Can India replace China as driver of world GDP growth over next 20 years?

[TaiShang]

Indian style governance is really wonderful for any career politician. You lose big time and continue not to deliver, and the elite (those who are literate and come from a higher class) will keep propping you up for system perpetuation.

As for the rest of the hundreds of millions of the illiterate, the visual media, which does not require much of a brain but a mother tongue to communicate, will keep them happily (or unhappily) ignorant.

The question is not really if India can become a driver of world GDP "over" the next 20 years. The question is not even the non-existent manufacturing chains, clusters, infrastructure, efficiency and quality labor force.

The question is the mentality. This, judging by this board, has not changed so far.

So, no, India won't be taking over in any qualitative way. Other [relatively] big population SEA states will be joining to contribute more to growth.

 

[Shajida Khan]

From Indian media, UN reports, BBC, CNN, New York Times, Indian posters, Chinese travelers, etc.

Yeah, judging from how you interpret them --like you read the quotes out of context-- it is not surprising that you are drawing wrong conclusion.

 

[Dungeness]

Yeah, judging from how you interpret them --like you read the quotes out of context-- it is not surprising that you are drawing wrong conclusion.

Those were headlines your media feeding Indians. What's wrong quoting them?

 

[Shajida Khan]

Bullshytter as their best, China this yr will add over 600 billions to their GDP compare to India add over 150 billions to India GDP, this yr alone China GDP outgrow India by a mile. Comeback and tell me when India GDP actually outgrow China.

And that 600 billions will only buy about 200 billion worth of (extra?) goods or services in China compared to India. Not saying India does not have a lot to do, but misleading comments like these are really funny.

Those were headlines your media feeding Indians. What's wrong quoting them?

Well it shows that you tend to be gullible for the starters and you do not look well in the matter before drawing a conclusion. Also, you do not read the whole article but just headlines.

 

[phancong]

And that 600 billions will only buy about 200 billion worth of (extra?) goods or services in China. Not saying India does not have a lot to do, but misleading comments like these are really funny.


Well it shows that you tend to be gullible for the starters and you do not look well in the matter before drawing a conclusion. Also, you do not read the whole article but just headlines.

If 600 billions only worth 200 billions then how much 150 billions worth compare to 600 billions?

 

[Dungeness]

Well it shows that you tend to be gullible for the starters and you do not look well in the matter before drawing a conclusion.

I did not believe a bit, based on your media's track records. It turns out, you guys are the gullible ones to even talking about superpower status. I read from different sources and talk to different people before I arrive my opinion.

 

[phancong]

India haven't surpass China in the real GDP term, illusion to think India surpass China in a near future.

 

[Shajida Khan]

If 600 billions only worth 200 billions then how much 150 billions worth compare to 600 billions?

150 billion in India will get you good and services worth of 300 billion if you had purchased in China.

India haven't surpass China in the real GDP term, illusion to think India surpass China in a near future.

What is 'real' GDP? Any sources to measure real GDP? Are you sure you are not confusing nominal with real. I know Chinese on this forum have shown a bit of incompetency when understanding the meaning of English words. See some of the posts by @Dungeness

I did not believe a bit, based on your media's track records. It turns out, you guys are the gullible ones to even talking about superpower status. I read from different sources and talk to different people before I arrive my opinion.

But surely you missed what was the real statement and went on harping about something which was either out of context or was simply not said! That is the very hallmark of a gullible person being easily fooled by spin doctors.

 

[phancong]

150 billion in India will get you good and services worth of 300 billion if you had purchased in China.


What is 'real' GDP? Any sources to measure real GDP? Are you sure you are not confusing nominal with real. I know Chinese on this forum have shown a bit of incompetency when understanding the meaning of English words. See some of the posts by

150 billions is worth 300 billions but 600 billions only worth 200 billions your perception of Vallue add to GDP is an illusion in in term of real GDP vallue in US dollar.

 

[Shajida Khan]

150 billions is worth 300 billions but 600 billions only worth 200 billions your perception of Vallue add to GDP is an illusion in in term of real GDP vallue in US dollar.

What do you think GDP measures? Hint it is not Dollars.

 

[Dungeness]

But surely you missed what was the real statement and went on harping about something which was either out of context or was simply not said! That is the very hallmark of a gullible person being easily fooled by spin doctors.

Nobody cares what ever real statement you are talking about. That was the message Indian government and media tried to deliver to the their gullible citizens, and hoped the rest the world would buy their story. In the process, they turned India into a laughing stock of the world, and people don't take you guys seriously anymore, you guys always over promise and under deliver anyway. Remember a viral video posted on Youtube, India in 2030? Or it is just another "Inspiration"?

 

[Shajida Khan]

Nobody cares what ever real statement you are talking about. That was the message Indian government and media tried to deliver to the their gullible citizens, and hoped the rest the world would buy their story. In the process, they turned India into a laughing stock of the world, and people don't take you guys seriously anymore, you guys always over promise and under deliver anyway. Remember a viral video posted on Youtube, India in 2030? Or it is just another "Inspiration"?

Huh! Did you know where that video came from?

HERE!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_(2010_Indian_film)

Read it and see how much of a gullible person you are if you take it seriously. It was edited from a Kannada movie from 2010! And there was a whole plot line about how Kannadigans in particular and Indians in general should work hard to achieve their dreams and how hopeless is their current situation if they do not work to improve it.

Think in this way, if I take clips from 90s hong kong movies about kung fu and Chinese martial arts movies and claim that Chinese are superstitious bunch who think they can fly by practicing martial art, will it make sense? I guess not. You are doing the same.

Lastly you want to see how else some Chinese are guliable? Read this thread from some days back posted in this forum itself. Chinese 'militray fans' claiming that they have discovered a substance which is 10-100x more energetic than TNT and is almost as powerful as a small nuclear bomb while posting quotes from a Japanese anime.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/chin...-powerful-than-tnt.474844/page-2#post-9408725

Look at the link below and see for yourself. Chinese military enthusiasts seem to have drunk the China shupa-powa kool-aid to an extent that even rules of physics do not apply to them.

 

[Dungeness]

Huh! Did you know where that video came from?

HERE!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_(2010_Indian_film)

Read it and see how much of a gullible person you are if you take it seriously. It was edited from a Kannada movie from 2010! And there was a whole plot line about how Kannadigans in particular and Indians in general should work hard to achieve their dreams and how hopeless is their current situation if they do not work to improve it.

Think in this way, if I take clips from 90s hong kong movies about kung fu and Chinese martial arts movies and claim that Chinese are superstitious bunch who think they can fly by practicing martial art, will it make sense? I guess not. You are doing the same.

Lastly you want to see how else some Chinese are guliable? Read this thread from some days back posted in this forum itself. Chinese 'militray fans' claiming that they have discovered a substance which is 10-100x more energetic than TNT and is almost as powerful as a small nuclear bomb while posting quotes from a Japanese anime.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/chin...-powerful-than-tnt.474844/page-2#post-9408725

Look at the link below and see for yourself. Chinese military enthusiasts seem to have drunk the China shupa-powa kool-aid to an extent that even rules of physics do not apply to them.

Made by Indian. It is all it matters.

China has been abused by just about every Indian members for "cheap" made in China products, just because some cheapskate Indian businessmen decided to buy low quality products from some unknown Chinese manufacturers. Every Indian here blames on China instead of dishonest Indian businessmen. Why should we spare you?

 

[Shajida Khan]

Made by Indian. It is all it matters.

How about 'Made in China' all that matters? isn't it?

BTW we don't even know who actually made that clip out of a movie. It was a random video on youtube/twitter. May be Indian or may be some random Pakistani's idea of a joke.

 

[Musafir117]

No for that Indian to be as Chinese