Musafir117
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2014
- Messages
- 9,613
- Reaction score
- -3
- Country
- Location
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
But you and many other Pakistanis justify the creation of Pakistan citing these incidents. In an undivided India, you could have still moved to now-Pakistan if you felt unsafe here so it baffles me as to why your lot keeps justifying the creation of Pakistan when you could have got the same thing in undivided India.
I am not sure how Nehru or Gandhi created insecurity for muslims because they always wanted a secular India with equal rights to all and that is how the Indian constitution has been written. So they stood for what they stated and believed.U should ask Nehru and Gandhi for that - They are largely responsible for creating insecurity among Muslims, eventually leading to creation of Pakistan.
Pre-1947, in undivided India, Muslims still would be unsafe from onslaughts of Sanghis despite migrating to Muslim majority areas because those areas would still felt the effects of all this just like South Indians are feeling the heat of North Indian hindutuva now a days...Why allow a certain religious group with certain interests of establishing its own power over others, only just because they had majority? This is where my forefathers disagreed.
My ancestors just wanted to avoid all this, thus, made the line and crossed the line. Leaving one's home, loved ones' graves is not a thing everyone can do. It takes real courage. My ancestors still campaigned for Pakistan despite living in areas which they knew, won't be joining Pakistan, yet they went for Pakistan. They were ready to migrate to regions which would be part of Pakistan. Fighting with Hindus/Sikhs despite living as minority in those areas is what courage is all about. If my forefathers hadn't got courage, Pakistan wouldn't have been formed in first place.
So, having a boundary is good as it affects people psychologically. People know that if they cross a line, then ...........
I am not sure how Nehru or Gandhi created insecurity for muslims because they always wanted a secular India with equal rights to all and that is how the Indian constitution has been written. So they stood for what they stated and believed.
Indeed South Indians are feeling the heat but they are giving a good fight and Sangh on more than one occasion were made to eat the humble pie. Were your fore-fathers not confident that you would be able to give that fight?
Sangh could have never dominated your present geographical area unless majority of the muslims of that area converted either ideologically or religiously to Hindutva/Hinduism. So what was the fear all about? Did they believe that their imaan was fickle?
Muslims in British India were around 25-30% and held power politically in the same proportion. Sangh wasn't a major worry then since Hindus mostly followed Gandhi and Nehru. So your forefathers demanding secession looks more like a folly. It would have made sense if your forefathers have asked of separate land if the Sangh was growing/grown powerful which wasn't the case then.
And if you think you don't have any threat, then you are mistaken. Yes I can see that you feel good now at least psychologically but your Government/Armed forces will still have to worry about an attack, hence the arms race. Let's assume Sangh is in complete control of India and orders attack on your country, you will still have to fight that threat and could possibly be on the loosing side. So your fore fathers creation of Pakistan hasn't guaranteed you safety which they have dreamed of.
I doubt it.Yaqeen kar...yar. Abhi roza se hun isliey lehaaz kar raha hun. These --------- would have had made our lives hell if our forefathers hadn't moved out...
What far-sightedness our fore fathers had...I salute them.
Guts to face it !Whose whining? I see you guys always trying to justify the creation of Pakistan citing these incidents. Hence I pointed out certain things unless you want to say that your ancestors didn't have the guts to face the Hindutva onslaught.
I doubt it.
We were seperate states,different culture,majority muslim,notorious,warlike & physically imposing frontier people.
Do they even try this in indian panjab?
Let alone in our regions?
If India was united all of Pakistan would be like KashmirBut you and many other Pakistanis justify the creation of Pakistan citing these incidents. In an undivided India, you could have still moved to now-Pakistan if you felt unsafe here so it baffles me as to why your lot keeps justifying the creation of Pakistan when you could have got the same thing in undivided India.
I keep constantly hearing about how your fore-fathers made the right choice, so just wanted to ask certain questions.
The land which is now Pakistan was always muslim majority, so do you think that these Sanghi loons would have dared to attack you in those parts?
So tell me what did you achieve with the creation of Pakistan?