does israel have the right to exist?

[FaujHistorian]

miti he daal rhey hein janab un masoom innocent par jo isreali terrorism se shaheed ho chukey hain

dooor ki mitti sooghi jaati
daali nahi jaati

 

[qamar1990]

mitti pao sarkar

yes dirt is being poured on the innocents who died.

 

[FaujHistorian]

then perhaps you should see your way out of the condo… too much heat in pakistan so you must not be thinking right…

Actually it is really nice now.

Noon and afternoon is a beaaaach.

 

[gambit]

list countries that have been created for religion….
only 2 so far
israel and pakistan
israel has a population that is over 80 percent foreign
pakistan has a population that is 85 percent native and the other 15 percent come from neighboring land.

Religion is only one criteria. But you missed the point, as expected. When Israel was created, if one is a Jew, one can migrate to Israel. When Jordan was created, certain tribal affiliations and origins were taken into consideration, you can find the details easily enough.

 

[Leader]

jani if we recognized israel today we were better position to talk with them and may we can even give 1-2-3 day war relax to gaza on the name of talks . and ys we can send then aid to gaza also

lolz... talk with them? we are not even a direct party as a matter of fact. but its just to give a muslim stance on a ghus bethiya... Egypt, Turkey, Saudia, Iran can give a befitting response, but how exactly were we going to give which they havent?

 

[qamar1990]

jani if we recognized israel today we were better position to talk with them and may we can even give 1-2-3 day war relax to gaza on the name of talks . and ys we can send then aid to gaza also

meri jaan israel ko recognize kar na hi juram hai….
if you recognize them you legitimize their terror against the palestinians.

 

[gambit]

Looky here...This have been a religious conflict all along. You do not want Jews to have their own country in the region, just have the intellectual courage to say so.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

In this world, it's not about the right, but the power.

And Israel is backed up 100% by the sole superpower America.

 

[Imran Khan]

lolz... talk with them? we are not even a direct party as a matter of fact. but its just to give a muslim stance on a ghus bethiya... Egypt, Turkey, Saudia, Iran can give a befitting response, but how exactly were we going to give which they havent?

thats called diplomacy .

 

[A.P. Richelieu]

israel has the right to exist now obviously because its too damn late…


but should israel have been created to begin with??
do jews around the world have the right to migrate to israel at the expense palestinians being kicked out of their homes?

Without the fights starting after WW1, a one-state solution would have been feasible.
With the fights, the creation of Israel becomes a neccessity.

As there are no laws against mass migration there is no collective crime.
No jew immigrating to the Mandate (early period) is committing any crime by doing so.

Modern justice demands that immigrants get the same voting rights as native borns.

When Britain left the Mandate, there was no longer anyone with claim to the territory.
The world, in the form of UN decided that there should be two states.
The Arab countries disagreed, but did not make a convincing case and lost the election.

This gives Israel the right to exist.

BTW: I am only looking at the legal situation. There is no doubt that poor farmers
leasing land from rich landowners ended up in a bad situation, if evicted after the land
they leased got sold of to jews.

 

[qamar1990]

Religion is only one criteria. But you missed the point, as expected. When Israel was created, if one is a Jew, one can migrate to Israel. When Jordan was created, certain tribal affiliations and origins were taken into consideration, you can find the details easily enough.

what is a jew my friend? just answer that…
i think we need to go slowly with you because your judgement is clouded by your bias.

 

[Imran Khan]

meri jaan israel ko recognize kar na hi juram hai….
if you recognize them you legitimize their terror against the palestinians.

or recognize na ker ke hum ne kya ker liya ?

 

[gambit]

In this world, it's not about the right, but the power.

And Israel is backed up 100% by the sole superpower America.

And China can use her might to make things right for the Palestinians. China should start arming Hamas and Hezbollah, no ?

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

And China can use her might to make things right for the Palestinians. China should start arming Hamas and Hezbollah, no ?

None of our business.

 

[FaujHistorian]

yes dirt is being poured on the innocents who died.

are you doing that?