What's new

China ready to cede land for part of Arunachal Pradesh?

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
China ready to cede land for part of Arunachal Pradesh?
Saibal Dasgupta| TNN | Mar 3, 2017, 01.03 AM IST
HIGHLIGHTS
  • The suggestion of an exchange of land with Tawang being ceded by India came from Dai Bingguo
  • Dai Bingguo headed the special representative dialogue with India for over a decade until his retirement in 2013
  • Dai is still regarded close to Chinese rulers, and his voice is taken seriously in the diplomatic community
57438172.jpg
Soldier guarding the Indian post at Indo - China border area in Bumla, Arunachal Pradesh a 15,500-ft high moun... Tawang tract in Arunachal Pradesh being ceded by India, could pave the way for a settlement of the India-China boundary dispute, China's former pointsman for India Dai Bingguo has said.

The suggestion came in an interview given by the former Chinese diplomat and high-ranking communist cadre to a Beijing-based publication. Dai Bingguo headed the special representative dialogue with India for over a decade until his retirement in 2013.

Though the exchange of Tawang is far from being a simple affair given the presence of the Tawang monastery, which commands a special place in Tibetan Buddhism and is highly regarded by Buddhists in India as well, Dai's remarks are significant as they may not be completely without official sanction.

Dai is still regarded close to Chinese rulers, and his voice is taken seriously in the diplomatic community. He is unlikely to make sensitive comments in an interview unless it has been cleared by top leaders of the Communist Party, sources said.

The major reason the boundary question persists is that China's reasonable requests have not been met," Dai said in the interview, adding, "If the Indian side takes care of China's concerns on the eastern section of the border, the Chinese side will respond accordingly and address India's concernselsewhere."

Dai Bingguo has written on similar lines in his book which came out last year. China analyst Shrikant Kondapalli said the Chinese interest in the eastern sector had been elevated since 2005, when both countries signed the Political Parameters and Guiding Principles. China has eyed the Tawang tract, describing it as Southern Tibet, because the 15th century Dalai Lama was born there. Interestingly, China withdrew from that area after the 1962 war with India. Control of Tawang will consolidate China's hold over the centres of Tibetan Buddhism.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...of-arunachal-pradesh/articleshow/57438182.cms
 
Human by nature is very greedy.
Today you give them 1sq.km ,tomorrow they will ask for more.

Peace with China is not a possibility...not in the next 1 century. So let's not hope that any exchange of land would dawn peace on NE.
 
Human by nature is very greedy.
Today you give them 1sq.km ,tomorrow they will ask for more.

Peace with China is not a possibility...not in the next 1 century. So let's not hope that any exchange of land would dawn peace on NE.


What's left unsaid is the Chinese Maxim - what's ours is ours , what's yours is negotiable .

If you notice there's no mention of what they're offering in return .No mention of Aksai Chin or other territories they seized when Nehru was napping or pretending to .Just a bland ambiguous statement of considering to take note of Indian interests .

It's a red herring .More of a diversionary tactic .just to gauge the public mood over here & test the incumbent GoI's reaction to this non proposal .

P.S - ever since Trump has become president , the Chinese seem to be softening their stand a bit.After playing the unpredictable one in international diplomacy for a long time , they don't seem too thrilled to be subject to a dose of their own medicine .They seem to be laying the groundwork for more Sino Indian co operation in case Trump turns the heat on .I think the Chinese are very uncomfortable with Trump coz they can't seem to read him .
 
What's left unsaid is the Chinese Maxim - what's ours is ours , what's yours is negotiable .

If you notice there's no mention of what they're offering in return .No mention of Aksai Chin or other territories they seized when Nehru was napping or pretending to .Just a bland ambiguous statement of considering to take note of Indian interests .

It's a red herring .More of a diversionary tactic .just to gauge the public mood over here & test the incumbent GoI's reaction to this non proposal .

P.S - ever since Trump has become president , the Chinese seem to be softening their stand a bit.After playing the unpredictable one in international diplomacy for a long time , they don't seem too thrilled to be subject to a dose of their own medicine .They seem to be laying the groundwork for more Sino Indian co operation in case Trump turns the heat on .I think the Chinese are very uncomfortable with Trump coz they can't seem to read him .
Vacate COK...first.
Then we swap land with tibet.
 
Human by nature is very greedy.
Today you give them 1sq.km ,tomorrow they will ask for more.

Peace with China is not a possibility...not in the next 1 century. So let's not hope that any exchange of land would dawn peace on NE.

Lol Indians talk like they're not greedy :sick:, China has never recognized Mc Mahon's line and has never signed the unfair demarcation imposed by British but Indians toke that as for granted and as affaire classé...this is like a thief force you to leave your house, he then give your house to his friend so the thief's friend can come to tell you that your house belong to him now.

You should consider lucky that Chineses are not greedy as you claim, we could have selfishly divert all water in Tibet for ourself and let India NE in misery.
 
Human by nature is very greedy.
Today you give them 1sq.km ,tomorrow they will ask for more.

Peace with China is not a possibility...not in the next 1 century. So let's not hope that any exchange of land would dawn peace on NE.

It's not about greed. China is not asking for land from Burma. Why? Because Burma is not occupying Chinese lands. You are - so they want it back.

If anyone is greedy, it's you for not letting it go after British Empire collapsed!
 
Lol Indians talk like they're not greedy :sick:, China has never recognized Mc Mahon's line and has never signed the unfair demarcation imposed by British but Indians toke that as for granted and as affaire classé...this is like a thief force you to leave your house, he then give your house to his friend so the thief's friend can come to tell you that your house belong to him now.

You should consider lucky that Chineses are not greedy as you claim, we could have selfishly divert all water in Tibet for ourself and let India NE in misery.

Subcontinent Indians in history never ruled northeast area, those are conquered by the British. If there is no future war to settle this, viable solution I see is to split the disputed land half and half and demarcate the border, no more troops/military spending needed.

It's not about greed. China is not asking for land from Burma. Why? Because Burma is not occupying Chinese lands. You are - so they want it back.

If anyone is greedy, it's you for not letting it go after British Empire collapsed!

Agreed, British colonists conquered those land, subcontinent Indians in history never ruled northeast area, heck, the people there look like Chinese and are subject to abhorrent discrimination in Indian society.
 
Whoops, looks like a troll doesn't understand how rivers work:

http://cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/iucn_research_brahmaputra_basin.pdf

Dw5PSpC.jpg


NFUjWY6.jpg


Now lets see you do some quick math on how much of the floodplain total discharge originates from China. Try looking up a map as well :D

Never underestimate Chinese civil engineering, not only we can dig a long tunnel to divert Tibet water to Xinjiang to fix our dessert land but we can steal Indian Monsoon as I mentioned on my previous thread :lol:.

 
Subcontinent Indians in history never ruled northeast area, those are conquered by the British. If there is no future war to settle this, viable solution I see is to split the disputed land half and half and demarcate the border, no more troops/military spending needed. .

Nor did China, the people who ruled this area are today standing firmly with India, be it Ahoms, Manipuris, Mizos and Nagas.

Never underestimate Chinese civil engineering, not only we can dig a long tunnel to divert Tibet water to Xinjiang to fix our dessert land but we can steal Indian Monsoon as I mentioned on my previous thread :lol:.


This should go straight to stupid and funny from all over the world. :rofl:
 
Last edited:
Never underestimate Chinese civil engineering, not only we can dig a long tunnel to divert Tibet water to Xinjiang to fix our dessert land but we can steal Indian Monsoon as I mentioned on my previous thread :lol:.


So in essence you accept that the Chinese are common thieves and criminals indulging in subterfuge ?
 
This should go straight to stupid and funny from all over the world. :rofl:

it sound stupid for Indian but If China decide to clear a single tiny of the Himalaya and let Monsoon cross the Tibet like 50 million years ago then India will be over: Not only we will recover our Taklimakan desert with water from monsoon but India a waterless country.

v42n2-clift3en.jpg


So in essence you accept that the Chinese are common thieves and criminals indulging in subterfuge ?

In essence, India is not only friend of thief but conspirator.
 
Back
Top Bottom