What's new

does israel have the right to exist?

should israel have been created?


  • Total voters
    99
you are now confusing the topic.

Bottom line

There are millions of Arab citizens of Israel.

Now I understand why you are confused I am talking about that Jews are allowed to settle in Israel but not Palestinians who were there before. Sorry my mistake.
 
. .
@FaujHistorian
forget about everything….
so why should have israel been created??? whats your reasoning for your vote?

Same reason I had paratha for Sehri.

i wanted to, I worked for it, i got it.

you got problems?

Everyone got problems.

But my paratha is mine to eat.

Go worry about your own paratha.


Hope this light hearted view helps you calm down a bit.

Now I understand why you are confused I am talking about that Jews are allowed to settle in Israel but not Palestinians who were there before. Sorry my mistake.

don't confuse yourself
and don't try to confuse others.

it will help you now
It will help you forever.
 
.
which fights?
do you know the jewish population in palestine after ww1?


of course he not committing a crime by simply migrating… no body said migrating is a crime.


i agree…


see this is the problem…. europe had no right decide what should be done to that land..
the un is irrelevant in this conflict because israel doesn't follow anything the un says
why are there over 1 million palestinian refugees? answer this question by biased friend.

you made a very weak case…. never mind making a country even making Facebook page isn't enough for the reasons you stated.


what is a jew?
just answer that question… i don't need to argue with you because facts will kill your argument..

I think it is well established that there were armed conflicts between Jews and Arabs during the British Mandate.
If you are not aware, then you need basic history lessons.

Europe did not decide what to do with the land.
It was a UN majority vote in the General Assembly, where all the countries are represented.
This gave the Jews a legal position to declare an independent state within the territory suggested by the UN.

Few states has a better legal position, and your comment that UN is irrelevant is
your weakest argument.
Most states are created by mafia-like organisations which have defined their borders
after fights with other mafia-like organisations.
Over time many of those organisations have been overthrown by revolutions or constitutional reforms.

The reason there are refugees, is that they fled their homes, and the reason has been debated.
Arab armies told them to get out of the way, to allow the Armies attack w/o risk of friendly casualties.
Scared away by risk of atrocities, as those of Irgun/Stern.
There has not been too many of them in Israel after the war of 1948 ended.

Reason they are still refugees, is the policy of surrounding Arab countries to not assimilate them.
An equal number of jew refugees went from Arab countries to Israel, and they are no longer refugees.
Legally, if you move out of occupied territories, you have the right to move back.
If you move out before the territory is occupied there is no such right.
That may be a loophole in International Law.

How many refugees remain in Pakistan/India after the partition.
10 times the number of refugees, but how many consider themselves to be refugees right now.
 
.
Same reason I had paratha for Sehri.

i wanted to, I worked for it, i got it.

you got problems?

Everyone got problems.

But my paratha is mine to eat.

Go worry about your own paratha.


Hope this light hearted view helps you calm down a bit.
this lighted heart view might help me if i was looking for a job or looking to get motivated to find or job but it doesn't help me understand why you made your vote??

the poll question was should israel have been created?
you answered yes
so I'm asking you the reasoning behind your vote??
 
.
so what do you suggest we do?
shall we recognize israel?

@FaujHistorian
why should israel have been created? i see that you voted yes.. any specific reasoning??
we must have diplomatic relations and active diplomacy with them so we will be able to save palastinen
so what do you suggest we do?
shall we recognize israel?

@FaujHistorian
why should israel have been created? i see that you voted yes.. any specific reasoning??

we must have diplomatic relations and active diplomacy with them so we will be able to save Palestinians lives and we can support them . remember if we save 1 life its like save humanity .
 
.
we must have diplomatic relations and active diplomacy with them so we will be able to save palastinen


we must have diplomatic relations and active diplomacy with them so we will be able to save Palestinians lives and we can support them . remember if we save 1 life its like save humanity .
so how we will we save palestinians by having diplomatic relations with israel???
today we are going to get down to the bottom of @Imran Khan logic unless you run away or something…
 
. .
this lighted heart view might help me if i was looking for a job or looking to get motivated to find or job but it doesn't help me understand why you made your vote??
?

Make sure you keep your job in America

With your views, you may have trouble soon.
 
.
so how we will we save palestinians by having diplomatic relations with israel???
today we are going to get down to the bottom of @Imran Khan logic unless you run away or something…

diplomacy active diplomacy just look how india recovered nurses from ISIS . we can pressure ask ceasefire for deliver aid . we have many options then to talk with israel . i blive if saudi - pakistan - uae - iran recognize Israel they can pressurize Israel very well all together then sitting and condemning on tv .
 
. .
I guess jews deserved a country of their own after WW2.. if not in palestine then somewhere else.
what abut in bihar - utter pardesh ? this is not the logic man . after giving thousands lives then why not Kashmirs - Palestinians should have country bro ?
 
.
diplomacy active diplomacy just look how india recovered nurses from ISIS . we can pressure ask ceasefire for deliver aid . we have many options then to talk with israel . i blive if saudi - pakistan - uae - iran recognize Israel they can pressurize Israel very well all together then sitting and condemning on tv .
wah kiya logic hai…
mere yaar koi kisi cheez ka to khuf kar assi batein karney sey pehley…

turkey eygpt both have relationships with israel… have they even saved one palestinian life? or have they ever stopped any israel attack?
having diplomacy will give what benefits to pakistan???

Make sure you keep your job in America

With your views, you may have trouble soon.
unforetunetly for you my friend in america everybody can have any view… thats why we have the 1st amendment.
nobody can deny me a job based on my views and race…
we have our own businesses in america my father is a job creator so for the time being allah blessed us very well.
 
.
wah kiya logic hai…
mere yaar koi kisi cheez ka to khuf kar assi batein karney sey pehley…

turkey eygpt both have relationships with israel… have they even saved one palestinian life? or have they ever stopped any israel attack?
having diplomacy will give what benefits to pakistan???


unforetunetly for you my friend in america everybody can have any view… thats why we have the 1st amendment.
nobody can deny me a job based on my views and race…
we have our own businesses in america my father is a job creator so for the time being allah blessed us very well.
meri jan they did not even try their best i still believe they can do much more but both are busy in internal politics .

pakistan can be benefited too bto jew lobby in congress can support us we have hand in indo- isr deals and have trade which must be benefited sir .
 
.
.

unforetunetly for you my friend in america everybody can have any view… thats why we have the 1st amendment.
nobody can deny me a job based on my views and race…
we have our own businesses in america my father is a job creator so for the time being allah blessed us very well.

just said. Watch out bro!
 
.
Back
Top Bottom