Can Afghan troops hold off the Taliban after Nato withdraws?

[Armstrong]

@Hyperion : Your opinion is needed ?

 

[OrionHunter]

khud hi post kar aur khud hi has terai ko kitni bar kaha hai youtube banned hai pakistan

Kya?? Abhi thak banned hai? Iss ka matlab hai ke tum log Hafiz Saeed aur Zaid Hamid ki chutkule nahin dekh sakthe?? Sheeesh!

 

[Hyperion]

They won't be able to handle half clothed Pygmies.

@Hyperion : Your opinion is needed ?

 

[OrionHunter]

we support afghan taliban

No wonder your country is where it is today!

 

[naseem shah]

No wonder your country is where it is today!

this current situation can only get better cant be more worst than it

will afghan taliban help in kashmir jihad

 

[OrionHunter]

this current situation can only get better cant be more worst than it

will afghan taliban help in kashmir jihad

There's a jehad in Kashmir?? Now why didn't I know that?

 

[INDIC]

they are locals thats why they have lost so many troops

Taliban kill 1,100 members of Afghan security forces in six months | World news | guardian.co.uk

@Sher Malang can put some light on this. But this time its extremely difficult for Taliban to take on Afghanistan.

Even Chinese are investing billions in Afghanistan, much more than Pakistan.

this current situation can only get better cant be more worst than it

will afghan taliban help in kashmir jihad

Also Kashmir is completely alien terrain for Taliban. But didn't some tell you America will stay till 2024 with their drone attacks in FATA.

 

[naseem shah]

@Sher Malang can put some light on this. But this time its extremely difficult for Taliban to take on Afghanistan.

Even Chinese are investing billions in Afghanistan, much more than Pakistan.



Also Kashmir is completely alien terrain for Taliban. But didn't some tell you America will stay till 2024 with their drone attacks in FATA.

THE Afghan government will collapse and Taliban insurgents are likely to retake power after the US and NATO pull their troops out in 2014, a respected international scholar has predicted.

The withdrawal of international forces will in some respects leave the country worse off than it was before a US-led invasion toppled the Taliban nearly 11 years ago, Afghan expert Gilles Dorronsoro of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace said.

"In the end the withdrawal is the result of a failed strategy," he wrote in an analysis published this week.

Even US President Barack Obama's troop surge, which pumped an extra 33,000 soldiers into Afghanistan two years ago - before they were withdrawn this month - had failed, he said.

"After 2014, the level of US support for the Afghan regime will be limited and, after a new phase in the civil war, a Taliban victory will likely follow," Mr Dorronsoro said.

@Sher Malang can put some light on this. But this time its extremely difficult for Taliban to take on Afghanistan.

Even Chinese are investing billions in Afghanistan, much more than Pakistan.



Also Kashmir is completely alien terrain for Taliban. But didn't some tell you America will stay till 2024 with their drone attacks in FATA.

and for drone attacks let next govt. come than we will see the drones

 

[INDIC]

THE Afghan government will collapse and Taliban insurgents are likely to retake power after the US and NATO pull their troops out in 2014, a respected international scholar has predicted.

The withdrawal of international forces will in some respects leave the country worse off than it was before a US-led invasion toppled the Taliban nearly 11 years ago, Afghan expert Gilles Dorronsoro of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace said.

"In the end the withdrawal is the result of a failed strategy," he wrote in an analysis published this week.

Even US President Barack Obama's troop surge, which pumped an extra 33,000 soldiers into Afghanistan two years ago - before they were withdrawn this month - had failed, he said.

"After 2014, the level of US support for the Afghan regime will be limited and, after a new phase in the civil war, a Taliban victory will likely follow," Mr Dorronsoro said.


and for drone attacks let next govt. come than we will see the drones

These are mere prediction, even province like Helmand is under ANA. While country like China see Afghanistan as a more attractive destination for investment compared to Pakistan.

If you stop America from targetting Haqqani network, its likely they will revenge Pakistan with different methods. Drone attack will stop only after the consent of Pak Army, not the next government.

 

[Iggy]

we support afghan taliban

Good for you guys!! Having dreams about Jehad in Kashmir with them huh?

The longer you support terrorism for helping your cause, the more your country heading for destruction.


Just think about it, who will Taliban prefer in neighbourhood??

A democratic government or groups who have same ideologies like them..

 

[Sher Malang]

@Sher Malang can put some light on this. But this time its extremely difficult for Taliban to take on Afghanistan.

Even Chinese are investing billions in Afghanistan, much more than Pakistan.

When you try to secure 80% of your country from active insurgents backed by world famous ISI you have to pay the price but the figures given by the dude aren't correct Taliban have long ago lost face to face battle with ANSF most of the causality is from our local police and national police forces who are ill trained and ill equipped especially on countering IEDs.

Gen. Richard Barrons also said roadside improvised explosive device (IED) attacks are the main motive behind increasing casualties of the Afghan security forces.

Afghan government officials last year also confirmed that over 80% of the Afghan security forces casualties are due to roadside improvised explosive device explosions.

When they have taken the responsibility NATO is relaxing now:

Monday, February 04, 2013 - Kabul—Up to eight soldiers with the NATO- led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) had been killed in Afghan war in January this year, the lowest casualty in a month over the past four years.

There is a realistic improvement in security otherwise all these countries would not have planned to invest billions in Afghanistan -

1) We had weekly suicide and bomb attacks in Kabul if your remember, but after security transition we have only had 6 fatal attacks in Kabul in 16 months!

2) Northern Afghanistan had become insurgents heaven highways were blocked but after security transitions insurgents were killed like rats today you seen no Taliban in northern Afghanistan except few who hides in their homes.

3) Western Afghanistan had also become Taliban stronghold even Herat city witnessed monthly suicide and bomb attacks but after security transition ANSF killed the culprits one by one and western Afghanistan is peaceful again.

4) Southern Afghanistan which remained Taliban stronghold since 1996 was cleaned by ANSF and NATO in 2011, Helmand and Kandahar is as peaceful as Herat today!

All this mess is now taken refuge in Pakistan bordering region which is eastern Afghanistan and soon by the will of god ANSF will turn those place hell for them.

NATO/US may have some political goals in this war but ANSF doesn't have any and they will not spare a single Taliban and will not have mercy on them!

ANSF have killed thousands of insurgents in 2012 if you need the list I have bookmarked all of them will put it here it was the pressure that scared the lower ranking Taliban and more than 5000 of them joined the peace process in 2012 only!

Long Live ANSF! Love Live Afghanistan!

 

[INDIC]

When you try to secure 80% of your country from active insurgents backed by world famous ISI you have to pay the price but the figures given by the dude aren't correct Taliban have long ago lost face to face battle with ANSF most of the causality is from our local police and national police forces who are ill trained and ill equipped especially on countering IEDs.



When they have taken the responsibility NATO is relaxing now:



There is a realistic improvement in security otherwise all these countries would not have planned to invest billions in Afghanistan -

1) We had weekly suicide and bomb attacks in Kabul if your remember, but after security transition we have only had 6 fatal attacks in Kabul in 16 months!

2) Northern Afghanistan had become insurgents heaven highways were blocked but after security transitions insurgents were killed like rats today you seen no Taliban in northern Afghanistan except few who hides in their homes.

3) Western Afghanistan had also become Taliban stronghold even Herat city witnessed monthly suicide and bomb attacks but after security transition ANSF killed the culprits one by one and western Afghanistan is peaceful again.

4) Southern Afghanistan which remained Taliban stronghold since 1996 was cleaned by ANSF and NATO in 2011, Helmand and Kandahar is as peaceful as Herat today!

All this mess is now taken refuge in Pakistan bordering region which is eastern Afghanistan and soon by the will of god ANSF will turn those place hell for them.

NATO/US may have some political goals in this war but ANSF doesn't have any and they will not spare a single Taliban and will not have mercy on them!

ANSF have killed thousands of insurgents in 2012 if you need the list I have bookmarked all of them will put it here it was the pressure that scared the lower ranking Taliban and more than 5000 of them joined the peace process in 2012 only!

Long Live ANSF! Love Live Afghanistan!

How are people in Afghanistan seeing 2014 when NATO combat troops completely withdraws from Afghanistan.

 

[KS]

But you forget, the Afghan National Army will have the support of the Brave Indian Army with them.

You are not suggesting that after NATO exits , Indians will turn their tails and run out of Afghanistan.

Not the Brave Indian Army. No the Courageous Indian Army will go in to help their Afghan partners.

Or are they going to Chicken Out as usual ?

Hi I learn that you are more than 50 years old

So use that to write useful posts

or

atleast join a comedy club to improve your sarcasm and humor. They suck right now.

===

Most likely, extremist elements will take over with the blessings of radicalism supporters and country will run back to choas while the supporters make merry and Afghani people suffer.

Only this time around the fire will not be limited to the west of the so called durand line but spread right across it.

 

[Sher Malang]

How are people in Afghanistan seeing 2014 when NATO combat troops completely withdraws from Afghanistan.

People living in cities whose lives are linked to US presence are worried and the rest see it very promising and they have started supporting their own forces that's why ANSF have so much success in a very short time we will be having challenges for another decade but that will be extremely good if Afghans take the responsibility and take this country forward by themselves.

 

[Pakistanisage]

Hi I learn that you are more than 50 years old

So use that to write useful posts

or

atleast join a comedy club to improve your sarcasm and humor. They suck right now.

Looks like someone stepped on your tail, Punk.......

a bit touchy there my little friend.

And speaking of humour, I am not seeing any Zingers coming from , Genius.

Same old "Sour Puss " comments that are getting pretty stale, bucko.