Flood aid for sale

[Metal 0-1]

This may not be true but what true is aid trucks were looted on gunpoint by dacoits in Sindh.

 

[PakSarZameen47]

 

[Mirzali Khan]

This image is viral on twitter, with the claim that UK relief material is being sold in Sindh. A PMLN account has claimed that this image is not from Pakistan & was first uploaded from India in 2014. Let's look into these two controversial claims & try to find the truth:——

As expected, Geo copied this thread verbatim and ran a package about it, implying that photo was taken in India. Imagine Pakistan's biggest media house has no in-house team to verify open source data.

You can see Shehbaz Banaspati Ghee on the shelf in the shop. Shehbaz Ghee is a Pakistani brand. To claim that this image is from India is false - unless its manufacturers have been exporting it to India, & that too with Urdu branding...

PMLN account says "this picture was taken in 2014 from SONY ILCE-6000 in India." When you upload a photo on Twitter, twitter makes EXIF data unavailable for the those viewing it. Hence, this claim is false.

This image was first uploaded on the internet by this user on Facebook. He is from Khairpur, Sindh. He claims to have captured this photo by himself and has provided address as well. Now it is the job of any journalist to contact him and verify this claim.

NDMA claims that news about UKaid relief item being sold is not true and that UKaid hasn't sent any flour bags.

While we don't know if this image is from recent floods, but what we know for sure is that this is from Pakistan. This picture, as claimed by Wahid Zia and Geo News, is from Pakistan and is not from India.

A facebook user is owning the picture. All it takes for a channel is to send a reporter to this address to verify his claim. Instead, Geo News decided to go on air with a random thread and amplified the disinformation.

Final word: This photo is from Pakistan. However, claim that this photo is from recent floods is not verifyable, so far. I like when people use data to debunk disinformation, but what to do when people pretend to use data to spread further disinformation? this is tragic.

Thread

https://twitter.com/x/status/1569042186695737344

@Maula Jatt @PakSarZameen47 @Menace2Society @Pakstallion @Vapnope @Bleek @Areesh @DESERT FIGHTER @Desert Fox 1@N.Siddiqui @Norwegian @TNT @Imad.Khan @Dalit @ziaulislam @EternalMortal @lastofthepatriots @WarKa DaNG @Warking @Talwar e Pakistan @WinterFangs @kingQamaR @Menace2Society @Indus Pakistan @Ghazwa-e-Hind @Norwegian @PakFactor @akramishaqkhan @Faqirze @pakpride00090 @MultaniGuy @Abid123 @Goritoes @SecularNationalist @PakistaniandProud @PAKISTANFOREVER @Dual Wielder

 

[Maula Jatt]

This image is viral on twitter, with the claim that UK relief material is being sold in Sindh. A PMLN account has claimed that this image is not from Pakistan & was first uploaded from India in 2014. Let's look into these two controversial claims & try to find the truth:——

View attachment 878860

View attachment 878861

View attachment 878862

View attachment 878863

As expected, Geo copied this thread verbatim and ran a package about it, implying that photo was taken in India. Imagine Pakistan's biggest media house has no in-house team to verify open source data.

View attachment 878864View attachment 878865

You can see Shehbaz Banaspati Ghee on the shelf in the shop. Shehbaz Ghee is a Pakistani brand. To claim that this image is from India is false - unless its manufacturers have been exporting it to India, & that too with Urdu branding...

View attachment 878866View attachment 878867View attachment 878868

PMLN account says "this picture was taken in 2014 from SONY ILCE-6000 in India." When you upload a photo on Twitter, twitter makes EXIF data unavailable for the those viewing it. Hence, this claim is false.

View attachment 878869 View attachment 878871

This image was first uploaded on the internet by this user on Facebook. He is from Khairpur, Sindh. He claims to have captured this photo by himself and has provided address as well. Now it is the job of any journalist to contact him and verify this claim.

View attachment 878872View attachment 878873

NDMA claims that news about UKaid relief item being sold is not true and that UKaid hasn't sent any flour bags.

View attachment 878874

While we don't know if this image is from recent floods, but what we know for sure is that this is from Pakistan. This picture, as claimed by Wahid Zia and Geo News, is from Pakistan and is not from India.

A facebook user is owning the picture. All it takes for a channel is to send a reporter to this address to verify his claim. Instead, Geo News decided to go on air with a random thread and amplified the disinformation.


View attachment 878875View attachment 878876

Final word: This photo is from Pakistan. However, claim that this photo is from recent floods is not verifyable, so far. I like when people use data to debunk disinformation, but what to do when people pretend to use data to spread further disinformation? this is tragic.

@Maula Jatt @PakSarZameen47 @Menace2Society @Pakstallion @Vapnope @Bleek @Areesh @DESERT FIGHTER @Desert Fox 1@N.Siddiqui @Norwegian @TNT @Imad.Khan @Dalit @ziaulislam @EternalMortal @lastofthepatriots @WarKa DaNG @Warking @Talwar e Pakistan @WinterFangs @kingQamaR @Menace2Society @Indus Pakistan @Ghazwa-e-Hind @Norwegian @PakFactor @akramishaqkhan @Faqirze @pakpride00090 @MultaniGuy @Abid123 @Goritoes @SecularNationalist @PakistaniandProud @PAKISTANFOREVER @Dual Wielder

yep

This image is viral on twitter, with the claim that UK relief material is being sold in Sindh. A PMLN account has claimed that this image is not from Pakistan & was first uploaded from India in 2014. Let's look into these two controversial claims & try to find the truth:——

View attachment 878860

View attachment 878861

View attachment 878862

View attachment 878863

As expected, Geo copied this thread verbatim and ran a package about it, implying that photo was taken in India. Imagine Pakistan's biggest media house has no in-house team to verify open source data.

View attachment 878864View attachment 878865

You can see Shehbaz Banaspati Ghee on the shelf in the shop. Shehbaz Ghee is a Pakistani brand. To claim that this image is from India is false - unless its manufacturers have been exporting it to India, & that too with Urdu branding...

View attachment 878866View attachment 878867View attachment 878868

PMLN account says "this picture was taken in 2014 from SONY ILCE-6000 in India." When you upload a photo on Twitter, twitter makes EXIF data unavailable for the those viewing it. Hence, this claim is false.

View attachment 878869 View attachment 878871

This image was first uploaded on the internet by this user on Facebook. He is from Khairpur, Sindh. He claims to have captured this photo by himself and has provided address as well. Now it is the job of any journalist to contact him and verify this claim.

View attachment 878872View attachment 878873

NDMA claims that news about UKaid relief item being sold is not true and that UKaid hasn't sent any flour bags.

View attachment 878874

While we don't know if this image is from recent floods, but what we know for sure is that this is from Pakistan. This picture, as claimed by Wahid Zia and Geo News, is from Pakistan and is not from India.

A facebook user is owning the picture. All it takes for a channel is to send a reporter to this address to verify his claim. Instead, Geo News decided to go on air with a random thread and amplified the disinformation.


View attachment 878875View attachment 878876

Final word: This photo is from Pakistan. However, claim that this photo is from recent floods is not verifyable, so far. I like when people use data to debunk disinformation, but what to do when people pretend to use data to spread further disinformation? this is tragic.

Thread

https://twitter.com/x/status/1569042186695737344

@Maula Jatt @PakSarZameen47 @Menace2Society @Pakstallion @Vapnope @Bleek @Areesh @DESERT FIGHTER @Desert Fox 1@N.Siddiqui @Norwegian @TNT @Imad.Khan @Dalit @ziaulislam @EternalMortal @lastofthepatriots @WarKa DaNG @Warking @Talwar e Pakistan @WinterFangs @kingQamaR @Menace2Society @Indus Pakistan @Ghazwa-e-Hind @Norwegian @PakFactor @akramishaqkhan @Faqirze @pakpride00090 @MultaniGuy @Abid123 @Goritoes @SecularNationalist @PakistaniandProud @PAKISTANFOREVER @Dual Wielder

this was debunked as fake afaik

 

[Mirzali Khan]

this was debunked as fake afaik

Nope, the image is from Pakistan.

The thread proves its from Pakistan.

However, we don't know if its from flood aid or somewhere else.

 

[SecularNationalist]

It's for sale despite the fact it's written on a bag "not for sale"
Welcome to the land of zardari.