What's new

Eating at public place in Ramazan Police beat up 2 persons

Status
Not open for further replies.

karan.1970

BANNED
Joined
Jan 3, 2010
Messages
14,781
Reaction score
-20
Country
India
Location
India
Eating at public place in Ramazan Police beat up 2 persons | DAWN.COM

ISLAMABAD, July 28: The capital police beat up two persons at Daman-i-Koh for having ‘soft drinks’ during the time of fasting.

The incident was reported to Inspector General of Police (IGP) who has assured to take action against the officials, Dawn has learnt.

The victim Anwar Abbas, while talking to Dawn said that on Friday at around 2pm he went to Daman-i-Koh along with his friend Malik Saeed and was having soft drink in his car.

Mr Abbas said: “I was not fasting and knowing that it would be ethically incorrect to have drink in front of people so I chose a place where no one was present.

“In the meantime, a police constable came and said taking drinks during fasting is a violation of Ramazan Act and a serious crime,” he said adding he told him (constable) that he was not fasting and taking drinks at an isolated place where no one was present. “I also told him that it was not their job to stop anyone from eating during the time of fasting but constable insisted that he has to implement the teachings of Islam,” he said. [Note: This guy seems to have the same mind as some of our Pakistani members here :)

“The constable called two other police officials and they took us to the nearby police post,” he said adding “at the check post heated arguments ensued and they removed their belts and started beating us.”

After a while, when the policemen felt that the situation was getting out of control, they let them go.

The victims said they reported the matter to the Kohsar police SHO and then to the capital IG Bani Amin Khan who assured them that action would be taken against the police officials.

On the other hand, the police officials have started offering apologies and their seniors are also approaching us to withdraw the complaint against the officials, he said.

A police officer requesting anonymity said that the act of police officials was against the law and ethics. “We condemn when Taliban do the same act but now police are doing it in federal capital which shows the presence of hardliners in the law enforcement agencies,” he said.


Human Rights Activist, Tahira Abdullah condemned the police brutality and said Ziaul Haq’s regime first disallowed eating at public places in daytime during Ramazan.

“We have to involve 180 million people and build a consensus for a Pakistan the Quaid-i-Azam dreamt,” she said.

Former General Secretary of Islamabad Distract Bar Association, Riasat Ali Azad said that there was no provision in Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) that prohibited eating at public places.

“It is a religious and moral obligation of a citizen to avoid eating but police cannot restrict them by force. Just like it is our duty to say prayers five times a day but police cannot force any person to go in the mosque,” he said.

Inspector General of Police Bani Amin Khan said in response to the complaint he had ordered inquiry into the incident. “On Saturday I have been informed by the police officers that both complainants are ready to have a patch up. If complainants
withdraw their application, case will be closed,” he said.
 
. . .
[

A police officer requesting anonymity said that the act of police officials was against the law and ethics. “We condemn when Taliban do the same act but now police are doing it in federal capital which shows the presence of hardliners in the law enforcement agencies,” he said.
A gradual Talibanisation of law enforcement agencies in Pakistan is underway.
US fears:
 
. .
[video]http://www.********.com/view?i=5ed_1325869992&p=1[/video]

Frustrations take over the best of us at times. The cases were seen as wrong and corrected.
 
. . .
OOh man look at these Indian Monkeys even if some one is beaten up by police is a news for them..

You guys born with this trolling ? I m damn Sure u also troll with Yr M8888R ***** when she giving birth to you guys !

Control your language. You would get hurt if the same lines are used against u. It is the very same for every individual. What has been said cannot be taken back. So, Choose your words.
 
.
........................................................................................................
 
.
But good they got beaten on teasing others who were fasting..

In a place where no one was present? That's very ingenious.

By the way, wasn't fasting about exercising self-restraint, controlling your anger, and being nonviolent and all? Seems the abuser failed miserably by not grasping the essence of his faith.

The question how faithfully a believer should implement his religious duties should be a matter between each believer and God. Just displaying a religious practice out of coercion is meaningless.
A society where such dangerous thoughts take root will be eventually turned in a place of death and destruction, where deemed souls and persons regarded as heretical will become legitimate targets of a jihad waged by radical Islamists.

No sane person should want or desire that.
 
.
In a place where no one was present? That's very ingenious.

By the way, wasn't fasting about exercising self-restraint, controlling your anger, and being nonviolent and all? Seems the abuser failed miserably by not grasping the essence of his faith.

The question how faithfully a believer should implement his religious duties should be a matter between a each believer and God. Just displaying a religious practice out of coercion is meaningless.
A society where such dangerous thoughts take root will be eventually turned in a place of death and destruction, where deemed souls and persons regarded as heretical will become legitimate targets of a jihad waged by radical Islamists.

No sane person should want or desire that.

Unfortunately there are no muslims the world over, only muslim rituals.
 
.
You guys are trying to make big wind out of any issue, it was clear they were not beaten on having a cold drink rather on the argument that happened at the police chowki. Quit trolling and I will send a request to correct the title of the thread.
 
.
Having spent time in the middle east I've wondered too, how does someone else eating violate your right to fast, or worse, weaken your faith in your religious practices?

When does self restraint involve forcing others? Does anyone see the paradox? Or am I opening the pandoras box?
 
.
good.... The idiots got what they deserved...
The police didnt force them to keep fast..that would have been wrong..
But good they got beaten on teasing others who were fasting..

Boo Hoo...if you wanna fast...it's not on others to conform for you. Do you think everyone in the UK is gonna go hungry for you?
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom