

[Jf Thunder]

hmm, strange
the PTI government didnt seem like, that they'd bow before extremists

 

[Verve]

Mr Verve and Mr Bharwa seem to be in an on going character defamation circle jerk mode, liking everything they post.

CPEC needs to be transparent because the terms of it can worsen Pakistan's economic condition. Atif's suggestion for Pakistan is to improve domestic productivity, grow exports and develop a sustainable economy. Not solely focus on projects by foreign entities which are susceptible to foreign factors and dictation.

Remember kids, economy is X + C + I + G - M.

X for exports, C for domestic consumption, I for investment, G for government expenditure - M for imports. CPEC could end up being an import heavy project and Pakistani's would end up crying themselves to sleep every night.

Any tom dick and harry can make the recommendations this man has made. I don't know what is so special about him that he's some 'special resource lost'.

Character defamation? Man who thinks that Jibran Nasir is the bravest and the MOST COMPETENT Pakistani political leader is an idiot!! If that's his standard of analysis (surely he would have studied Political Risk to assess better), then it is a good thing he's no longer part of the economic council.

Remember your Earth is Flat thread?

What is your point?

I am not appointed to some economic council or space programme for that matter.

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

Now coming back to merits I can name 100 people more qualified than Atif Mian for this job.
.

No one in top 25 economist.

 

[Verve]

https://twitter.com/x/status/962732037097639938

Right ... Fantastic decision to retract his appointment, however it has happened.

 

[Kabira]

Sir i am shia and i dnt want to derail this thread

Mullahs consider you kafirs but they don't have balls to say it openly and neither state will act against shias.

 

[BHarwana]

A man who is bashing China's funding for CPEC can be fine in your views but he is not fine in my views. So now it is a matter of opinion on merits. Let's leave the minority issue and discuss his views on CPEC.

I don't want my country run by another economist who will get asylum in England.

 

[Verve]

Plus a retweet on Malala ...

A man who is bashing China's funding for CPEC can be fine in your views but he is not fine in my views. So now it is a matter of opinion on merits. Let's leave the minority issue and discuss his views on CPEC.

I don't want my country run by another economist who will get asylum in England.

View attachment 497238

Like the Indians here on PDF, this guy has made very similar 'assumptions' and some complete lies.

$30bn CPEC loan in one tweet, $50bn CPEC liabilities in this paper.

 

[Kakaspai]

A man who is bashing China's funding for CPEC can be fine in your views but he is not fine in my views. So now it is a matter of opinion on merits. Let's leave the minority issue and discuss his views on CPEC.

I don't want my country run by another economist who will get asylum in England.

View attachment 497238

There is nothing wrong in it.Asad umer says the same an independent financial analysis.

 

[Verve]

https://twitter.com/x/status/941923528663760896

The line was first breached by Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto in 1974 who, flanked by every political party and religious scholar, set out to determine who was a true Muslim and who wasn’t. General Zia took this initiative to the next level by inventing his own “divine laws” that prescribed precise penalties for a wide range of “blasphemous” acts.

So he's equating the APS massacre to the Qadyanis being declared non-muslims.

https://twitter.com/x/status/937038970923319296

The guy who has so many issues with Pakistan should have ABSOLUTELY nothing to do with the economic affairs of the country.

 

[Kakaspai]

Its strange , beside mullah party, PMLn and ANP raised objection on his appointment.

"UNITED OPPOSITION"

 

[Malik Usman]

Before to jump on any conclusion someone must know why there is hate and pressure about Ahmdis in Pakistan..

According to Muslim Faith if you Don't accept Holy Prophet Muhammad (Peach Be Upon Him) as a Last and Final Messenger of Allah. You are not a Muslim. And Ahmedis don't accept Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as Last Prophet. That's why according to Pakistani Constitution they are declared Non-Muslims and Minority In Pakistan.
But Ahmedis Don't consider them as Monitory they call themselves Muslims....That is the main dispute........
Thing is if they don't want to consider themselves Minority and want to call themselves Muslims they need to Accept the Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH as last and Final Prophet (Messenger) of Allah as Islamic Faith.......Until they don't do they have no right to get any position in Pakistani Govt. (Its Islamic Republic of Pakistan)

 

[BHarwana]

There is nothing wrong in it.Asad umer says the same an independent financial analysis.

I know and the words were given to Assad Omer from this dude he was taking them in the direction he wanted. Tell me next when Assad Omer says this now.

 

[Mrc]

He can start by accepting constitution of Pakistan