Chabahar: Without Pakistan, there is no stability or growth in landlocked Afghanistan and Af-Indo

[BABA AGHORI]

No trade is possible through Afghanistan without the consent of Taliban and Haqqani network as they control 50% of the area. Indian goods will never reach Central Asia without consent of Pushto speaking areas so Pakistan's influence cannot be eliminated just like that. India will be a loser in this game in the long term.

Yes, you are 100% correct. But India does not need Afganistan to reach CAR. Pakistan might need Afg. Pushto speakers also need food to eat. There might be few attacks on the convey towards Kabul which is actually expected. But Taliban handlers will soon learn that there are convey on there side of the borders too. The game will be on. But certainly not on Indian soil.

 

[maravan91]

We could always help Trump invade Iran and destroy Indian dreams

You already helped USA to invade afghnistan. That doesn't end well for pakistan.

 

[truthseer]

You already helped USA to invade afghnistan. That doesn't end well for pakistan.

But this will. Iran is a threat anyway, get rid of them and get US+Saudi funding= WIN WIN!

 

[maravan91]

But this will. Iran is a threat anyway, get rid of them and get US+Saudi funding= WIN WIN!

In this scenario ,Like Afghans, Iranians will also develop deep hatred for pakistan.
Dollars from GCC,US wilĺ only hav short benefit to pakistan. In long term you will hav another enemy in your neighbourhood.

 

[BABA AGHORI]

But this will. Iran is a threat anyway, get rid of them and get US+Saudi funding= WIN WIN!

Cool, You can do it on your own and charge US+Saudi ... After all you have a huge capable force which brought down a superpower a few decades back.

 

[Awan68]

We could always help Trump invade Iran and destroy Indian dreams

Exactly, what these little indiot idiots dont realize are the ground realities n how Pakistan plays them, Iran however is not that stupid n understands that too well hence mark my words they will limit colloboration with India to a minimum, they only did in the past because Pakistani foriegn policy was completely pro saudi n anti iran, things have changed now n with that our foriegn policy...

Cool, You can do it on your own and charge US+Saudi ... After all you have a huge capable force which brought down a superpower a few decades back.

Well we did, no amount of jesting will change the fact so frankly mate stuff ur butthurt n talk future rather than pathetic attempts at undermining concrete history....

You already helped USA to invade afghnistan. That doesn't end well for pakistan.

If we helped them than why is 50% of Afghanistan still under a group that in common knowledge is directly known to take dictation from Islamabad, these things are way above ur head, indian.

 

[maravan91]

If we helped them than why is 50% of Afghanistan still under a group that in common knowledge is directly known to take dictation from Islamabad, these things are way above ur head, indian.

Which world you r living? How Americans entered Afghanistan and staying there more than 16 years. Who is providing logistics to US army man in Afghanistan.
Your influence in Afghan taliban started eroded the day your army started operations in NWFP,FATA under pressure from America

 

[Awan68]

Which world you r living? How Americans entered Afghanistan and staying there more than 16 years. Who is providing logistics to US army man in Afghanistan.
Your influence in Afghan taliban started eroded the day your army started operations in NWFP,FATA under pressure from America

, i would not debate geo politcis with an imbecile who doesnt even know the difference between ttp n afghan taliban, spend a few more years in high school kid....

 

[maravan91]

, i would not debate geo politcis with an imbecile who doesnt even know the difference between ttp n afghan taliban, spend a few more years in high school kid....

Its you who need to learn geopolitics. Afghan talibans r not that stupid. They know who helped Americans to overthrow their regime.

 

[Awan68]

Its you who need to learn geopolitics. Afghan talibans r not that stupid. They know who helped Americans to overthrow their regime.

 

[maravan91]

You can't deny facts

 

[truthseer]

Its you who need to learn geopolitics. Afghan talibans r not that stupid. They know who helped Americans to overthrow their regime.

The Indians?

 

[maravan91]

The Indians?

 

[truthseer]

Fake news

 

[kasper95]

@ why is Pakistan brought up in anything related to Chahbahar?



Would India give us a way through its country to trade with Nepal, Bangladesh and Myanmar?
Ofcourse not.By the time Pakistan starts doing it we would be blamed for providing support to the secessionists and commies and above all Muslims .

Indian had already proposed such a thing to connect all the sarcc countries ,Pakistan is the only opposing it.
We are not responsible for your assumtions.