Dwarka : Myth or reality?

[Rafi]

Im a baluch....... we were a part of IVC ......yet we r middle eastern n share nothing with hinduism............. civilisation isnt based on religion........ IVC existed before hinduism.

Exactly right PN brother.

 

[Peshwa]

Im a baluch....... we were a part of IVC ......yet we r middle eastern n share nothing with hinduism............. civilisation isnt based on religion........ IVC existed before hinduism.

Thats a stupid comment....

Civilization represents culture and traditions that are driven by religion....

Of course the IVC natives were Hindus (proven without doubt and enough sources have been provided)...so obviously their culture was similar to modern day Hindus...majority of who live in India...
Modern day Pakistanis have very little in common with the folks of IVC....whether it be from a culture or religious standpoint...PERIOD!

 

[Fireurimagination]

Im a baluch....... we were a part of IVC ......yet we r middle eastern n share nothing with hinduism............. civilisation isnt based on religion........ IVC existed before hinduism.

So what was the religion practiced in IVC? So how come Pakistan was ruled by Hindu kings Mauryas/Kaushans etc after the IVC period, that means Hindu kings attacked and conquered present day Pakistan? So what will happen to Muslims defeated and ruled India theory

 

[Rafi]

Rafi, its going to be 3 hour's now.. I'm still waiting for your credible link which says about Pakistan existence before 1947.

History of Ancient Pakistan

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.
And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

 

[Dalai Lama]

Proves that they were not Hindu's and we are Muslims now, the IVC was before the Holy Prophet had even born.

So... what were you before?

 

[Major Ram]

Wikipedia is heaven for you Bharits.

Your fellow came up with some animal from Wikipedia to prove that Pakistan was existed for thousand years.. And all he has is that animal..lol

 

[Peshwa]

No indian's unless visitors, diplomats, spies and prisoners.

Budd...Your ancestors were Hindu too....dont be so cross though....Im sure the invaders erased any memory of that for your kind...

 

[Masterchief]

Wikipedia is heaven for you Bharits.

its anyday better than your rants brother.

 

[Rafi]

Thats a stupid comment....

Civilization represents culture and traditions that are driven by religion....

Of course the IVC natives were Hindus (proven without doubt and enough sources have been provided)...so obviously their culture was similar to modern day Hindus...majority of who live in India...
Modern day Pakistanis have very little in common with the folks of IVC....whether it be from a culture or religious standpoint...PERIOD!

Only according to indian's, how could they be Hindu's when they buried their dead, ate beef and had no idol's.

 

[Fireurimagination]

Rafi, its going to be 3 hour's now.. I'm still waiting for your credible link which says about Pakistan existence before 1947.

Dude don't hold your breath hehehehe

 

[Galaxy]

Im a baluch....... we were a part of IVC ......yet we r middle eastern n share nothing with hinduism............. civilisation isnt based on religion........ IVC existed before hinduism.

Common Man not again, IVC was Hindu Civilisation.

BBC - Religions - Hinduism: History of Hinduism

Hinduism (religion) :: Religion in the Indus valley civilization -- Britannica Online Encyclopedia

Our Vedic Books are written some 2,500 years back. Islam didn't even existed at that time.

 

[Rafi]

Your fellow came up with some animal from Wikipedia to prove that Pakistan was existed for thousand years.. And all he has is that animal..lol

That animal is in all the science books on paleontology look it up sonny

---------- Post added at 10:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:37 PM ----------

Common Man not again, IVC was Hindu Civilisation.

BBC - Religions - Hinduism: History of Hinduism

Hinduism (religion) :: Religion in the Indus valley civilization -- Britannica Online Encyclopedia

Our Vedic Books are written some 2,500 years back. Islam didn't even existed at that time.

how could they be Hindu's when they buried their dead, ate beef and had no idol's.

 

[Dalai Lama]

Budd...Your ancestors were Hindu too....dont be so cross though....Im sure the invaders erased any memory of that for your kind...

Pakistani's are living proof that the invaders were damn good at what they did.

 

[Fireurimagination]

So... what were you before?

Don't ask uncomfortable questions mate

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Thats a stupid comment....

Civilization represents culture and traditions that are driven by religion....

Of course the IVC natives were Hindus (proven without doubt and enough sources have been provided)...so obviously their culture was similar to modern day Hindus...majority of who live in India...
Modern day Pakistanis have very little in common with the folks of IVC....whether it be from a culture or religious standpoint...PERIOD!

IVC ppl worship a female goddess! or the mother godess.

2) (I think ur a south indian) nd u have no links with the ppl of IVC! While the modern day Pakistanis r the descendants of the IVC people......... Tell me who has a right to claim their fathers identity? a guy in trivandam or a Pakistani?