Did Pakistan have any historical religious personality on its land ?

[Spring Onion]

Pakistan is a Land, It dosent have a religion. Land is made by God and Religion is followed by Man. Just my thoughts.

The poster is asking if any prophet or companion of prophets or for that matter saints has ever landed on this land of Pakistan .

 

[Tea addict]

Its near the city of Gujrat

There was a documentary I was watching few days ago but I can't find it anymore.. They claim its Hazrat Qanbeet A.S grave who was supposedly the son of Prophet Adam although I have never heard of such personality in my life

But it is quite popular place (not in my city but nearby). I remember I went to that place after the Kargil war and people were claiming because of its close proximity to Indian border there was a lot of shelling and bombs thrown in that area and I could see some of the houses been destroyed and all and the people were claiming some of the bombs had fallen in that shrine but none of them exploded... They were all buried under the ground...

I am not sure what to make out of such stories but yeah there was certainly a lot of mortar weapons thrown in that area by Indian forces. You can google "barila sharif" to find out more

Sorry it was "tanot mata" not "karni mata"...fot confused as both has similar stories

 

[Hyde]

This is literally,word to word the same story i have heard about the temple of "karni mata" of Rajasthan..tha in 1965 lots of shells landed in the premises but not a single one exploded..the place where the temple stands now is famous because of pre battle prayers the armies of Rajasthan did before facing bin qasim in battle of Rajasthan..it is said that when the army of pratiharas (modern day jatts,gujjars and Rajputs) of Rajasthan were victorious they built a small temple there which was later built in modern form few hundred years ago.

i know when religious sentiments start flowing in blood, such stories come to rise in my opinion

The major difference between the shrine I was talking about and the temple you are talking about is that I have seen the shrine with my own eyes and is a recent story within the past 2 decades and its close proximity with Indian border it is fairly acceptable to believe that it may have been bombarded with mortar weapons and other artillary.

Peace

 

[313ghazi]

Guru Nanak was from near Lahore.

 

[I.R.A]

The concept is correct. Your interpretation is not.

Every people got their enlightenment through a Prophet or a Messenger.

Who came from among them. When they were most in need.

Some earlier. Some later.

Cheers, Doc

I had stopped taking part in religion related discussion but you are one person I can freely discuss anything .......... and you know my hidden motive is to convert you someday to being a Musla

Now being serious ............ taking your argument okay a Messenger was from amongst the people ........ do you not think it is logical that Muhammad (Peace be upon him) is the last messenger for all the times to come and for everyone....... considering today's environment and the easy connectivity between people with easy access to research and understanding of the concepts and beliefs?

And I have serious doubts over extraordinary long graves that exist in Pakistan ...... people may have myths and their own stories but I believe these graves have hidden wealth of Hindus who left it behind at time of partition (very disturbing times, wasn't safe for people migrating to both sides), they knew very well that no Muslim is going to dig up a grave ....... so they sort of thought we will come back someday and take it back..

 

[padamchen]

I had stopped taking part in religion related discussion but you are one person I can freely discuss anything .......... and you know my hidden motive is to convert you someday to being a Musla

Now being serious ............ taking your argument okay a Messenger was from amongst the people ........ do you not think it is logical that Muhammad (Peace be upon him) is the last messenger for all the times to come and for everyone....... considering today's environment and the easy connectivity between people with easy access to research and understanding of the concepts and beliefs?

And I have serious doubts over extraordinary long graves that exist in Pakistan ...... people may have myths and their own stories but I believe these graves have hidden wealth of Hindus who left it behind at time of partition (very disturbing times, wasn't safe for people migrating to both sides), they knew very well that no Muslim is going to dig up a grave ....... so they sort of thought we will come back someday and take it back..

I was just having coffee with another PDF senior.

And I discovered I'm equally hated by both Pakistanis and Indians.

I feel strangely like a warrior from the old days.

Cheers, Doc

 

[I.R.A]

I was just having coffee with another PDF senior.

And I discovered I'm equally hated by both Pakistanis and Indians.

I feel strangely like a warrior from the old days.

Cheers, Doc

Shuker karo they are not out to kill you ........ itnay saray janmo k badh itna to banta he hay yar

Khair don't take it to heart ......... if you are sure you are speaking the truth then who thinks what doesn't matter.

 

[padamchen]

Shuker karo they are not out to kill you ........ itnay saray janmo k badh itna to banta he hay yar

Khair don't take it to heart ......... if you are sure you are speaking the truth then who thinks what doesn't matter.

I give a fig man.

You come in alone.

You go out alone.

In the middle, a few good men (and women) is all you really need.

Cheers, Doc

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Time is the greatest test. Quran fulfills that test.

Its high time that Muslims or Humanity go back to the message of the Quran because that is the eternal truth and everlasting reality.

Rest are speculation, hearsay and concoction.

The Truth is Opposite.

 

[I.R.A]

I give a fig man.

You come in alone.

You go out alone.

In the middle, a few good men (and women) is all you really need.

Cheers, Doc

Wow kya gayan mara hy ...........

You come alone ......... you go alone ............. what about the twins/ triplets etc yar

 

[El Sidd]

The Truth is Opposite.

Ok

 

[padamchen]

Wow kya gayan mara hy ...........

You come alone ......... you go alone ............. what about the twins/ triplets etc yar

They (identical twins) are truly blessed and cursed.

Anyways I will reply to you on this. I've spoken about it before. When I used to be more a .... sanghi.

But on this I am the original Aryan. And my belief is as unshakeable as it is ancient.

Cheers, Doc

 

[I.R.A]

The Truth is Opposite.

Lucky you got away with an Ok only.

Kya chal ra hay ajj kal? Studies ya job?

 

[Solomon2]

Well one can entertain a thought without accepting it. Its quite fanatical thinking if you believe every philosophical debate should end by a concession from someone.

Not every such debate. However, a fanatic is someone who has intense uncritical devotion to his cause. Therefore a person who refuses empirical evidence to maintain his or her devotion is a fanatic.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Lucky you got away with an Ok only.

Kya chal ra hay ajj kal? Studies ya job?

Yeah, I did not expect that. Back to job. You?