What's new

Farakka Day today

What does a document have to do with the results?

That is a treaty signed between two sovereign countries, any violation of which is punishable in International Court of Justice. Although Bangladesh, just as our western neighbour, never felt the need to seek UN's help.
 
.
The farmer has been fed with propaganda, it has nothing to do with Farakka. Most water is used upstream of the river, also Bangladesh has pretty poor water management.

My granny used to live back there so I visit those places once in a while. One can literraly cross the river walking in dry seasons when the oldies say they used to watch launch sail past the river. According to the treaty the authorities are supposed to release 50k+- cusecs but there are years when it goes as low as 30k cusecs.

Anyways you are an avid port follwer;) so its futile.
 
.
The farmer has been fed with propaganda, it has nothing to do with Farakka. Most water is used upstream of the river, also Bangladesh has pretty poor water management.

mmm...I am not surprised. There are often water shortages in many parts of Old Town Dhaka.

Hell, the electricity supply in Bangladeshi villages is so little that people can't get enough energy to recharge their cell-phones! Yes, it is that bad in villages.

:coffee:
 
.
My granny used to live back there so I visit those place once in a while. One can literraly cross the river walking in dry seasons when the oldies say they used to watch launch sail past the river. According to the treaty the authorities are supposed to release 50k+- cusecs but there are years when it goes as low as 30k cusecs.

Anyways you are an avid port follwer;) so its futile.

50k cusec only for rainy season, in may it's around 30k for both the countries.

rivers in bengal often change course or dry up, it's not exclusive for bd.
 
.
mmm...I am not surprised. There are often water shortages in many parts of Old Town Dhaka.

Hell, the electricity supply in Bangladeshi villages is so little that people can't get enough energy to recharge their cell-phones! Yes, it is that bad in villages.

:coffee:

You've forgot 'bout solar power and yes its that common nowadays in villages.
About old town, well no comments as its friggin old town!
 
.
You've forgot 'bout solar power and yes its that common nowadays in villages.
About old town, well no comments as its friggin old town!

Oh come on! Its Old Town. How can we ignore our good Old Town in Dhaka and the well-being of its inhabitants ;)

Well, solar panels cost a lot of money in Bangladesh. Not all villages have them. And usually, they need NGOs to help them out.

What's more, there is a serious energy issue in the country. Getting energy to a population of 160 million in such a small country is no easy task. I have come to think that we need nuclear reactors for sure.

About the Farakka dam issue, well I wish there was real-time data for me to actually see. I never heard our government say anything about the issue. Correct me if I am wrong though. I am not very familiar with the subject.
 
.
Oh come on! Its Old Town. How can we ignore our good Old Town in Dhaka and the well-being of its inhabitants ;)

Well, solar panels cost a lot of money in Bangladesh. Not all villages have them. And usually, they need NGOs to help them out.

What's more, there is a serious energy issue in the country. Getting energy to a population of 160 million in such a small country is no easy task. I have come to think that we need nuclear reactors for sure.

About the Farakka dam issue, well I wish there was real-time data for me to actually see. I never heard our government say anything about the issue. Correct me if I am wrong though. I am not very familiar with the subject.

Even I dont know much about the issue. I read only some rants from bd side and some people from Indian side doing same or giving some data about why those fears are wrong. I am not sure who is right.

But surely BD govt can take India to international forums if it has a strong case. If not AL govt, surely BNP govt could have taken.
Why are they silent?

Happy farakka day!!!
 
. .
Yet gaddar Awami government allowing Bharti to use our land as corridor. If Bharti gets the corridor then it will save in Billions. I believe if strong Bangladesh government comes in office then they can negotiate with Bharti for our share of water.

Bharti wants to use our land to transport goods then it must pass our water otherwise no corridor.
 
.
Pakistan wastes a lot of its own water, and is blaming India for its failure to dam and control its share of water.

About Farakka what do the Bangladeshis expect from India? To blow up the dam?

It is Pakistan's privilege to decide whether to waste its water or not. But, India has no right to put obstacles to the naturally flowing water. Both BD and Pakistan are suffering from India's self-centered attitude towards its neighbours.
 
.
That is a treaty signed between two sovereign countries, any violation of which is punishable in International Court of Justice. Although Bangladesh, just as our western neighbour, never felt the need to seek UN's help.

Yes, it is a treaty forced-fed through our throat by a bullying India. Either accept it or we are going to withdraw all water-this is what India did. Now, similarly we will also give you transit in exchange in a befitting manner. No to Farakka and no to transit.
 
. .
nations should be willing to trade water. every country builds dams.

Farakka is not for irrigation, it is meant for easy navigabality of ships in Haldia. But, it is death penalty for Bangledesh. Demolish the UNNECESSARY Farakka and get a suitable water transit deal.
 
.
Bangladesh has suffered a lot due to floods in the past. The dams built by india is preventing losses to bangladesh from floods in terms of both life and property. Follow the link to know the truth:

Floods in Bangladesh - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

causes_of_flooding_in_bangladesh.jpg


Bangladesh is one of the world most densely populated country and one of the most susceptible countries to flood disasters. It also has one of the three most powerful rivers passing though it Ganges, Meghna and Brahmaputra. About one half of the land area in Bangladesh is at an elevation of less than 8 meters above sea level. Up to 30% of the country has been covered with flood waters. In 1991 more 200,000 deaths resulted from flooding and associated tropical cyclones.

gr2007112100115.gif


There are many physical and human causes that allowed the floods to be worse; such as:

The Physical Causes of the Floods:

->Most of the country consists of a huge flood plain and delta.
->Snowmelt from the Himalayas takes place in late spring & summer.
->70% of the total area is less than 1 meter above sea level.
->10% of the land area is made up of Lakes and Rivers.
->Bangladesh experiences heavy monsoon rains, especially over the highlands.
->Tropical storms bring heavy rains and coastal flooding.
->The main cause was the above average & long period of heavy rain which caused all 3 rivers to have their peak flow at the same time.
->In the spring, melting snow from the Himalayas further increases the flood risks as ******** of melt water enter the rivers at their source.

The Human Causes of the Floods:

->Deforestation in Nepal and the Himalayas increases run off and add to deposition and flooding downstream.
->Urbanization of the flood plain has increased magnitude & frequency of floods.
->Global warming is blamed for sea level rise, increased snow melt & increased rainfall in the region.
->Poorly maintained embankments (levees) leak & collapse in times of high discharge.
->Increasing population pressure in Bangladesh itself has resulted in the sinking of many new wells resulting in the lowering of the water table and the subsequent subsidence of land making it even more prone to flooding.

Clearly none of the point above points towards the dams built by india.

BNP's rally against dams built by india is just a politically motivated stunt and nothing else. It is just out of sheer hatered against india. BNP has nothing to contribute to bangladesh's development.

Agreed dams built by india might cause some environment related issues such as increase in the problem of sedimentation in Bangladesh. But that's it. It could have been just one of the reason out of loads of reasons mentioned above and most probably the least important. If india haden't built those dams more than half of bangladesh would have been washed away by floods every year and bangladesh had to survive only on aid, just like pakistan. Their would have been only negative rate of growth.

What say you??

Should india release all the water of river ganga??

Farakka is about water sharing in dry season. The dam stays open in monsoon, the locks go in in dry season. Flood has little to do with damn dam.
 
.
It is Pakistan's privilege to decide whether to waste its water or not. But, India has no right to put obstacles to the naturally flowing water. Both BD and Pakistan are suffering from India's self-centered attitude towards its neighbours.

You need to look into the Indus water treaty, and the claims and counter claims made by India and Pakistan. Pakistan was meant to come up with its arguments in the International Court of Arbitration(UN) by April 15th, 2011, but Pakistan didn't submit any arguments, makes you wonder if they have any arguments at all. This water stealing is nothing by propaganda. But then again, you can only see Pakistan's POV because deep down you are a Pakistani too. Now go worry about the mega dams that China is going to build on Jamuna. :wave:
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom