What's new

'China did not expect India to give up so easily in 1962'

ChinaToday

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 31, 2011
Messages
4,557
Reaction score
-2
Country
China
Location
United Kingdom
NAGPUR: China did not expect India to give in so easily in the 1962 war, so much so that the People's Liberation Army (PLA) overran Indian posts and reached deep into Tezpur in the plains of Assam, said Colonel (retd) Abhay Patwardhan. He was delivering a lecture as part of a series organized at the Dharampeth College of Arts.

indiaf.jpg


Even fifty years after the war, scars of the debacle remain fresh and the ex-serviceman came up with some rare declassified documents related to the war. Addressing a small audience of mainly senior citizens, Colonel Patwardhan showed a letter citing an admission by then Chinese Premier Chou En-lai to a veteran journalist. Chou En-lai had gone on record saying Chinese leaders were surprised at the feeble resistance of the Indian Army.

Patwardhan, now a defence analyst, also showed a telegram shot off to US President John F Kennedy by Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, in which the latter pleaded for more help from the superpower. As the PLA was over running post after post, Nehru sent the frantic cable depicting the situation and asked for jet fighters and transport planes to stem the Chinese tide.

Nehru's telegram mentions India was grateful for the help it earlier received from the US. He says that Bomdila, the headquarters of North Easter Frontier Agency (NEFA), was already surrounded by the Chinese and Indian forces amounting to two divisions (18 infantry battalions) were fighting a grim battle. Nehru had expressed uncertainty about how many of them would be able to find their way back safely to the Corps headquarters in Tezpur. Nehru added for emphasis that the Chinese forces were heading toward Leh and there was nothing to stop them after that.

Patwardhan brought memories of the war alive with his presentation to an audience that might have only heard radio broadcasts as teenagers as that time. A 1971 war veteran himself, Patwardhan was 15 years old at the time. He also showed a picture depicting an Indian jawan cooking in a makeshift kitchen, showing how the Army was low on rations besides other equipment.

'China did not expect India to give up so easily in 1962' - The Times of India
 
.
I wonder why 1962 then 1963 Sino-Soviet relationship breakdown.Is that because of the Yellow Peril complex?
 
.
I wonder why 1962 then 1963 Sino-Soviet relationship breakdown.Is that because of the Yellow Peril complex?

Not quite, Stalin wanted to control China like it controled Eastern Europe. Stalin wanted to set up bases in China and asked China to give up nuclear program. Mao was pissed and wrote the famous "add beef after potato is roasted, do not fart" line. That was the end of the deal.
 
.
Not quite, Stalin wanted to control China like it controled Eastern Europe. Stalin wanted to set up bases in China and asked China to give up nuclear program. Mao was pissed and wrote the famous "add beef after potato is roasted, do not fart" line. That was the end of the deal.
I know the famous saying by Mao.
Stalin did not happy at beginning when CCP took authority in China,for he did know China potentially a super power could not be controlled some day.
 
.
NAGPUR: China did not expect India to give in so easily in the 1962 war, so much so that the People's Liberation Army (PLA) overran Indian posts and reached deep into Tezpur in the plains of Assam, said Colonel (retd) Abhay Patwardhan. He was delivering a lecture as part of a series organized at the Dharampeth College of Arts.

indiaf.jpg


Even fifty years after the war, scars of the debacle remain fresh and the ex-serviceman came up with some rare declassified documents related to the war. Addressing a small audience of mainly senior citizens, Colonel Patwardhan showed a letter citing an admission by then Chinese Premier Chou En-lai to a veteran journalist. Chou En-lai had gone on record saying Chinese leaders were surprised at the feeble resistance of the Indian Army.

Patwardhan, now a defence analyst, also showed a telegram shot off to US President John F Kennedy by Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, in which the latter pleaded for more help from the superpower. As the PLA was over running post after post, Nehru sent the frantic cable depicting the situation and asked for jet fighters and transport planes to stem the Chinese tide.

Nehru's telegram mentions India was grateful for the help it earlier received from the US. He says that Bomdila, the headquarters of North Easter Frontier Agency (NEFA), was already surrounded by the Chinese and Indian forces amounting to two divisions (18 infantry battalions) were fighting a grim battle. Nehru had expressed uncertainty about how many of them would be able to find their way back safely to the Corps headquarters in Tezpur. Nehru added for emphasis that the Chinese forces were heading toward Leh and there was nothing to stop them after that.

Patwardhan brought memories of the war alive with his presentation to an audience that might have only heard radio broadcasts as teenagers as that time. A 1971 war veteran himself, Patwardhan was 15 years old at the time. He also showed a picture depicting an Indian jawan cooking in a makeshift kitchen, showing how the Army was low on rations besides other equipment.

'China did not expect India to give up so easily in 1962' - The Times of India

And ? :coffee:
 
.
Very limited pictures of 1962 war here's a few 1962????[?]_?_ also have a picture of PLA feeding Indians that surrendered.
 
.
Yes, I also think Mao were surprised at the feeble resistance of india force. Then border force defeat the Principal force, no wonder Indian can't forget it!!
Just like 1840S, Only 20 British soldier defeat China. That's a shame!!
 
.
Yes, I also think Mao were surprised at the feeble resistance of india force. Then border force defeat the Principal force, no wonder Indian can't forget it!!
Just like 1840S, Only 20 British soldier defeat China. That's a shame!!

Our best forces during those days were stationed near the Korean Border and the Border with the USSR, we had experience in mountain warfare.
 
.
Yes, I also think Mao were surprised at the feeble resistance of india force. Then border force defeat the Principal force, no wonder Indian can't forget it!!
Just like 1840S, Only 20 British soldier defeat China. That's a shame!!
Just for quantity,differenc is that British soldier with advanced weapons and Chinese soldiers with bravery.
 
.
Just for quantity,differenc is that British soldier with advanced weapons and Chinese soldiers with bravery.

KMT had better weapons and more support then PLA during 1930-1949 however PLA still defeated them, however thats a different story.
 
. . .
Why didn't the chinese kept Aruchal/S.Tibet like they kept aksai chin. And since they gave it back why are they demanding it
now?
 
.
Why didn't the chinese kept Aruchal/S.Tibet like they kept aksai chin. And since they gave it back why are they demanding it
now?

According to Manmohan Singh, "China is trying to keep India off-balance". :lol:

Anyway, Aksai Chin is strategically important for us, much more so than Zangnan.
 
.
According to Manmohan Singh, "China is trying to keep India off-balance". :lol:

Anyway, Aksai Chin is strategically important for us, much more so than Zangnan.

I think China should have kept arunchal since you guys won it in Battle. And the people there look more like tibetans than
Indians.
And the area would have also given you guys direct border with almost all of Indian NE states.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom