Criticism on Pakistan's Nuclear Doctrine.

[DESERT FIGHTER]

These generals in neighborhood who are enjoying 5 star facilities and power at the cost of development of a nation, will they commit national suicide by using tactical nukes when they know that the retaliation will be in total terms....

The English word Bluff is evident if not stark

For your presentation this is how your enemy That is us India's understanding of the Nuclear Bluff

Guess what happens if it turns into a full blown nuclear war... You (india) is wiped of the face of the earth.. That's MAD & our "Sampsons option".. Kaboom... We cove your entire country aswell.. Not even your aboriginals on andamans will survive.

So we all die ..

 

[Ragnarok connection]

My friend just post one video of Indian nuclear test and then we can talk
India has no videos released out of shame as it was just a puny fizzle in the desert

Yes, it was as much as a fizzle as Pakistan's test.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Dont worry our very noble, respectful and democracy loving Generals are no saints and we know how to take "Good Care" of the our enemy and since when are we not aware of our neighbor haysiyat.... for ur info with 12000 nukes that included 50 plus ton TSar bomba's soviet empire collapsed and democracy prevailed......

on the issue : By the way the Global concern of an unstable country further increasing the risk of these horrible toys falling into hands of Jihahds is the only concern.......

Uncle Sam is more worried than us

Truth is you can criticise what ever doctorine...
But fact is these doctorines are not fixed..and war if God forbid if it ever happens, is not going to be fought on expectations but on surprises....

Miniature nukes are not only arming nasr.... but also an impressive array of land sea and air launched cruise missiles for deep strikes at long ranges....

Only logical criticism can be a that a general might take a risk and try to launch a pre emptive strike with stealth cruise missiles to devastate oponents nuclear arsenal before it can be launched....
Risk may pay off....
Or it may not...

Tactical nukes may result in more risk taking as you are only destroying nuclear basis but not the cities close to them;
Thus may be making a strike justified....

India-Pakistan Nuclear War Would Kill 2 Billion People, End Civilization: Report

Kaboom.

My friend just post one video of Indian nuclear test and then we can talk
India has no videos released out of shame as it was just a puny fizzle in the desert

Coz they were indeed shameful to how.. Producing very low yield .. Probably comparable to our tac nukes or even lower...

Yes, it was as much as a fizzle as Pakistan's test.

we smoked a whole mountain publically .. With the video aired by all global outlets... And your tests are still hidden .. With all international scientists/analyst believing they were low yield... Aka fizzle ..between 12-20 as opposed to indias claimed 50-60.. According to USA.

 

[shaheenmissile]

Yes, it was as much as a fizzle as Pakistan's test.

Come on... Even North Korea released this video... Shoopah Powah India ? No video

 

[Ragnarok connection]

we smoked a whole mountain publically .. With the video aired by all global outlets... And your tests are still hidden .. With all international scientists/analyst believing they were low yield... Aka fizzle ..between 12-20 as opposed to indias claimed 50-60.. According to USA.

Same 'fizzle' yield was obtained by Pakistan, so I don't understand why you get so obsessed over videos and "smoking mountains". I just enjoy reading this kind of stuff; egocentric views held here by some and expressed publicly by Pakistani politicians on Nuclear weapons is so entertaining. Bash India more, it will only turn out to be counterproductive.
Take care and Peace!

 

[shaheenmissile]

Same 'fizzle' yield was obtained by Pakistan, so I don't understand why you get so obsessed over videos and "smoking mountains". I just enjoy reading this kind of stuff; egocentric views held here by some and expressed publicly by Pakistani politicians on Nuclear weapons is so entertaining. Bash India more, it will only turn out to be counterproductive.
Take care and Peace!

This is fizzle yield. Problem is Indian chest thumping and Bravado which is based on nothing really.

 

[Ragnarok connection]

Come on... Even North Korea released this video... Shoopah Powah India ? No video

Our "Shoopah Powah" country does not have enough money for good quality video recorders, the quality of the recorder during Pokhran-2 was so bad, that it fell of its tripod and broke. Please, provide us some funds from your budget please.

This is fizzle yield. Problem is Indian chest thumping and Bravado which is based on nothing really.

Chest thumping? It appears to me, that you are the one chest thumping here and talking of videos and shaking dust and fire from within the mountain,....etc.

 

[posedion]

What makes them think South will be spared? As I see it, South is driving growth engine of India and will probably get more attention.

“Paranoia is just the bastard child of fear and good sense." (Charlie)



"You want to get it a puppy, too?"

Guess what happens if it turns into a full blown nuclear war... You (india) is wiped of the face of the earth.. That's MAD & our "Sampsons option".. Kaboom... We cove your entire country aswell.. Not even your aboriginals on andamans will survive.

So we all die ..

I am very interested in the kind of drugs available in ur place man u guys beat many mad people by mark

 

[tarrar]

Our Nuclear program is the fastest growing in the region & Pakistan should continue to master the technology. As far as the bitches of foreign countries are concerned they will speak the given script, since nothing is done against them, then Pakistan should not give a f**k about the barking bitches. Honestly speaking they should be hanged for committing treason but they are well protected by corrupt politicians.

 

[Sine Nomine]

Use it on Amerika may be the mad sheikh ladan had dreams like this and also that kid Kim jong bitch also has similar one

Yes that's why your Amreeka called our PM,please sit with us and we will provide you what you want,but please do'nt develop an ICBM.

According to this premise, if double the amount of dust and "Bigger the Bang", double is the power. So Pakistan's test must have been 60Kt, and the world was trying to downplay Pakistan's Nuclear Tech.
What is the harm in admitting that even with a foolproof Chinese bomb design, Pakistan did not have the proper manufacturing Tech and/or high purity weapons grade plutonium in 1998.

Pakistan got her A-bomb ready in in 1985,that's why brass track never made up to full war.

 

[FuturePAF]

AoA
Stability and ambiguity do not go together. Use justification of stability to increase conventional forces. Define nuclear threshold and be prepared to implement. If conventional strength is high enough agree to no first use. That would bring stability.
Regards

It is not in Pakistan's interest to define its threshold, if it doesn't have the economic means to match India conventionally
Even asymmetrically, Pakistan is barely holding its own.

Stability means Status Quo polticially on the surface, while you advance your interest knowing the adversary is advancing their own.

Under the seeming hair trigger nuclear capability of the generals, Pakistan's only hope for future stability is to advance its economic development without fear of being stifled by foreign powers or its own greedy elites; the dramatic population growth and limit time left to capitalize on its young labor force can only be placated for so long. In this way it can spend more on conventional military means and the rely less on threat of tactical weapons

 

[zebra7]

Our Nuclear program is the fastest growing in the region & Pakistan should continue to master the technology. As far as the bitches of foreign countries are concerned they will speak the given script, since nothing is done against them, then Pakistan should not give a f**k about the barking bitches. Honestly speaking they should be hanged for committing treason but they are well protected by corrupt politicians.

Who gave you this information. The US media report of Pakistan having 4th largest nuclear stockpile in the world or your own specullation, or some official statement of Pakistani Govt.

@DESERT FIGHTER how many nuclear weapon of who much TNT is required to wipe India from the world.

Elaborate it rather than Kaboom

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

“Paranoia is just the bastard child of fear and good sense." (Charlie)



"You want to get it a puppy, too?"


I am very interested in the kind of drugs available in ur place man u guys beat many mad people by mark

Why your desi thara or the cough syrup you are on.. Aren't they enough already?

 

[kṣamā]

My friend just post one video of Indian nuclear test and then we can talk
India has no videos released out of shame as it was just a puny fizzle in the desert

bcoz unlike you we do not bandish our nukes to blackmail the world. Neither we have them to intimidate others. They are just for deterence.
And for proof part, As someone truly said, there exist no multi media file of your birth, dose that mean you where not born?? To be honest you are not the only one. It was one of your brethren who asked for a video proof of Mangalyan in martian orbit .

 

[silent hawk]

It is not in Pakistan's interest to define its threshold, if it doesn't have the economic means to match India conventionally
Even asymmetrically, Pakistan is barely holding its own.

Stability means Status Quo polticially on the surface, while you advance your interest knowing the adversary is advancing their own.

Under the seeming hair trigger nuclear capability of the generals, Pakistan's only hope for future stability is to advance its economic development without fear of being stifled by foreign powers or its own greedy elites; the dramatic population growth and limit time left to capitalize on its young labor force can only be placated for so long. In this way it can spend more on conventional military means and the rely less on threat of tactical weapons

AoA
Interesting definition of stability. Almost makes Pakistan look like being stable. The economic issue is something on which there can be little difference of opinion. But Stability over all is dependent on security in all of its forms.
Regards