Burma is for Buddhists

[Khalid Newazi]

Unfortunately Khalid, you can not decide what area remains with which country.
Rakhine remains with Myanmar.

Myanmar as a State does have the Sovereign Right to deprive people of citizenship and eject them. Which it is doing. All Bangladesh can do is either accept the refugees or reject them from your country.

Ofcourse, killing Rohingyas is illegal and one that can be taken up by UN legally.

Or, a freedom movement in Rakhine can be started and then free the people. Also Burma isn't a democracy, calling it one would be like calling North Korea a democracy (they hold elections). If you read the article it not only states the struggles of Muslims but others too.

Also there is no forced conversion in Saudi Arabia like Burma. There are plenty of Hindu, Christians and other religious minorities working there. They just don't allow religious institutions over there.

 

[Judge]

Or, a freedom movement in Rakhine can be started and then free the people. Also Burma isn't a democracy, calling it one would be like calling North Korea a democracy (they hold elections). If you read the article it not only states the struggles of Muslims but others too.

Also there is no forced conversion in Saudi Arabia like Burma. There are plenty of Hindu, Christians and other religious minorities working there. They just don't allow religious institutions over there.

No freedom movement against Myanmar can be started. China and India both have too much at stake in Myanmar to let another Islamic insurgency start right in a nation that borders both.
I didnt call Myanmar a democracy. I said it is the right of a Sovereign state to deprive citizenship should it want to. Therefore declaring the Rohingyas as non-citizens of Myanmar is legal. Consequently evicting them from Myanmar is also legal.
Only killing them is illegal.

 

[TopCat]

Unfortunately Khalid, you can not decide what area remains with which country.
Rakhine remains with Myanmar.

Myanmar as a State does have the Sovereign Right to deprive people of citizenship and eject them. Which it is doing. All Bangladesh can do is either accept the refugees or reject them from your country.

Ofcourse, killing Rohingyas is illegal and one that can be taken up by UN legally.

Where did you get this idiotic law?

 

[Judge]

Where did you get this idiotic law?

Every nation has this.
I can be made a non-Citizen of India tomorrow should the Government of India so decide. They have the authority by Law to do it.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

No freedom movement against Myanmar can be started. China and India both have too much at stake in Myanmar to let another Islamic insurgency start right in a nation that borders both.
I didnt call Myanmar a democracy. I said it is the right of a Sovereign state to deprive citizenship should it want to. Therefore declaring the Rohingyas as non-citizens of Myanmar is legal. Consequently evicting them from Myanmar is also legal.
Only killing them is illegal.

China has been funding insurgents in Myanmar, there are plenty of insurgency in Myanmar, a lot of them are Buddhists.
Wa Rebels to Send Fighters to China for Pilot Training: Reports

The Burmese government have been not only oppressing and killing religious minorities but also Buddhist tribes. Therefore there are plenty of rebels fighting the government.

India has no common border with Rakhine and it has to worry more about Buddhist rebels in the actual border India shares with Burma.

Burma is just a step away from becoming the next Yugoslavia.

 

[Judge]

China has been funding insurgents in Myanmar, there are plenty of insurgency in Myanmar, a lot of them are Buddhists.
Wa Rebels to Send Fighters to China for Pilot Training: Reports

The Burmese government have been not only oppressing and killing religious minorities but also Buddhist tribes. Therefore there are plenty of rebels fighting the government.

India has no common border with Rakhine and it has to worry more about Buddhist rebels in the actual border India shares with Burma.

Burma is just a step away from becoming the next Yugoslavia.

Yes, China did.
So has India supported factions in Myanmar.
Note - however that both India and China know the folly of letting Islamic militancy raise its head in Myanmar.

At the end of the day any freedom movement is not happening. Both India and China are giving arms, ammunition, aircraft to Myanmar Army and investing billions of dollars.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

Yes, China did.
So has India supported factions in Myanmar.
Note - however that both India and China know the folly of letting Islamic militancy raise its head in Myanmar.

At the end of the day any freedom movement is not happening. Both India and China are giving arms, ammunition, aircraft to Myanmar Army and investing billions of dollars.

Sorry to tell you this and your delusion neither India or China care about Rakhine. They know very well that the Rakhine millitias can't get inside India or China. There is a huge unfriendly land that needs to be crossed before entering either countries.

FYI just because Muslims rise to free their lands from non-Muslim invaders it doesn't mean militancy. Go preach your Hindutva somewhere else.

 

[ashokdeiva]

Indians, Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, and stupids thats what I can come up with. come on guys. Human Rights violation were ever it happens in the name of law, religion, ethnicity, color, etc has to be condemned. People who ask for revenge or death penalty do not understand that its not the solution.

 

[Judge]

Sorry to tell you this and your delusion neither India or China care about Rakhine. They know very well that the Rakhine millitias can't get inside India or China. There is a huge unfriendly land that needs to be crossed before entering either countries.

FYI just because Muslims rise to free their lands from non-Muslim invaders it doesn't mean militancy. Go preach your Hindutva somewhere else.

Its your call. Its not going to happen on the ground. You can keep wishing otherwise.

 

[ashokdeiva]

No freedom movement against Myanmar can be started. China and India both have too much at stake in Myanmar to let another Islamic insurgency start right in a nation that borders both.
I didnt call Myanmar a democracy. I said it is the right of a Sovereign state to deprive citizenship should it want to. Therefore declaring the Rohingyas as non-citizens of Myanmar is legal. Consequently evicting them from Myanmar is also legal.
Only killing them is illegal.

so India and China are sponsoring state terrorism, the way they did in Sri Lanka. For geo political reason these two nations will fun state terrorism against people who stand up and say enough is enough.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

Its your call. Its not going to happen on the ground. You can keep wishing otherwise.

Sorry to tell you this but Burma has no International supporter. At least not any that would fund them a major war that is most likely against inhumane acts.

 

[Judge]

so India and China are sponsoring state terrorism, the way they did in Sri Lanka. For geo political reason these two nations will fun state terrorism against people who stand up and say enough is enough.

India is no longer doing that. We have decided to make peace with whatever happens in Myanmar and not intervene unless the Govt of Myanmar asks for help - whether civilian or military govt.

Sorry to tell you this but Burma has no International supporter. At least not any that would fund them a major war that is most likely against inhumane acts.

If giving military aid - including tanks, weapons, trucks, surveillance aircraft and investing billions of dollars in a country does not count as International support, then I dont know what does.

Both India and China have been doing this and in violation of the International arms ban on Myanmar. Goes to show how much we are backing Myanmar.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

India is no longer doing that. We have decided to make peace with whatever happens in Myanmar and not intervene unless the Govt of Myanmar asks for help - whether civilian or military govt.


If giving military aid - including tanks, weapons, trucks, surveillance aircraft and investing billions of dollars in a country does not count as International support, then I dont know what does.

Both India and China have been doing this and in violation of the International arms ban on Myanmar. Goes to show how much we are backing Myanmar.

They are selling them (not aiding) and also a war in Rakhine involving Bangladesh will cost Burma a lot more. Not to mention our military is much more well trained than theirs. Also we will be fighting one font war, they are fighting at multiple fonts. We have plenty of Burmese Buddhists in Bangladesh and they would rather prefer to stay here than join Burma, thanks to Burma's championing in human rights (sarcasm).

There are plenty of Hans in Burma and China has itself claim over Burmese territories.

Burma is set to divide like Yugoslavia and it's just a matter of when.

 

[Judge]

They are selling them (not aiding) and also a war in Rakhine involving Bangladesh will cost Burma a lot more. Not to mention our military is much more well trained than theirs. Also we will be fighting one font war, they are fighting at multiple fonts. We have plenty of Burmese Buddhists in Bangladesh and they would rather prefer to stay here than join Burma, thanks to Burma's championing in human rights (sarcasm).

There are plenty of Hans in Burma and China has itself claim over Burmese territories.

Burma is set to divide like Yugoslavia and it's just a matter of when.

Are you joking? It is aid, not sale. No, it was not sale with a loan given by India. It was/is pure aid.

And Bangladesh will not attack Myanmar as long as India and China support them. As I said we will not let anyone threaten a country which borders us and one in which we have invested a lot and aided a lot.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

Are you joking? It is aid, not sale. No, it was not sale with a loan given by India. It was/is pure aid.

And Bangladesh will not attack Myanmar as long as India and China support them. As I said we will not let anyone threaten a country which borders us and one in which we have invested a lot and aided a lot.

Loans are not aid, loans have to be repaid. Also please give your source for the MILITARY AID India gave to Burma.